Latest Posts
One moment pls. Loading 10 latest posts...

23 January 2015

THE VIRTUOUS QUEEN OF HAN / 大汉贤后卫子夫 [TV][China][2014][R] Funn Lim

Written by Funn Lim


This series reminded me why I liked him so  before the singing and Karenas and all that scandals takeover. Raymond is not a bad actor and he can cry beautifully when he wants to. And when he doesn't scream as he cries, that's when he is an elegant actor.


SPOILERS ... SPOILERS ... SPOILERS



CHINESE TITLE
Literally, The Virtuous Empress of the Great Han Dynasty, Wei Zifu.

RELEASED IN
2014

NO. OF EPISODES
40

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN
Mainland China

LANGUAGE
Mandarin, all voices dubbed and usually dubbed by someone else. I saw the English subtitled version on TV but if you can understand basic Mandarin, this shouldn't be too hard as the level of Mandarin in the dialogue isn't too difficult to understand and the dubbers enunciated each word clearly.

CAST-CHARACTER
Wang Luo Dan as Wei Zi Fu
Raymond Lam as Liu Che
Niki Chow as Princess Pingyang
Xu Zheng Xi ad Duan Hong
Shen Tai as (沈泰) as Wei Qing
Chen Sha Li as Grand Empress Dowager Dou
Grace Yu as Empress Dowager Wang
Liu Ying Hong (柳影虹) as Princess Guantao
Zheng Miao Zhi (郑淼之) as Chen A Jiao
Li Xin Cong (李欣聪) as Shen Jia
Liu Yong (刘永) as Liu An
Peng Guo Liang (彭国梁) as Yi Han
Yang Zi Jiang (杨紫茳) as Xia Hou Po
Zheng Si Ren (郑斯仁) as Han Yan
Zhang Ya Xi (张亚希) as Huo Qu Bing
Miao Hao Jun as Ai Shu
Zhang Xu (张绪) as Bai Hao
Wang Meng Li (王萌黎) as Yao Ji 姚姬
Xu Jing Kun as Wei Chang Jun
Fu Tao as young Chang Jun

EPISODIC COMMENTS
I made some comments about this series in my blog with spoilers. 

STORYLINE
About the rise of a lowly dancer who became one of the longest serving Empress in Chinese history. Be rest assured as with all dramatisation of a real historical figure, huge liberty taken with the real story.

COMMENTS
I will be first to state I seriously enjoyed this series. It started out unconvincing and there were many times I fast forwarded all the flashback scenes and repetition scenes and certain characters talking scenes (mostly Duan Hong who always looked drugged, dazed and tortured and of course the ultimate villain whose scenes you can fastforward and still manage to catch up on the story). As it goes on, the story falls into a pattern and yet it is surprisingly entertaining and very emotionally evocative mainly because you follow the characters from they were young and unknown until for some characters, their untimely deaths and so on and so forth. I became quite emotionally invested, but not as much as I was in Schemes Of A Beauty. There is similar pattern between the two, mostly in depicting the vast powerful Han Dynasty and downsizing it into a family. Now in TVB we often see that and often the Emperor and Empress and concubines are all so downsized, it never felt like a dynasty. Not in this series. Even if the emperor is a father, empress is a mother, etc etc you never forget that father is an emperor in a great dynasty known as Han dynasty. It is an intimate portrayal of a very vast and powerful dynasty. Of course something's gotta give and it is the actual history that is sacrificed. Certain real facts were changed, endings were altered but who are we to know what happened 2000 years ago eh? The story begins to build up and in the end a climax that is both scary and realistic in a familial settings because like I said, the husband is the emperor and anything can happen. The final ending for some characters are bittersweet but what makes this series so enjoyable is in TVB series, the women are marginalised into the concubine who scheme, the men are portrayed as the officials who also scheme and the emperor with the ultimate power never felt like an emperor with the ultimate power. Not in this series. In here, we have strong female characters, even if they do live by the unthinkable code of "husband is always right" and here even if we have decisive men, these men are quite emotional. Most of the time it is the women who have more self control. No doubt this series is more about women than about men and for a series whose title is about the lead character called Wei Zifu, she is a rather bland character most of the time. Luckily she had great supporting characters which made her character a little more interesting than she should ever be.

Anyway, first the women...

WEI ZIFU
From the very start I feel this character is seriously bland. Some will term her as Mary Sue which is not incorrect. She is not perfect as a person as she has her stubborness and her flaws. She seems perfect as a wife when in reality she is actually a wife who has to hide her own feelings because she married the emperor. She seems like the best sister there is and no doubt she loves her family, especially her half brother Wei Qing more than she could ever love anyone, including herself. She is like the best possible empress ever because she believes wholeheartedly in harmony within the royal harem, she strives to keep everyone in check not by force (she will have you killed if she really had to and the fact she had to means you must be the scum of all scums), she hardly is every angry, she is very very careful with what she says, what she does and how she conduct herself and she makes sure the emperor is worry free so basically she doesn't tell him everything. In other words, she is close to perfection as a person or maybe someone who is so good at playing mind games and politics. Her character captured the emperor's attention by her beauty but mostly for her political opinion which she will rarely express after she goes into the palace as a concubine. This series made it perfectly clear she is innocent of all charges, so whatever bad things that happen to her or because of her or due to her, she is the most innocent party of them all because she doesn't know what happened and why her. Now most of the time this will make for a very irritating and so easy to hate character but surprisingly I don't hate her. For all her perfection, the few times she lost control of herself were the times that is really the most interesting; like how she was poisoned and lost her senses and for once screamed at the emperor and her stupid mother (yeah! best moment!), how she squared off wit Empress Chen over the disappearance of her brother Wei Qing, how she lost her patience with a concubine and tried to defend herself against the emperor's stupid suspiscion (come one Mr Emperor, don't you know, she is always blameless and it is not sarcasm on my part, she is truly blameless!) and how in the end she marched out of the palace with style and into the prison to free her best friend in life, Duan Hong and then walked back into the palace to square off with the emperor who was becoming very emotional, almost like a girl which of course is stereotyping but you know what I mean. But can you see it? You can actually count how many of such great moment for this Zifu to act out of character because when she is in character, she is basically so in control I am sure she times how much oxygen she breaths in before she exhales. She is not a control freak but she lives in dangerous time so she has to be in control if not she will die. All these adds up to her being the virtous queen and you may scoff at the word virtous and all but the scene where she faced the guards and talked her way to the prison to face Duan Hong and many times the emperor sided her are purely because of her virtousness. She is a woman who proves she walks the walks and talks the talks and don't judge her by what she says but judge her by her actions. So basically the character is on point even if at times I just wish she is more woman than virtous perfection.

I WAS THINKING ...
Sex with her must be quite a  non-event! But he finds her desirable enough to have at least 3 daughters and 1 son. Of course virtous means conduct not her womanly appeal. I just wish at some point she stop being so understanding to the emperor and just show him her temper, which she did  in her own spectacularly underwhelming fashion in the end where she is clear minded although the best was when she was poisoned but that doesn't count. And like I blogged before, everybody just love to hate her, including her husband until his common sense came back to him.

BEST MOMENT
A few such as how she reasoned with the guards who let her walk past them despite the emperor saying she can't leave her chamber  which explains why for so long in the series she is so virtous, all culminating in these series of scenes or her outbursts when she was poisoned but most memorable had to be towards the end when she cried "Since my husband does not believe me, what have I to live for?" and she ran towards the sword drawn by Liu Che and next we see blood spilt! Very dramatic stuff and at least, a change of character for this bland character.

THE PERFORMANCE
Wang Luodan. She isn't the prettiest but she does have a kind gentle ancient beauty face that fits the title character. Just don't talk about aging because aging in this series is represented by moustaches and redder lipstick. I thought she gave a fine performance to which I can't complain much. If I find her bland, that is because her character is bland.

IN HISTORY
If you watched Schemes Of A Beauty, you will be introduced to this character at the end of the series. If you're watching Songs Of The Desert, I believe she is played by Maggie Cheung Hor Yee. In real life, she exists. This series changed her fate in the end. She had a happy ending in TV but in real life, her ending was very sad. She was the 2nd longest serving Empress but her end was, she sided with her only son who chose to revolt against his father the emperor and in consequence, she was about to be stripped from her title when she killed herself. Her son was cornered and murdered and most of her clan was too. This series doesn't show all that but it does show a theory why she ended up such a sorry state. In the series the bad guys could get to her by planting seeds of doubt in the emperor's mind about her love for him only when Wei Qing died, her nephew Ho Qubing died, the princess Ping Yang and her entourage of friends all left the palace and Zifu was all alone. In real life, perhaps the emperor could get to her because all her support and ally in the form of family died and she outlived her usefulness and the emperor's love. Sad, very sad. If you're in such a position of power, better to die early and remembered fondly by the emperor because that is the only way to preserve your clan's survival. An early death will preserve all those perfection that was never there. Unfortunately she outlived two of her most powerful allies, her brother and her nephew, both who were great generals that the emperor depended heavily on.

GRAND EMPRESS DOWAGER DOU
I remember this character from 2 versions; Han Wu Da Di and mostly Ruby Lin's Schemes Of A Beauty. This Empress Dowager Dou is however neither of the two. She is shown as a formidably scary blind but clear eyed woman who is smart, sassy, forceful, respectable and yet clear minded. She has her mistakes but in the end everything she did was to preserve Han Dynasty so that in the end she can give this dynasty to her grandson, our hero Liu Che. She is not without her faults. She loves her niece too much because she loves her daughter too much and because of that she spoilt both of them which ended with I suppose tragic circumstances. She steps on Liu Che to ensure he doesn't rise above her, not because she was malicious as we are made to believe in the beginning but because she felt he was not ready. If he can't handle her alone, what more of those corrupted conspiring politicians. Basically she gave him good training. Her death left a void in this series for a little while because this character was so all encompassing in all aspects of this series. Even in the end her influence is there when Zifu begged the emperor to spare the empress Chen's life and later to see Empress Chen for one last time. It is also realistic as she cried very hard as she realised her end is near. Nothing graceful but not ugly either. She may look like the villain but as the series goes on, it shows she is not a villain but a woman tasked with a difficult task; to keep the dynasty from the hands of invaders and dirty politicians and to hand it to her grandson who she hopes is not corrupted by ideologies of others but have his own opinion that must first and foremost work for the dynasty and not for himself.

BEST MOMENT
For me it was when she curtly reminded Liu Che Empress Chen's title as empress is not for him to strip. The power, the authority and all that from a woman who is also old and blind. Who says in ancient times women were meek eh? Not in Chinese dynasty!

Also her last scene with Zifu where she begged Zifu; "I want you to promise me, no matter the wrong did to you, you will do all you can to ensure Empress Chen lives. I know after my death, Empress Chen will be in danger, but more so from the one person I know who will be the one to kill her; Che er (the emperor). I know this is too much to ask of you, but I can see you are kind and generous and with your attitude you will soon be an empress. Will you promise me?" and of course Zifu did and it took a few more years I believe before she had to carry out her promise.

THE PERFORMANCE
Chen Shali. I was complaining about the ultra red lipstick at first but when she was sick and dying and without the red lipstick, I really missed it because the red lipstick represents her vitality and the fact she is dying means I am gonna miss this mecurial character. It is not the best ever performance, she is not very convincing as a blind woman but I truly enjoyed her authority, her power, her assertiveness which this actress very convincingly portrayed. You can understand why Liu Che loved, respected and dreaded her all at the same time.

IN HISTORY
This woman existed and she was indeed blind for a better part of her tenure as the most powerful woman in the dynasty and she outlived her husband and her son. She was I suppose the defacto ruler and if history is to be believed, she is akin to Kangxi's grandma but more forceful; meaning she assisted, she guided, she raised the children, she sorta ruled but she didn't try to usurp unlike Wu Zetian. I quite admire her, blind, a woman, widow and all and still she managed to live I believe into her 70s (really old wayyyy back then) and keep the dynasty together whilst I am sure fending off hungry wolves. What is there not to admire about her? Maybe she was as scary as the actress who interpreted her in this series, she has to be, she can't be meek like how Zifu is portrayed and still survive. After all Zifu had her powerful scary husband and who this Dou had?


EMPRESS DOWAGER WANG
This is the meek mother of Liu Che whose best moment was after the death of Empress Dowager Dou, she sat alone and began to cry, not with sadness but with relief and happiness. At last, at long last she was free from the clutches of the powerful and domineering mother in law. Life must have been very hard for her. Well, once she was free, you will expect her to be a bit wiser, no? Like poor people who suddenly get very rich, what do you do? Spend! Same with this woman, once she is free from domineering mother in law, she herself chose to be the domineering mother in law, acting unjustly towards poor Zifu like taking away Zifu's children, imposing her will on how to manage officials on her son and insisting on the death of loyal subjects like Duan Hong. Of course she was misled but it does show the huge difference between her and Dou. Dou was harsh, she was domineering but she exercised her power with wise discretion although at times her hands are tied. This mother however with so much power tend to not only misuse but totally and carelessly misuse them on the wrong people! Exciting moments in this series. Luckily she realised she was an idiot and her death scene was one of the hardest to watch because it was a death filled with regret. Basically she died a very sad and regretful woman thanks to her decision which destroyed Princess Pingyang's happiness for quite some time.

BEST MOMENT
That moment where she threatened her son to either kill Duan Hong or she kills herself. Emperor, famous for being filial basically said to his mother he will make sure she will be buried with all the rites and grandness!! So funny! Yeah she deserved that wake up call.

THE PERFORMANCE
Grace Yu. Fantastic. THe actress looked the part of a meek mother turned crazy mother in law.

IN HISTORY
She existed. And quite an interesting woman as well.

PRINCESS PINGYANG
She will have my vote as the strongest female character in this series and perhaps one of the strongest in any series ever. She has her moments of jealousy, stupidity, unreasonableness and all those imperfection but for me, she is the wisest of them all and the most human. Zifu for all her down to earth qualities is hardly human in my book, Dou was larger than life, the mother was just silly, those concubines stupid but Pingyang could have existed and I would have wanted to be her best friend. At the time when there is chaos and stupidity, she was the voice of reason and luckily her brother, that is Liu Che listen to her counsel. Sure she blamed Zifu for destroying her happiness, but who wouldn't in a way resent Zifu for the fact that her brother gave up his love of the princess to protect his sister? She should know and she does know she is always 2nd to Zifu in Wei Qing's heart. As years go by she lived with the fact that she and Wei Qing would never be together and when she found out why Wei Qing let her go, she reconciled with him and was gracious enough to honour his wife with very kind  words when the wife died. She was classy, she was smart, she was sassy and if she had been a man, she would have been a wise emperor. She doesn't let her heart rule her mind and yet she doesn't forgo her conscience and what her heart tells her despite the facts to the contrary. She was the first to speak up for Zifu and when the emperor said he has evidence, she said "I don't care about the evidence, I believe her with all my heart and all my soul". She married 3 times; 1st out of duty and she ended up in her way loving her husband who wasn't ambitious and wasn't smart but doted on her and let her have her way, the 2nd out of necessity since she has to remarry but it ended up her biggest mistake which she quickly corrected by telling her brother the truth about her useless husband which may sound heartless but this is a woman who doesn't dwell in small talks and her 3rd husband was her true love whom she spent the happiest of days but tragically for a very short time. Her ending was bittersweet, and I feel for her but in her own way, she is a survivor. She needs to live to protect her husband's memory, her husband's children, her husband's mother in law and her husband's biggest worry, his sister. A very purposeful life and I am very happy to watch that never once did she ever consider killing herself to be with her husband. In her own way, Princess Pingyang is as selfless as Zifu, at times I feel even more selfless.

BEST MOMENT
Many. One of the best and most entertaining characters, her best moment were with her brother. I love the scene where she explained why she believes Zifu despite the gossips. I love the scene where she advised her brother on whose son should be crown prince despite the fact that at that time she was having cold war with Zifu (as usual Zifu doesn't understand why the princess hated her). I love how she warned Li Furen and I definitely love the very sad scene as she cried very hard when her 1st husband died in her embrace. What I don't get is why she introduced that Li Furen to her brother, that makes no sense.

THE PERFORMANCE
Nikki Chow, who obviously delivered her dialogue in Cantonese. The first great fortune is her voice was dubbed because I don't think it would have worked with her original lazy tone voice. This voice was strong, regal and really suited her face. I did not quite like how unsteady she was; like most HK actresses in China ancient series portraying someone powerful or daughter of someone powerful, their heads tend to move too much. Case in point is Myolie Wu who by moving her head too much fails to show the elegance of a character. Nikki at first moved too much, her body bend over too much. Just look at the actress who played Zifu; still and steady. Nikki's Pingyang was a highly trained princess so it was disorienting at first. However her movement became lesser, maybe because her headgear was too heavy for her. Anyhow that was when she got better. Firstly, her character is great so it will be hard to screw up such a strong character. Secondly, whenever she is not required to be too emotional and be a little bit mischevious, Nikki more than filled the description. I think this is one of her best performance todate and she has a lot to thank for in terms of the voice dubber and the writing. But credit goes to her for her emotion on her face and the way she manages to seem so intelligent and 10 steps ahead of everyone. However my problem with her is she doesn't give me an impression that she is a princess, I find her lack of regalness that is not helping her. It took me a while to see her as a princess of high birth.

IN HISTORY
She existed, was the emperor's favourite sister. She did marry Wei Qing, she did marry 3 times, she did adopt a son (and so openly doing so for a woman of her background is admirable), I don't think she had any children like in this series and whilst I don't believe she would force her opinion on her royal brother, I believe in some ways her relationship with the emperor was truly one of  loving siblings. Other than that I don't know much about her.

EMPRESS CHEN
Sometimes I wonder why this woman is so jealous. I got very tired of watching her jealous and temper tantrum and so when she was deposed, it was good news. Her end was near anyway when Empress Dowager Dou died. In a way this series depicts her downfall is thanks to her mother. The emperor may not love her anymore but he never gave any indication he will strip her off her title even if he doesn't go visit her sexually or otherwise. Sometimes I do pity her. She craves for the emperor's full attention. She doesn't mind the other concubines much but with Zifu she minded because she knew the emperor was in love with Zifu, hence all the things she did. She wasn't right and her ending was lenient for all that she did but yes I do feel the emperor was unfair to her as a husband to a wife. She later died in the arms of Zifu when the emperor refused to see her one last time and she laughed a little as she thought the irony of it all; that she should die in the arms of the woman whom she had hated and yet who has shown her kindness when no one bothered to.



BEST MOMENT
She learned humility when she begged, with genuine sincerity for Zifu to help persuade the emperor to spare her scheming mother's life and to take hers instead. Rather moving. I was also hoping the emperor will see her one last time but that would be a sell out to the usual stubborness of the emperor who has always been slow to forgive his enemies so I do think whatever portrayed was consistent.


THE PERFORMANCE
Zheng Miao Zhi. Very prettty, love the headgear (sort of) but the hair a bit too Korean for me. Hers looks especially Korean. Performance is rather good but I feel she is too young for this role because she never ages. In real life the empress was I read 8 years older than the emperor and was childless. This actress however looks far too young for this role even if she is nt 8 years older.

IN HISTORY
She existed. Apparently she was every bit as scary as she was depicted in this series. She was the "kiu" in the "Kam Oak Chong Kiu" where story has it Liu Che built her a chamber of gold for her to stay (which you will see to great effect in this series). But that saying in modern times now mean a man keeping a mistress. Not sure how it evolved into this modern saying. I think she was probably luckier than Zifu in the sense she lived out her life in seclusion, she wasn't killed or anything.


PRINCESS GUANTAO
The mother of Empress Chen and the most favourite daughter of Grand Empress Dowager Dou, this woman is haughty, arrogant, trouble maker and above all else, loves her daughter very much. Unfortunately she did all the wrong things and taught her daughter all the wrong methods in winning the emperor's heart. A sad end but she planted the seed of disdain by the emperor to the empress and in the end nurtured the hatred that caused Empress Chen to die deep with regret. Basically she really is something, this woman.

BEST MOMENT
One of the best if not the best scene in this series that I will choose also for the Emperor Liu Che which is the confrontation scene between Emperor and his aunt with the empress in tow. The princess knew she got caught and instead of displaying humility and being very truly sorry for what she did, she argued with the emperor about merit, about how she helped him, etc etc. The emperor grew increasingly angry as the princess became increasingly fearful. Stuck in between are the historians tasked as the emperor put it, to write what happened and to put the records straight. So we have the princess shouting "Historians!! Write all these down!" and the emperor screaming "Historians! You shall all that I say! WRITE! WRITE ALL THAT DOWN!!". It became a battle of wits, wills and authority where the emperor finally displayed his emperor like behaviour that basically forced the terrifying but humbled princess into submission. Excellent scene.

THE PERFORMANCE
Liu Ying Hong. I remember her as a Hong Kong actress but I can't pinpoint which series. I am often distracted by her silly Marge Simpson hairstyle but frankly nothing silly about her performance. She is well dubbed and the voice suited her even if she definitely spoke cantonese. She played the mean spirited mother of the empress with panache and her performance deserves a praise even if her character goes nowhere but to the abyss of the emperor's hatred. Seriously after a while it gets  a bit tedious with her scheming non stop and teaching her daughter all the wrong things.

IN HISTORY
She existed (but can't find an individual page for her) and from what I can understand, wielded considerable authority. Named Liu Piao, she was the older sister of the previous emperor. Not sure what happened to her though.


SHENJIA
The faithful friend turned maid turned sister in law of Zifu. Not much to say except her ending was sad and admirable.

THE PERFORMANCE
Li Xin Cong. Not much to say. She was effective. And I was waiting for her to die so that Wei Qing could marry the princess and she didn't die until much much later.


WANG FUREN AND LI FUREN


Both concubines (Wang Furen on the left, Li Furen on the right) managed to capture the emperor's heart and both died for different reasons and different method. Both as stupid and both were means to an end by the ultimate villain.

IN HISTORY
Both existed, one more celebrated than the other. History was changed for Li Furen  (Consort Li) who was poisoned whilst pregnant in the series. In real life she didn't die, her grandson became the emperor. I believe the same Li Furen is in Sound of the Desert portrayed by Fala Chen.


THE PERFORMANCES
Two of the worst female performances in this series.

Next, the men ...


LIU CHE


Emperor of China, the emperor famous for his defeat of Xiong Nu and known as the military emperor so to speak because he spent a lot of years in war. Of course this series shows he delegates the war thing to his trusted generals and aides and rules from his palace and he is a very busy emperor. He is not perfect. He is young and handsome and also lusty and easily falls for tricks and lies. But the good thing about this emperor is he is also not stupid. Given a bit of quiet moment he will figure things out and he will seek the counsel of people he trusts, such as his grandmother the powerful grand empress dowager Dou and his sister, Princess Pingyang, arguably the wisest people in this series who are both wiser than him at times. He is also smart enough to not seek his mother's counsel who proves herself to be rather stupid. He wants to be filial and often times almost makes decisions that would have been very wrong even if he was filial. He is a fighter that is ready to fight for his loyal aides but most of the times will fail not because he didn't try but his loyal aides would think of ways to assist the emperor even if it means by their death. He has good taste in who should be Empress and even if at times they argued like any couple would, for better or for worse as depicted in this series, he is a caring father, a loving husband and a good son. He is also a good leader who will listen but when he has had enough of listening, he will not hesitate to be very harsh to protect the people he loves. He gets jealous too and this would prove to be his weakest point but in the end, he is lucky he still has the counsel of his beloved and wise big sister who will not hesitate to tell him, tactfully where he gone wrong.

BEST MOMENT
The fighting with his mom where he declared "Mother, it is the tradition of the Hans to be filial but I will refuse to be filial if it will cause the death of my most loyal aide. Please forgive me but if you insist to threaten my authority with your death and demand for the death of my most loyal aide, I will promise you I will bury you will all the rites and honours as shall befit you after your suicide"

Ding!Ding!Ding! Knockout!

Another was his fighting with his aunt, with the increasing shouting match of "HISTORIANS!! RECORD ALL THAT DOWN! EVERY WORD! WRITE! WRITE!!!!"

Also that scene where he was fuming about the so called affair between Zifu and Duan Hong and he was angry and alone in the hall sitting on his throne when someone announced "Grand General Wei Qing seeks counsel" and by that time Wei Qing was dead and it was repeated and the emperor in anger shouted "WHAT UTTER NONSENSE! WEI QING IS DEAD!!!" and well it was Princess Pingyang carrying Wei Qing's armoured dress into th hall to square off with the emperor. He looked taken aback.

And many smaller scenes such as when he laid a trap for the stupid Wang Furen and his very stern decision which sounds cruel but I feel is wise; he definitely sides his empress more because as he said it many times; "The Empress has proven herself to be kind and virtous".

THE PERFORMANCE
Raymond Lam. He spoke mandarin and the guy who dubbed his voice sounded like Raymond except Raymond doesn't speak such fluent Mandarin. Perfect voice and compliments Raymond. But how was he you asked? Raymond these days have a lot of bad habits; bulging eyes, dramatic move of his head, overacting, chok all the way, those you can see in Line Walker. But in these settings, it works but it also helped he kept things to the minimum. At first you can see the chok stuff but as the series went on, as he gain a moutasche then a beard, he lessened his movements and kept them to a minimum. He lets his eyes do the talking and he has got very expressive eyes. This series reminded me why I liked him so  before the singing and Karenas and all that scandals takeover. Raymond is not a bad actor and he can cry beautifully when he wants to. And when he doesn't scream as he cries, that's when he is an elegant actor. In this series, he also has to be authoritative. I didn't believe his emperor aura at first until he had his moustache and many scenes he had to display this complete authority over someone and he did remarkably well. There was no hesitation, there was no wavering but just pure power radiated from this man that at times you wonder, will he kill that person on the spot or will be spare them? He is almost believable as a loving father, almost believable as a loving husband but he did better as the lusty emperor and the jealous husband eager for assurances that his wife, Zifu loves him and only him. His best was his display as a reasonable man. He didn't do so well as a young emperor but he did much better as an older emperor who wants to have control, who has control and who at all times remain in control even if there were some scenes you wonder, has he lost his mind. What is great about Raymond's performance in here is his ability to convince me that people could fear him, loath him, love him and bow to him. I feel this is one of Raymond's best performance todate and it takes a great voice dubber and Mainland China to remind us all how much potential he had when he was much younger. You can forget about the substandard and OTT Line Walker. Any Raymond fan must watch this series even if his character is at times hard to like.

IN HISTORY
He existed and quite a bastard to his wives. He came from a prolific line of emperors, where his grandpa was known to be a benevolent Emperor, so was his father whilst he was quite scary. You can google Liu Che or Emperor Wu of Han. He ruled for 5 decades and as with long rules, in the end he became quite mad. So before you believe whatever is said in this series, do keep in mind in the end he forced Zifu to kill herself. I do think Raymond portrayed a much gentler version of this not so gentle emperor.I went to his father's tomb in Xian, China and it was an experience I never forgot. Everyone must go to Shih Huangdi's tomb, no doubt but if you are there do drop by at Emperor Jing's mausoleum. It is much quieter, fully air conditioned, some very interractive stuff but the best was you walk on top of the burial chamber and you can see the excavation and creepy dolls. Creepier because the place is literally empty, it is chilly because air cond on at full blast and you are reminded this is a burial chamber! You can also see cute looking pigs and cows and what nots. I feel the museum is one of the best organised museum and you can see the curator must be very proud of it. Still excavating though so if you go now maybe more things to see.

GENERALISSIMO WEI QING
Half brother of Zifu from a different father and they love each other the most. Whatever either party do they do it for the other party. Wei Qing spent his entire life protecting his sister, even on his deathbed. Started out as a servant then a stable boy and because I don't know how but he knew Kung Fu thanks to Duan Hong, and because he was smart and a capable leader, he rose ranks quickly as he won wars after wars. He remained humble and well liked. He fell for the Princess Pingyang but decided to let the love go because the gossips surrounding them was destroying the princess' credibility much to the annoyance of the princess who spent I think the next decade thinking he did it for his sister, he married Shen Jia not out of love but grew to love her over the years. Her sad death caused him to lose himself for awhile until he recovered and in his later years he married the princess but died of his internal injuries he suffered in war which was aggravated when he was attacked by masked assassins. He never saw his sister for the last time before his death.

BEST MOMENT
Not much but the best was his last where he begged the emperor that no matter what his sister did wrong or is accused of doing wrong, "please treat the merits I have earned from my faithful and loyal service to you as your repayment to me on my sister" and the emperor promised until of course he forgot about that not much later. Also a scene where he vommitted blood but he had to go to war for the emperor and his wife Shen Jia begged him not to but he said something very true; "I am who I am today thanks to my sister but the higher I climb, the more I need to cling on because now I have to remain where I am for my sister. I need to earn this merit to ensure her position, her son's position is secure".

THE PERFORMANCE
I didn't notice him in the beginning but age and moustache suits him perfectly and he does look honourable. However he was too small to be convincing as a powerful general. No complaints about the acting but the looks is rather unremarkable.

IN HISTORY
Definitely existed and very prolific. Not sure how he died though or what age he was when he died.

HUO QUBING
Major character in history, if he had lived long enough maybe as or more prolific than his uncle but died young as depicted in this series. I didn't find him remarkable at first and he had very few scenes but as the series went on, you see Qubing as someone very young but very capable. He is rash and at times acts before thinking but he is a passionate, playful and mischevious guy that walks around with a glint on his eyes like he is up to something. Noble, helpful and caring, he protects his aunt and he has no problem going straight to the emperor to tell him as it is. In this series he was a sickly child and he died from an undiagnosed heart ailment all of a sudden. It was quite shocking because one minute ago he was so full of life and playing pranks on his aunt Zifu and the next he was dead and took them quite some time to realise this time it was no prank.

BEST MOMENT
I can't speficy one since I like the character but he isn't given much time to truly develop.

THE PERFORMANCE
Zhang Yaxi. Not Eddie Peng for sure, no sex appeal like Eddie Peng and I suspect no six packs like Eddie Peng but he has the same mischevious look as Eddie Peng. This actor may be small in stature but he has a face that is perpetually up to something mischevious and playful. So for me the performance is on point.

IN HISTORY
Existed, very prolific and died very young, like early 20s, before his uncle from some illness. Whether he looks like Eddie Peng or not is debatable. Anyway this is the same character you will see in Sound Of The Desert but more prominent (one of the 2 male leads) but name is changed thanks to party spoiler that is China's censorship board.

DUAN HONG
Childhood friend and love of Zifu, he was in love with her all his life and he almost had both of them killed because of that. Loyal to the Emperor, loyal to his friends and all in all a really nice guy except for that face you wanna punch. I mean he is a good looking guy but why wanna punch him? Because this guy does not understand the meaning of moving on with life, forever wallowing in his unrequited love for Zifu which is really irritating because he always looks so sad, so morose, forever in mourning over something. Other than that, he is a really nice guy.

BEST MOMENT
I suppose his almost last scene where he was dying of poison and he asked Zifu tearfully I think whether she had ever loved him and she admitted if she never enter the palace, she would have married him and had a simple but happy life and he tearfully cried "Thank you" because he thinks she is lying for his sake but I think she is telling the truth and the emperor was nearby listening but he wasn't jealous or anything; after all Duan Hong was dying.

But no, he didn't die. His hand got chopped off, he left the palace finally and in the forest at night, in the middle of nowhere he met a girl that is a very panda looking (aka tired) Michelle Ye in a gueat starring role as some creepy keeper of an inn who resembles his Zifu in some ways and who invited him in. If there is a sequel, she probably drugged him, robbed him, chopped him up and served his meat in cha siew bao. Yes, the entire setting was just creepy. Anyway at least he found his big dipper star which is what he sees Zifu as.

THE PERFORMANCE
Xu Zhengxi aka Jeremy Tsui aka Nikki Chow's boyfriend and they had like 3 scenes at most and never any dialogue with one another. Good looking guy, tall, supremely thin with such a morose face that I wanna punch and an exaggerated way of speaking his lines whilst his lips is pursed, something like a Japanese animated series. Not a bad actor, just the character is yeah yeah someone I wanna punch.

IN HISTORY
Don't think he existed but maybe an embodiment of someone the real Zifu might have known as a child or when she was a dancer.


UNCLE YI HAN
Gifted fortune teller turned murderer turned fugitive turned chef turned Elder of Han turned charity worker. He was saved by the young Zifu as he laid dying from starvation and later met her again as a chef and quietly helped her to gain favour of the emperor. As for his ability as astronomer and fortune teller, they have no correlation with his duties in the palace. He is more like a friend and to provide some comic relief.

BEST MOMENT
Can't think of any. Enjoyable character but nothing stood out.

THE PERFORMANCE
Peng Guo Liang. I recognise him as a ke-le-fe HK actor who is suddenly given this very prominent role and he did very well. No complaints.

IN HISTORY
Figment of storytelling.


OTHER CHARACTERS
Many characters come and go and some around for a long time. Such as the ultimate villain whose name I can't remember but the actor is 9th prince from Yong Zheng Wang Chao and the kindly eunuch in The Glamorous Imperial Concubine who took a long time to die. He was good even if his character is just illogical. Then there the deceitful uncle of Liu Che whom I remember was the father of Ruby Lin in The Glamorous Imperial Concubine. Also got this weird man dressed as a woman who is the "sister" of the same sect with the ultimate villain's girlfriend who has a passion for belly dancing. And many more. Some were more competent than the others. None too terrible.

OTHER NOTABLE STUFF
THE COSTUMES
I do love the costumes. Nothing so amazing that jumped out like in Songs Of The Desert where royalty really looks like they dressed like royalties but for what it is worth, the costumes were very nice, especially those on the emperor. 

THE HAIRSTYLES
The hairstyle is a different matter. Not as cumbersome as Beyond The Realm Of Conscience ...



which most looked like helmets, 

In this series, some do looked too made up and too korean style. Zifu's pearls for jades crown were overkill. I quite like Princess Pingyang's headgear towards the end but still look rather clumsy. But the shiny gold must be complimented, like the mega OTT crown for Empress Chen which was so shiny...




But I feel it is too much for that dynasty. I don't know, I just thought they aren't accurate,  no one ever will and most aren't very Han like to me.

PASSAGE OF TIME
You won't see the passage of time in women but for the men,  I was most impressed with the men's moustaches and beards. They all look good with it and as there were flashbacks from the past, suddenly you see the difference in the passage of time.







MISSING SCENES
However probably due to budget contraints we never get to see how mammoth was the funeral for Qubing or Wei Qing and the series does confine itself to the palace whilst the war scenes were bare minimum. It doesn't feel limited though; it does feel like a palace like I said at the beginning because we have an Emperor who acts like an Emperor who happens to be a family man with many wives.

VERDICT
There were times I just fast forwarded a whole chunk because it was repetition and it concerned characters I didn't want to watch. I missed nothing. The main stars are the Empress, her Emperor and perhaps Princess Pingyang, the 3 most worthy characters to watch. The Empress by herself is terribly boring, nothing much ever eminates from her, she is like the little rabbit that everyone protects, and yet the hawks keep attacking and she never knew why she was target, why she is so hated, etc etc. You can say she is wide eyed most of the time but towards the end she wisen up and made some tough decisions even if it goes against her Emperor. No doubt this series took pain in explaining the virtous part but it never fully explained how a starving young girl ended up at the Pingyang mansion, how she knew how to dance so well although we can assume Princess Pingyang trained her. The start of the love affair with the emperor was cold and calculating and purely sexual. I never got the feeling she loved him at first but she had to since she is virtous and he is her husband. As for the emperor, I believe he grew to love her over the years. There are a lot of jumps in time and suddenly she has nephews like Qubing etc etc. Too much time is spent on Empress Chen and her deceitful ways and Duan Hong and his unrequited love. But luckily this series balances all those unnecessary in excess with some fine performances that grabs you. The passage of time, although unmarked except for deaths and moustaches and some costume changes is felt in the sense that you see the characters grow old and die one after another. History is changed but for once, I like that it is changed for a happier end and some a bittersweet end. In real life, Zifu had it worst.

Watch this for the costumes, watch it for Raymond, watch it for Nikki Chow who grows in confidence as the series goes on and on and watch it for the fairytale ending which we know in real life never happened that way.

Highly recommended.

FUNNY OBSERVATIONS
You can see Raymond looked exhausted towards the end of the series with his red eyes. I don't think Nikki Chow ever spoke Mandarin for her lines. Hers very consistent with Cantonese dialogue. For such a rich dynasty as with all the gold, Empress Chen hardly had any costume changes. And you will see the same black/white flag meant to announce death of someone important quite a lot towards the end, always the same shot. And you will see the same shot with the guards standing guard on the stairs, like the exact same shot. For a series so much about politics, it rarely shows the emperor ever in discussion with his ministers (apart from Duan Hong and Wei Qing)  about politics. And don't hope for war scenes. Budget all gone to clothings!


SOME RECOMMENDATION
If you wanna watch the fictionalised lives of the real historical figures in this series, watch these;

Grand Empress Dowager Dou - Schemes Of A Beauty
Huo Qubing - Songs of the Desert
Liu Che - Han Wu Da Di



Share:

LINE WALKER / 使徒行者 [TVB][2014][R] Funn Lim

Written by Funn Lim

Main reason is because Sharon (Chan) was god awful


SPOILERS ... SPOILERS ... SPOILERS




Released in
2014

No. of Episodes
31

Cast
Michael Miu
Charmaine Sheh
Raymond Lam
Sammy Sum
Sharon Chan
Elena Kong
Benz Hui
Oscar Leung
Samantha Ko

Stefan Wong
Patrick Tang
Ankie Belkie
KK Cheung
Toby Leung

and more.

The Story
One cop sent out 5 cops as undercover at various section of society and one day he supposedly jumped to his death. Before he died he confided in his good friend, a fellow cop about the 5 undercover cops but before he could reveal their identities, he died. So now this friend of his has to find these 5 undercover cops to work with them to bring down the biggest triad in HK whilst protecting their identities and evading investigations and allegations that he is a corrupt cop by ICAC as well as threading the line with another sworn enemy, the O-kei.

Episodic Comments
I posed some of my thoughts with spoilers here by episodes. You will find more plot points there.

COMMENTS
It started sort of silly, a bunch of mad looking gangsters with huge knives and bats and what nots chasing after 2 very well dressed (in black if I remember correctly) Charmaine and Raymond (Lam, not Wong, not Cho) and they pledged their love for one another as one seeks death as a resolution and the other proclaims there is a way to survive and zoom, back to I believe 9 months or so ago. I don't believe it was even a year ago. The trouble with TVB is their flashback is usually a year or less and in light of so many episodes later, I kinda wonder, all these in less than 1 year? Woahhh... brutal world. When it comes to UCs and spies and moles and traitors, I do think maybe 3 to 5 years will justify all the pain, anger, heartache and fear. The series was still so good when we are introduced to an enigmatic Hong Sir who unfortunately died just 2 episodes into the series and the entire series thereafter is basically about a character very much talked about but dead since forever. I felt sad for Hong Sir but it should have been more. I wished the series took its time to establish Hong Sir who is the emotional string that binds all the UCs. In fact all of them have nothing bad to say about him at all but for him to die so soon and then so many minutes wasted on 2 couples, one of whom is just a complete waste of space is an injustice to what this series could have been. Which is slightly better than what it ended up becoming. Even then with Hong Sir's shocking but untimely death, the story shifted to an equally enigmatic Cheuk Sir who is one of the 2 men who is the glue of this series. I can even take Hong Sir's love story and all that lovey dovey stuff because this series has a  kick ass villain in the form of the even more enigmatic Chum Foon Hei, the triad boss of Hung Ying triad. All is well and great, even if I had to sit through in total disbelief that Chum Foon Hei is basically surrounded by close men who, 4 out of 5 are traitors whereby 3 out of the 4 are UCs. But still, all is well until the story shifted to our young hot couple who kisses every episode, that is Kobe and Yan. And then it became worse and worse as the series tries to create an intricate web of conspiracies and betrayals that all ended being half baked and just silly before tragedy strikes where the veterans all die (except for Cheuk Sir who escapes that fate because he is only 40 therefore not quite a veteran) and then we are left with angry, disappointed young ones who either suddenly gone rogue and gone mad or gone missing or just simply gone. Of course some episodes later before the ultimate end, some young ones had to die and yes, one died but is totally unrelated to the UCs and moles. Frankly, this series died for me when Chum Foon Hei died. He was such an all consuming character that made me guess, is he good, is he bad, what makes him tick, why he is the way he is without any answer until the end. So all consuming that in the end when he died, when he shot himself to save the cowardly Bao Seed, whatever happened next until the end were just totally crazily mad bonkers. All the series ever wanted was to shock and the story, the consistency, the pacing, the integrity to the basic premise was thrown out the window for the purpose of style. For a series eager to showcase its youth and vitality, to modernise certain aspect, many of the storyline is really very very traditional and old fashioned.

Which is why in my blog writeup for this series, I thought the out of this world premise would have worked excellently in an ancient settings in a Wulin world or a world with dirty eunuchs and scumbag politicians in a dynastic settings where a minister is hell bent in discovering why his sworn blood brother was murdered and where the moles and UCs are. It would have been an excellent ancient series. They don't even have to change the dialogue, except changing English words to Chinese words. It could be Ming dynasty or really old Qin Dynasty, whatever. Unfortunately, it is set in modern times and as the series progresses, you can't deny the writers have balls since they criticised and theorised about bad cops as well as white collar crimes and drug dealers and what nots. And yet I have a hard time believing Escobars of the world would want to deal in real estate and retired respected politician like Chung King Fai will deal with such obviously in your face dubious character when the writers could have balls of steel to show the real bad guys as politicians from that particular political party in Mainland China. Now that would have gotten my respect and I would have forgiven all those stupid silly agonising love story between the main characters. But it didn't go that way. I do think though if this series had gone beyond the ending and give it maybe 5 more episodes, maybe we will find out Chung King Fai's big boss is from China and then that big boss from China in another 5 more episodes had his moles and spies in the White House. I mean it seems to be heading towards bigger and bigger revelations as it became more and more "mo lei tau".

And that's when I realise until the very end, our Cheuk Sir never managed to properly arrest anyone except in the end he managed to arrest Chung King Fai and himself. Yes, the ultimate sacrifice. His turn to the dark side was so predictably fake, especially when Bao Seed or someone accused Cheuk Sir of not understanding the life of an UC since he was never an UC and guess what? He became an UC not long later! Shocking? Nahhhh, expected. By the time I don't really care. Not after seeing Kobe laying on a chair as he manipulated the share market in no less than an abandoned house. Imagine if this was in ancient setting, Kobe would have been laying dying in an abandoned temple and using pigeons as his "laptop" to manipulate some general's order or imperial edict or whatever. It was just so funny to watch but it quickly became really stupid when Yan came along and for a man who could hardly push himself up to look at the laptop, could not somehow run away from Yan to hide from her. A perfectly capable healthy woman can't even chase after a half dead coughing blood and probably hungry sick man (his loaf of bread was on the floor, unopened for days so I assume he must not have eaten at all). Theirs was so supposed to be the love story of the century, but in the end it was just pain of the century for me. Did I mention  how Yan seems to take all things personally and finds anyone who didn't do anything her way as a total disappointment? Like everything is about her and in the end I am left scratching my head why both Kobe and the dastardly Yip Sir fell so deeply for her? Must have been the perfect hair and long shapely legs. This series took pains to exploit that to such an effect that I wonder, what's the point again?

Talking about perfect hair, everyone has perfect hair in here and is hardly ruffled despite running, crawling, shooting, hacking, hiding and even extreme grief. It just felt so unreal. But no more unreal than the actual job of being a UC. 

Of all the UCs, Bao Seed had the most believable UC role but even in the end when he became Hung Ying's leader, one wonders shouldn't he by that time have access to enough evidence to make some arrest? But then by that point, no one probably remembers what Hung Ying does in the first place. For a triad, it does everything. From small stuff like betting to drug dealing to real estate to ... sushi restaurants and of course money laundering to basically everything. Hung Ying is one triad that does not discriminate whatever illegal activities they do as long as it serves the plot and it is illegal. His ending was so super ridiculous. His identity as an UC is breached and yet in the end he is still an UC. But if this was set in ancient settings, well you can say he shot down all pigeons and so the secret identity is still safe in another town. But in the modern world of google, youtube, Facebook and Twitter, it is impossible.

Then there's the other UCs. 

Sis Deng perhaps has the 2nd most believable UC except her job could easily have been done effectively by an informer. She runs a foot massage business and is more businesswoman with some legal ethics than an UC. In fact I wonder why she bothers to be a UC. JUst quit and be a thriving business owner. 

Kobe has the best hair, look, wardrobe, car, everything and he even manages to leave USD20 million (or is it HKD? Whatever.. loads of money) for his ultimate one true love, Yan when one wonders, shouldn't he hand over that money to the police? After all who paid him his start up capital? If Bond had to handover his winnings in Casino Royale, why is Kobe keeping his? In fact why is Kobe an UC when he is such a financial whiz kid, he could have just quit, become a stock broker or trust fund manager or whatever and become so awesomely rich, legally. I don't get it. Poor man even had to go to jail to get close to Chum Foon Hei but let me speculate a bit; he was tried and convicted of either Criminal Breach Of Trust or fraud. Why is he allowed to even trade in stock market? Shouldn't those Commercial Crime Bureau of equivalent investigate him? I mean he can't even run a company, be an accountant, etc. Unless of course HK is different.

Ada of all the UCs was most pitiful and had a pitiful ending. She died before the series became incredibly stupid.

But Miss Lam, the scary PA of James Pong, one of the main bad guys before we reach the upper echelon of bad guys except we are never told his connection to the rest of the bad guys, she reminds me of a haughty harajuku girl than a woman so scary, even Bao Seed fears her. Well she died, horribly, not sure who killed her and the writers don't care either. Her story of betraying the UCs and Cheuk Sir is half baked at best. By that time everyone knows everyone is respectively a UC or mole and yet, not one killing. The most unbelievable was Sis Deng's ability to work with Miss Lam who was the singular reason why her 3 moms were shot so brutally that really shows me this series has lost its plot. By that time it has lost its plot for many many times. When the emotional aspect could be milked and some girl on girl fight most justified, nothing happened. You get that short fight some time later, but for the wrong reasons. I wished Sis Deng had exhibited her spunkiness when it comes to Miss Lam but this series suddenly shifted to her being a politician's assistant... yeah, like what? Huh? Really?

Makes no sense. 

For a series that started about a kind handler with his 5 missing UCs, it in the end became an absolute mess.

No doubt, you my dear reader probably disagree with me and feels this series is TVB's best for 2014 because it is so exciting. Take out the excitement which is scene per scene and I wonder, do you still feel the same? Do you feel excited about Bao Seed's sudden madness and his sudden recovery? Sis Deng's sudden philosophical approach to her identity when she was one who exhibited the least philosophical approach? Did you not see Flea and Kobe dying like miles and miles away? Don't you wonder about Foon Hei's background and the stupid ending scene where his UC file was erased and you wonder, where did that come from? Why can't villains be villains and good guys be shady? Why must Foon Hei in the end be an UC too? And what about that embarrassing implied sex in an ambulance between two people so bandaged, they can hardly move their hands more so remove their pants to have sex? I mean after so many episodes of so much tragedy, shouldn't this series end on a mature note instead of rewinding to step 1, cue the childish cutesy music and cutesy expressions and cutesy expressions? So many deaths, so many lies, sometimes you can't just go back to the way you were. Innocence are lost, sometimes a more subdued ending would have heightened the ending rather than that stupid ending.

The only good ending was Cheuk Sir and wife but even they had some silly moments.

PERFORMANCES EVALUATED
There are some major players in here and considering how extensive the story tries to be, naturally it has lots of actors consists of veterans and ... more veterans. I mean I consider Charmaine and Raymond veterans.

Michael Miu
I suppose you can say this is his best performance todate, except I do think his performance in L'Escargot as the hardworking older brother (albeit he was too old for that role) was to me his best performance. He is to me not the best actor in TVB. He never was. But what he lacks in acting, he made up for his good looks that look younger as he grows older (which give proof to growing old gracefully), his height, robust physique and in this series, he shows he can be as dubious as he is persistently honourable. Frankly never quite believed his Cheuk Sir ever went rogue but that aside, he really is the 2nd saving grace of this series. By the way Tony Leung Ka Fai was supposed to be in this series and I bet as this character which would have been awesome either way.

Benz Hui
He is to me such a surprise casting for a role that requires him to be at first scary, then remorseful and finally pitiful only in so far that as a viewer, you sympathise with him. It is such a success because in the end you still know so little about this enigmatic character. Why did he quit being a cop? Why did he do what he did? Erase that stupid ending where his file as UC is erased. That is an afterthought and it is stupid. Taking away that one moment of stupidity, his Chum Foon Hei like Cheuk Sir are the 2 most consistent characters in this series. Whilst the story revolves around Hong Sir with Cheuk Sir as sidekick, Benz has an awful lot of screentime and I thank the power that be for that. When he laughed, it was scary. And yet in certain scenes you get a sense that if he wasn't the bad guy, you will like his jovial nature. After all, his name does mean Seeking Happiness. His final scene was rather sad and Benz handled that so well, I immediately missed his character. When the young ones took over the mantle from the veterans, frankly speaking they were all inadequate. For this, if there is a Most Favourite Supporting Actor, Benz has my vote. In fact he should be the TV King because TV King shouldn't be about Most Favourite Lead Actor but rather, the best actor with the most impact to a series, story and character of that given year and Benz Hui definitely fits that definition.

Jimmy Au
As Hong Sir, he has very few scenes but his character is one of the most talked about character, next to Chum Foon Hei. The actor looks honourable and good natured enough for this role. In fact I have seen him as a cop way too many times. I would have wished he had more scenes to build up the affection with the viewers but I suppose the series was in such a hurry to introduce the younger actors as UCs. For me his early death never quite balance well with the rest of the story, more so when the rest of the story was filled with such useless plot and unimportant character development.

Chung King Fai
His character is silly in a way, too short since he was introduced so much later but ever since Will Power, I can really see him as the ultimate villain.  I suppose gravitas is needed for such an important role and it is supposed to be important. After all he is the top of the food chain of villainous characters, all the UCs are after that merits our main guy Cheuk Sir becoming a UC himself. Unfortunately, much too late, much too short even if his final confrontation scene with Michael was well acted even if it is frustrating to watch; after all, for all the capabilities of the women, at the end of the day they are reduced to damsel in distress. 

Oscar Leung
One word; awful. His performance never quite gel it for me. It felt forced, it felt unreal and it felt so put on. His antics, his behaviour, even his god awful way too long death scene was annoying. There can only be one actor who can do sidekick well and that is Jazz Lam. Oscar was like a poor imitation of Jazz Lam in King Of Comedy and mind you, that was a comedy, that was a Stephen Chow movie and that was Jazz's debut acting ever. He is not helped with the fact that his character was basically nothing to do. If he had been UC, it would have made better sense. If his death scene was better handled, it would have made better sense. The only time I ever liked his character was when he attended his grandma's birthday bash. Those personal moments which unfortunately was not meant to enhance his character but rather pave the way for some flashback scene when he died so that the viewers can see how BFFs he is with his Bao Seed Gor and Deng Jeh. I feel so disconnected watching Oscar and kept wishing Jazz would show up except he showed up in All That Is Bitter Is Sweet.

Stephen Huynh/Stefan Wong
The actor with many names. At some point he must win Most Improved Actor because he has improved a lot. He is believable as the crooked businessman named James Pong except the problem is not much is known about his character. Where did all the time fly? Well, certainly not in establishing his James. But overall, a convincing performance.

Patrick Tang
Not the best actor around but his character is intriguing except again we know zero about his character in the end except he is a dirty cop. Pity.

KK Cheung
Nothing much, but make up is convincing.

Elena's husband
What's his name? Convincing as the ultimate bastard husband.

Foon Hei's son
Not sure what is his name but deserving of an honourable mention. I thought the kid had spunk. Unfortunately he had to die so tragically and in a way that is totally avoidable.

Sammy Shum
What a deliciously handsome man. That's where my compliment ends. Not his fault. I mean he has improved in his acting and many said he is winning the Most Improved. Well, not for this atrocious series I hope. He was far far better in his villainous role in All That Is Bitter Is Sweet with the same premise of longing for the girl he can never have except in this series, he did get the girl but then the tumour got to him. Yeap, tumour. In the dangerous world of white collar crime, imprisonment, gang war, drug war, and all wars, in the end he died of a tumour. So K-drama and was hoping Yan will die with him, but no such luck! I always thought Sammy is a star in the making. He has all the qualities; flawless look that is probably TVB's only answer to Wallace Huo in terms of HDTV durability test, he is young, he has a moldable face that can play any character (even gwailos because he looks mixed at some angle), he has a good voice and clear diction (maybe too clear diction, he can at times talk one word at a time) and yes, kissable lips. And this guy can kiss. Unfortunately, he is a tad short so he isn't Michael Miu but he has the talent, the looks and the charisma. His only major problem is his acting talent is still lacking behind his charisma. What I mean is this; he has the stage set up for him, but he still can't quite step on it yet because he has yet to have the skills to go with that talent. In time he will gain that skills, he has the potential and his performance in All That Is Bitter Is Sweet will convince you of that (oh please, not this performance though). Still needs a bit more "cooking" time. But in here, I am sorry to say, the character is poorly written. His Kobe comes across as delusional, destructive for love and just all round wimpy. When he died,  I was applauding. That's the end of one suffering, whether it is his or mine is up to interpretation. 

Raymond Lam
He started so well. I have waited so patiently for the Raymond I once knew but somewhere along the way when the drama is heightened, so is his chok-ness. It is still the same "new" Raymond that I am beginning to despise. He was ok in calm moments and as the street smart Bao Seed. But he was terrible as the grieving Bao Seed and the absolute worst when he has to grief, angry, hurt, pain and cry all at the same time. Maybe it does remind me of the old Raymond, the one who debuted many years ago and was so opera-ish in his performance. One of the worst performance in here and  to think many fans are hoping he gets TV King. I'd rather Lawrence Ng or the exquisite Vincent Wong in Tomorrow Is Another Day winning than Raymond Lam.

Elena Kong
I never truly appreciated her. I always felt she was always so haughty in her performances and I am sick of her older woman-younger man storyline. But in here, she is well matched with Michael Miu and she has the boasting point of saying Michael kissed her on the lips, at least 3 times and I think he even nipped her on the nose once. How many times have you seen Michael kissed an actress, let alone nipped her nose? They share this amazing chemistry but at times I wished she did more in terms of touching him. There was a tender scene where she told him to ask her to marry him, that she is ready and she was gingerly touching his face I think, or her hands were on his shoulder. I wished she had sat on his lap, kissed him on the cheek and cupped his face with both the palms of her hands. I wanted more intimacy but Elena seems to hold back herself. Her performance as the battered wife was absolutely convincing. Whatever your personal opinion about battered wives who chose to stay with their husbands, you gotta admit that performance was absolute perfection; the begging, the justification, the pain, everything. The make up was convincing. Her hair was the only one that reflected her predicament. However in the need to connect all characters, she was made into a prosecutor and then we are told she married not too long ago so how she became from feared prosecutor to battered wife is not justified long enough. The timeline should be longer. Other than that, I do think she was stunning in this series and frankly I would have given her the TV Queen title, same justification why I will give Benz Hui because TV Queen shouldn't be best lead actress performance but should be best actress performance.

Charmaine Sheh
Not her best performance because An Herbalist Affair was her best. Not her second best because HSDS was her second best. You can this is her third best performance, and she has improved a lot since Time Off which was a long long long time ago. I know a lot of fans is hoping she gets TV Queen and between her and Linda Chung, I'd rather Charmaine but between Charmaine and a whole lot of other performnaces we have yet to see? Like Josie Ho, like a lot more? Let's wait and see. Standalone, Charmaine gave it her all and frankly the director used her to the hilt. She had to do everything in here, even sexual innuendos and outright sexual scenes apart from drama, comedy, cutesy stuff, annoying stuff, etc etc. Everything rolled into one. And guess which one she did best? Those that require her to act smart, making decisions with her wit, those still moment. I always thought Charmaine can handle a strong character that does not need to have a man next to her. She can be the Empress who rules over the harem and I believe she will be convincing. Unfortunately as in this series, at some point she is cast as the helpless damsel in distress or the shrieking mourning crying banshee. Mean words you think? Some may think the scene at the hospital where she had to mourn her 3 mothers' death was her best, I thought it was her worst. The shrieking was hurting my ear. To show pain, anger and hurt, see Elena's performance or see the numbness in Carmen Lee's performance in M Club. Everybody else will cry and shriek but very few will have that more powerful quiet moment. And plus Raymond Lam who was also crying hard, what you have is an overdone scene. The one scene that convinces me that she should at least get a nod as one of the nominees for TV Queen is the one where she faced off Benz Hui where he tells her he knows she is an UC. She hardly spoke in there but she used her ability to cry beautifully without grimace or uglfying her face to full and beautiful effect. She tried hard to change her voice to lower tone, but many times she failed and reverted back to her very girly voice. I am ok with that although it shows she is still lacking consistencey and she is still a scene per scene actress. I never get the feeling her performance in the present scene was ever connected with the scene before or will connect with the scene later, unlike Maie Cheung Hor Yee or Tavia Yeung. But it should pleased her fans to know she is not the worst in this series. Many were worst than her.

Sharon Chan
Sharon Chan has the distinction of being cast in characters that are consistent in one thing; capitalizing on her long shapely legs or close up shots of her buttocks or both. It is getting to tiresome and predictable. In this series her legs are used for zero effect; it makes no sense to set up a scene for her to dress sexily or dance sexily when at the end of the day there is no useful connection to the plot. So her role in here is to sex it up. I have made myself clear how I feel about her Yan; I hate her Yan. I find her Yan self centred and pulled down the series to a level called "What's the point again?" and she even manages at some point to pull it down to a further "Please die! Die! Die! Die!". She predictably lives. The problem is Sharon is cast in  a hot babe role, and she isn't hot. Her character is a bit like Mary Sue and that is annoying. Everyone tumbles on his feet (note; not her but only his) to please her, to live up to their expectations but what about she herself? Sharon Chan could not bring out the sincerity in her character, she could not act out the idealised aspect of her character. I find Yan such a waste of space and I had to fast forward so many of her scenes because I just couldn't stand her and if that means fast forwarding Kobe's scenes, well sacrifices has to be made. And guess what? Not one storyline missed. Their story has no continuity in the main storyline. At least Deng Jeh and Bao Seed have some connection but Kobe-Yan is just a complete waste of time. Main reason is because Sharon was god awful.

Ankie Belkie
Now THAT is sex on legs. She should switch role with Sharon. A twirl of her little finger is sexier than the whole long legs of Sharon Chan. A good performance, a very pitiful character which unfortunately lacks development except to add on to Bao Seed's guilt and Deng Jeh's needless jealousy.

Samantha Ko
She should switch role with Sharon. Sharon should be Miss Lam and Samantha should be Yan. Maybe it might be better. Samantha was badly cast as the scary Miss Lam. She didn't look scary at all and was so very unconvincing and her role so lacking, when she died, I doubt anyone cared.

Toby Leung
My 2nd most unfavourite TVB actress in TVB right now and whilst her character is useful to throw us off in a few moments but frankly her performance was quite simply very bad. From her voice to her expressions to her interpretation, etc etc I find no merits just confusion.

The 3 Moms
Noisy when all 3 together and whilst I expected 1 or 2 to die, I never expected all 3 to die in the same scene. Brutal finishing of the veterans but I suppose at that point something super dramatic must happen to trump the mystery of "Who is NOT a UC" plot.

Now you must wonder, wow so few people? A whole lot more but most are not worth mentioning since they're mostly touch and go basis.

Before I end with my Verdict which you already know what it will be, I would like to bring back a segment which I haven't done for a very long time; Most/Least.

Most Overused Moment
Death/Sad scene > hug that person > cry hard > look up the ceiling > scream

Once was ok, twice maybe, but after that it was just funny.

Most Needless Moment
Three. Yan dressing sexily to go into a bar to do... what? AND Yan practices sexy dancing in front of Kobe for... what? AND Yan dressing sexily to dance with a villain for ... what?

Most GET ON WITH IT Moment
The nominees.

One mom's death, she screams, Second mom's death, she scream some more. Third mom's death and I thought so lucky Deng Jeh only has 3 moms.

Yan's inability to admit she is still crazy in lust with Kobe and wants to rip off is shirt and make mad love to him; instead she gave him a run around for so many wasted episodes.

Flea's death scene with flashback and back to death scene, some dialogue and still he is alive to the point poor Deng Jeh probably has no more tears because then Bao Seed enters and still no death.

The winner? Obviously Yan because her story has no connection to the main plot If it is to show how desperate Kobe is to leave his UC life, what a terrible way to explain it.

Most Pitiful Character
Three nominees.

3 step moms. Poor women. All dying one after the other.

Chum Foon Hei's son. Poor kid, all over for a kite.

On Lam. Poor girl. What a sad life.

My choice is On Lam. One very suggestive scene; she could hardly wal, her hair a bit tousled, her hands bruised and then we find out she had to give herself in exchange for an escape boat ride for her "father". Coupled also with her drug addiction forced on her and her sacrifice in the end, for me, On Lam's scenes were brief but they made a huge impact for me. A pity so little scenes. On Lam's story deserves more.

Most Hated Character
4 nominees.

Miss Lam because Samantha Ko was awful.

Yan because Sharon Chan was awful and Yan was begging to be hated anyway.

Bao Seed because he turned mental for no reason and Raymond Lam's god awful pained expressions towards the end.

Kobe for his wimpiness, his longing for Yan to the point many times he nearly jeapordised everyone.

Yip Sai Wing for his meaness.

Winner? Yan, clear winner for me. I wished Yip threw her off the building.


Most Embarassing Moment
Four nominees.

The ending. No not the ambulance scene, the deleting of Foon Hei as UC data scene. 

Yan's seductive dance scene. Pointless.

Kobe dying and doing share market thing in an abandone building whilst lying on a chair coughing up blood and weakly punching the keyboard of his laptop.

Bao Seed opening a foot massage shop to continue being a UC. Seriously?

Winner?

Ending. What a cop-out.

Most Favourite Couple
Without a doubt, Cheuk Sir and Katie. Who can forget how her husband kidnapped her and crashed the car and then ran away as she lay trapped in the upturned car when in slow mo we see Cheuk Sir who also crashed his car and is hurt didn't care for anything but to save her as he slowly limped to her even when his head was I believe covered in blood. 

A close second is Hong Sir and Ada but only because they're such a tragic love bird.

Least Favourite Couple
Who else?

Most Favourite Scene
Gotta be Foon Hei tearfully telling a tearful Deng that he sees her as his daughter. Most beautiful moment, most beautifully scripted and most beautifully acted moment in this series. Charmaine thrives when she is next to a very very good actor, like how she was when she was next to Roger Kwok in An Herbalist Affair.

Least Favourite Scene
Entire series except for the ones I labeled as Favourite.

Scariest Scene
Admittedly, the scene where Bao Seed and Deng were dragged out of their car by the angry mob was very scary.

Least Scariest Borderline Stupid Scene
The whole scene about UC's identity revealed on the internet. Could have been done better, so very Skyfall, you know? But none of Skyfall's elegance in showing how scary it should be because it is negated by the fact that Bao Seed later opens a massage parlour as a UC. By that time I think even the writers forgoten who is doing what. 

Most Shocking Moment
All about deaths plus one but not the fact they died, but the way they died.

Hong Sir's death

Yip Sai Wing's death

3 moms' death

Foon Hei's death

Ada's death

On Lam's flash tradein for boat escape

Foon Hei's son dying. Shocking because it is revealed Foon Hei ran past by the very same ambulance his son was being given CPR and Foon Hei was smiling his smug smile for having escaped his enemy without knowing the higher power up there dictates he should win some and lose big.

Yan didn't die.

Toby Leung really has a pointless red herring role. I mean she is neither a mole, UC or whatever. She is just a cop, a niece. That's shocking. Ok also that scene where she was in a dumpster about to be crushed to death. 

Winner?

Hong Sir for the fact he fell and it was shocking!

Least Shocking Moment
2 deaths plus one.

Flea's death

Kobe's death

Cheuk Sir is not a mole! He is a nice guy!

Winner?

All 3 but Flea's death is predicted by me since day 1. What is shocking is not how he died but why he died. Blame Deng.


VERDICT
It has its good moments, some very poetic moments. I am sure there will be a clear division of opinion; like When Heaven Burns, either you think this is the best ever or the trash of 2014. I tried to like it but after half way through when I had to sit through the slow mos and lovey dovey pointless scenes, I lost my patience. I fast forwarded them all and did not miss a single plot point. Fans of Charmaine and Raymond and the likes will be pleased because they're pleased with whatever their idols do whatever I say but to those who wants and seeks good performances and unique characters, you gotta watch this for Benz Hui, Elena Kong and Michael Miu. This is the series where veterans rule and the younger veterans just almost made the grade and the ones that the veterans are passing the torch to is just abysmal. It is a combination of poor performance, badly written character and poor direction but ultimately for me why I hated this series is because it is just so darn out of this world stupidity. And there's a movie coming soon! Guess what? Ditch the TVB version, go buy Infernal Affairs, HK's best movie about moles and UCs and triads and demi gods and semi devils in the modern world. If this series had been an ancient series, it would have been quite awesome but certain ideas just do not work in modern world.

I will say watch it with fair warning but I suppose you will probably say you have seen it and that I am wrong. Let's say opinions differ but validly given opinion either way is still an opinion worth reading.

Anyway, one of this year's most wasted story opportunity and for me one of the worst this year.

Great Tidbit
Michael's character was supposed to have been played by Tony Leung (Ka Fai) but he injured himself. Pity.

Sammy Leung was supposed to play the character of Kobe, now occupied by Sammy Shum who was supposed to play the annoying O-Kei cop now occupied by Patrick Tang! But is Sammy Leung suitable for the role of Kobe if Kobe is as he is as played by Sammy Shum? I doubt it. I think the casting now is just right. Sammy Leung would have been a better fit as Raymond's character or Oscar's but Jazz Lam was born for Oscar's character. Talk about a huge miscast!

I suppose this series marks the return of Charmaine Sheh to TVB, but not permanently of course.

Share:

19 January 2015

ALL THAT IS BITTER IS SWEET / 大藥坊 [TVB][2014][R] Funn Lim

Written by Funn Lim


The shorter version is she never seem comfortable in this role.


SPOILERS ... SPOILERS ... SPOILERS



Chinese title
大藥坊

This is
formerly known as Big Apothecary! Better change the name, since most can't pronounce the name anyway. Apo what? Apo then carry what?

Year released
2014

First Date of 1st broadcast
08.09.2014

End Date of 1st broadcast
17.10.2014

No. of Episode
30

Cast & Character
All names in Mandarin. I will change them to Cantonese as I go along.

Du Yan Ge as Du Shen / Dou Sam
Linda Chung as Du Jia Qi/Dou Kai Kei
Pierre Ngo as Du Rong/Dou Yung
Shirley Yeung as Feng Yu Qin/Yuk Kam
Raymond Wong as Zhuang Ji Zu (Chong Kai Cho) and Zhuang Ji Zong (Chong Kai Chung)
Natalie Tong as Xu Jun Yue/Hui Kwan Yuek
Pat Poon as Zhuang Dun Ru/Chong Duen Yu
Susan Tse as Wei Qiu Qing
Ruco Chan as Ding Yi Yuan/Ting Yat Yuen
Sammy Sum as Wei Jun/Wai Chun
Samantha Ko as Pian Pian
Elliot Yue as The General Hui Shung Ming
Alex/Jazz Lam
Ching Hor Wai
Choi Kwok Hing
Bak Yan
Choi Kwok Hing as Dr Sheung

Synopsis and Episodic Thoughts
I wrote detailed episodic thoughts until episode 11. Then I switch to opinion and summaries in my blog until the last episode.

NOTICE
At the time of writing this review I was pretty sure who is Kai Cho and who is Kai Chung. Now that my memory fades a little, I am not so sure so any mistake, I! AM! SORRY!!!! in my Linda Chung voice.

COMMENTS
I am gonna talk about this series on the 3 aspects;

1. Story and Characters
2. The stuff I absolutely hated
3. The stuff I absolutely liked
4. The performances

And I am gonna talk about this series from the perspective of a fan of Ruco Chan and Linda Chung.

If you are ready to take out that champagne for Linda because I am not ashamed to admit I am a Linda Chung fan and seen a lot of her series, do keep that champagne in the fridge. You should bring out the plates you do not ever want to see anymore, a nice cosy corner with a broom ready because if it was me, I would be throwing those plates on the floor screaming "Why? WHYYYYYYYYYYYY? LINDA! WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY?!?!?!?" in that "Linda Chung's Dramatically Betrayed By A Person You Trust And Feeling So Hurt That The World And All Worlds In All Dimensions Simultaneously Come Crashing Down And You Don't Have Your Helmet On Voice" which should have its own entry in the dictionary as a verb; like I just gave that traitor a piece of my mind with my Linda Chung Voice.

STORY AND CHARACTERS
This title is so aptly named in English if you look at the title the opposite. All that is bitter is sweet will eventually become bitter. That's how I feel with the ending. It is not the stupidest ending, that belonged exclusively to Bottled Passion. I mean in recent memory there are a lot of stupid endings so frankly ATIBIS is not THE worst. But it is one of the worst. It is not a genuinely happy ending unless you just want a happy ending for the sake of a happy ending. It continues the run where TVB simply refuses to invest in a good wedding scene which actually completes and ends with a happy couple. But then when I first watched this series, I could have guessed it isn't all rosy and in some ways I got some things right but in many ways, this series really defied my expectations.

The story is cut into 3 segments.

1. Kai Kei and her struggles. This is where the main story is.
2. Kwan Yeuk and her struggles. 
3. Pin Pin and her struggles.

The men are complimentary to these 3 segments. Yat Yuen for Kai Kei and Pin Pin, Kai Cho for Kwan Yeuk and Kai Kei, 2nd Uncle and frankly can't remember who and Ngai Chun for first 3 but it all leads back to these 4 eventually.

Of all the male characters, Ngai Chun had the most to do. Yat Yuen at the end of the day is quite simply the hero and nothing more. Kai Chung is the short tempered rebel with a heart and nothing more. Ngai Chun is the villain, the antagonist to all characters, the go-to evil guy. In fact if there is any compliment to be given for this series, the deaths are very dramatic and probably the highlights of this series. I am sure many of you will clap happily when Ngai Chun died and I was happy for the way he died. 

Before I venture further, I just wanna ask, why the name Kai Kei when everyone struggles to pronounce it? Most sounded like Ka Kei!

Ok, continue.

The story is standard stuff, even if it is supposedly about a strong female character against insurmountable challenges in life to become a success. Ahhh you must have noticed even my short description is inaccurate, that is because this series became different somewhere at the beginning of the series. The trailers, everything misled me to think this is a story about poor little rich Mary Sue who had to learn the hard knocks in life and lead her family to glory again whilst falling for our dashing hero who is dying of a heart disease who she will in the end save. For a series supposedly about the main girl that is To Kai Kei, you know something is gonna go wrong when even the cast sometimes got her name wrong; it is often sort of Ka Kei instead of Kai Kei. For such a series to work, it must wholly be on the main girl and she must be thrown into such situations that we either like her and cheer for her or like her but wonder maybe someone else can do better than her. Problem is I never liked Kai Kei because she was never proactive. She was always the damsel in distress. At the beginning she can't even speak in a timely manner and in the end she can't even count properly. All I can remember of the last scene she saw Yat Yuen and he told her to close her eyes to count to 3, by the time she actually started counting after breathing deep and hard, I have counted to 20. Let's just say Kai Kei redefines ladylike in the annoying slow mo way. Slow mo doesn't mean ladylike by the way. The main problem is that the story is so familiar. Someone did it first and did it better, like Jewell In The Palace which centres on the female lead. In ATISBIS, you get the idea Kai Kei is more of an observer rather than in the centre of it all. It also doesn't work as well because she is not a very interesting heroine. Her situation is dire and interesting but how she goes about it is not. She doesn't have one exceptional moment and towards the end when this series is so saturated with so many characters, our Kai Kei sort of got pushed into the corner and forgotten. There are other more memorable characters in this series and that is why Kai Kei never really fit in. The story does try to show her uniting her family, saving her father, saving people, saving our hero, saving everyone but it never really properly show it all. The limelight should be on her and her actions but the story was too busy with everyone else that there isn't enough focus on her. And I never liked her at all. She seems so weak, so whiny, too gentle and always the cause of everyone's problem that I didn't feel for her at all. And when Kwan Yeuk appears I feel less. When Pin Pin appeared, all my sympathies go to Pin Pin. Like what I wrote in my blog post, like every woman in this series, I detest Kai Kei because she is a non entity in a world where she is supposed to be the supreme entity. 

The story is not standard stuff when it is about Kwan Yeuk. Half the time I was wondering is she nice or is she a bitch in sheep clothing. Well, she is an elegant, educated, practical woman who sees things as they are and a problem solver. She is not Kai Kei, she is who Kai Kei should be. I like Kwan Yeuk even if she was always miserable. Twice falling in love with 2 men who are brothers who both love the same woman. In the end I was never convinced Kai Chung loved Kwan Yeuk but anyway, she got her happy ending and that's pretty awesome. I like how she ended Ngai Chun's life. 

Talking about strong women, Pin Pin is one tough cookie. Her background is not as innocent and protected as Kai Kei or as rich and educated as Kwan Yeuk but she is one street smart girl. Her only flaw is she fell for a guy who refuses to commit but at least in her own tragic way, she got her happy ending. After such cold deaths in Line Walker which I felt nothing, when Pin Pin died and it was a long death scene, it brought tears to my eyes. Could such a giving person ever exist? Someone who so understand how to love and is so unselfish in the sense seeing her death for the man she loved is worth more than living for nothing? She is to me a perfect character or near perfect. Kwan Yeuk had long bouts of jealousy and insane expectations for Kai Chung who never really promised her anything. Kai Kei's head is forever in the clouds that she is so unbelievable as a person. Pin Pin had her faults too but once she think things through, she would gather her wits, come to a correct conclusion and do the right thing, even if it meant her life. For that I like Pin Pin the most even if her character appeared late into the series and died so soon.

Shirley Yeung's character is not worth to talk about much except she is naive. Not naive smart like Kai Kei but so seriously naive you will wonder how she can survive all these years. I never got the impression she ever loved the 2nd Uncle but her ending is good. She smartened up after a lifetime of stupidity.

Let's talk about the men who are complimentary to the women.

We have Kai Cho, the calm beloved first born of Chong family and the lookalike (not twin) Kai Chung, the rebel of the family. Kai Cho is quite a charmer. His death scene which was the 1st major death scene was horrific and major and very upsetting because he is such a nice guy. Everyone likes him and he is Kwan Yeuk's adonis as much as Kai Kei is his goddess. However he appeared briefly and died and then came same actor, different character, Kai Chung who is the annoying righteous guy who is the Incredible Hulk of this series; he is perpetually angry. When he is not perpetually angry, he is suddenly as meek as a mouse, especially when it comes to women. He is the rebel but with a conscience and a heart. But I never really liked him much and sometimes he disappears from the series and from Kai Kei's life. 

Then there's Ting Yat Yuen, the hero of our series, literally. He saves lives, he is a nice guy, he trades with a conscience and a heart. He believes he will die before he is 35 and so he lives as he says;

"..I live my life calculating the risks because I will soon die when I reach 35 and I don't want to waste my time and risk whatever time I have"

Interesting. Usually when people know they're dying, the story is almost always how they live life without calculating the risk and to the fullest since calculating time and risks would be too much of wasting whatever precious time he has. Anyway that is why he doesn't want to commit because he can drop dead anytime soon. At the very start I know he won't die because that will be contrary to the purpose of Kai Kei. I was right except Kai Kei did not save him. I suppose he had time to spare after the age of 35 by the fact that perhaps the disease skip a generation perhaps? I do not know. I consider this a plothole.

This is one character that is as helpful as he is noble. He is a bit like Kai Chung except with a cooler head. He is more like Kai Cho minus the wealth and education but he isn't stupid. He is a very appealing character, probably will be popular with viewers, except his only problem is he has no purpose. The fact that he will die when he is 35 is just a motivator. His entire singular purpose in this series is to help and assist Kai Kei. There is no Yat Yuen without Kai Kei. When Pin Pin appears, at least there is some individuality for Yat Yuen but again he is there to save and help Pin Pin. There isn't much dilemma when there should be since he chose Kai Kei over Pin Pin, even if he never really did promise Pin Pin anything. So Pin Pin had no just cause to be butthurt by Yat Yuen's refusal. I just feel at times Yat Yuen is the overhelpful pedesterian who has no legitimate story in this series. Quite a waste of a good character.

Then there's Ngai Chun, who is rather intriguing. The villains are rather intriguing. What is intriguing is he is a competent police but dirty corrupted and sadistic. But he is also defined by his worshipping of Kwan Yeuk as his goddess and admirably so. He is gentle, caring, attentive and sort of speak the truth when he is with her. He never really take advantage of her, never tried to kiss her, the only intimate thing he did was to gently wipe the tears from her face. And I so want to like him, and I do and of course that is wrong because he is supposed to be the villain and so he has to do villain stuff. He is always that sort of guy who has a sadistic cruel streak but I thought maybe Pin Pin is there for a reason. Well, not quite. Maybe Kwan Yeuk will change him but not quite. Since Kwan Yeuk is deadset on Kai Chung who has no other woman for him, Ngai Chun will be the "sacrificial lamb". Oh towards the end he is was evil and his ending justified. But I just wished why can't black isn't always black, white isn't always white? I find him more character than that annoying Kai Chung!

There's To Yung, the 2nd uncle. I thought maybe he has hope to be a better person, like how it was in Safe Guards but nope, in the end still rotten to the core. You can't say he is evil but he is definitely a selfish bad man who prioritises his own interest over another. Whatever he does, his first question is "What do I gain from this?". His ending is proper although he disappeared from the screen many times.

And finally the old ones. Plenty of old people in here with many scenes that overshadow the younger cast and obviously Kai Kei. They're the fathers and mothers.

There's General Hui Shung Ming who is quite a revelation. Like Ngai Chun (before his downfall at the end) he is intriguing. I so want to hate him but I end up emphatising with him. There is no doubt General Hui is a harsh cruel man who is as arrogant as he is brash. But he also loves his daughter very very much. Even his daughter is exasperated by his constant meddling in her love life but in the end it was all for good intentions. Any father who thinks the world of his daughter will do the same thing he did, minus the whole gun pointed to the head thing. He is also working in a highly pressurised work. But I can't understand if he is so rich, why not just cut the bs and just retire? Because he loves power too much? But he loves his daughter more! In the end he is ready to confess his sin and frankly he died a decent man at the hands of the dastardly Ngai Chun. A good ending in my opinion.

There's To Sum, Kai Kei's dad. For me To Sum is on the same page with General Hui, both as arrogant, as self centred, as self assured, as perfectionist. The only difference is To Sum has tact whilst General Hui lives in a world wen he doesn't need to be tactful. Both are good fathers, raising decent daughters. Both love their daughters very very much and think the world of them. However To Sum has the disadvantage if thinking his medical knowledge was complete, and nothing can harm him. In the end he was absolved from the death of Kai Cho who he thought he dramatically killed due to medical negligence. He didn't know the lingchi was poisoned by General Hui's biochemical factory. However I still think he was right to be imprisoned. Part of the reason why Kai Cho died was because To Sum was too arrogant to accept there may be flaws with his pills and his diagnosis. In some ways his diagnoses was flawed because he didn't pay enough attention to the symptoms, such as blackened fingernails. He was so confident that he didn't observe the basics of medicine; observe and diagnose. He jumped straight to medicine. He felt he deserved to be jailed which was great but how he accepted that fate was done in a very profunctory nature. I wanted to see how he finally accepted his part of the blame but the process was too short. And he has the shortest greatest dilemma ever; wife pregnant with his brother's son and all solved in the space of 5 minutes. No great dilemma for him. I do like his ending though; simpler clothings, back to being the physician rather than the businessman.

There's the mayor and his wife, who both are more accepting of a girl whose father pulled a gun and tried to kill their youngest son (and not to mention also a possible terrorist and homocidal maniac) rather than a girl whose father negligently killed their beloved older son. The father is meek who is lucky to have married a smarter more capable wife, much like how in the end Kai Chung the not so smart guy marrying Kwan Yeuk who is obviously the smarter one. They are major players in the story and I enjoyed their dilemma and interactions but I never quite warm up to the cowardly mayor and his smart wife who unfairly blamed Kai Kei for every jinx coming their way.

Finally, the supporting of the supporting. If Kai Kei is lead, Yat Yuen is supporting, then whoever next to Yat Yuen is supporting him and frankly I really like the silly tastefully comedic trio whose name I never quite catch. I know the actors, well 2 of them at least but did not catch their characters' names. They were witty and funny without sounding inappropriate. No silly cute music at the worst possible timing. Their comedy is subtle and I find them cute and did their job well in supporting the main cast. I don't feel they're time wasters.

THE STUFF I ABSOLUTELY HATED
Some are performance based, some are writing based.

I absolutely hated the way there is ordinary people slow mo and then there's Kai Kei slow mo. Even in emergencies, she doesn't break away when someone is holding her back. Instead she will stand still and finish whatever line when at the back of your mind you're thinking "Kai Kei, Kai Cho is dying! Hurry for god's sake!". Her interpretation of time is 10 seconds slower than we are and whilst it is not fatal, but 10 seconds is enough for a dying weakened body man to run away from her and into nowhere. And she never stood up to run and find him. Even when our hero is beaten to a pulp, it took her 10 seconds to register any reaction such as like you know, saving him? When she is walking she tends to trip a lot because you know, she is a gentle soul living in the protective coccoon of her father's love that she has never climbed onto planks and into boats without wobbling. She can't even carry anything without wobbling. She can't even fret at a shorter time. Her fretting is 10 seconds. The way she was there to warn anyone of any danger, when she faced some difficulty, she actually walks away when she should be pushing, running, panicking. She is hardly hard pressed for time.  That is what I absolutely hate. The Kai Kei Time Factor. By the time she is done fretting, I could have finished half the pack of popcorns.

I absolutely hated the illogical story abot Kai Kei insisting the herbs in her foreclosed Sheung Chun Toong to remain exactly where they are. In the end it was Yat Yuen who moved them to a secure location which Kai Kei should have thought that in the first place.

I absolutely hated Kwan Yeuk's condition for a while. Was she a vegetable? Was she immobile? Was she crazy? Or was she just too traumatised for anything? Which is which?

I absolutely hated the notion chinese medicine can cure everything with 1 dosage, 1 acupuncture exercise, etc. 

I absolutely hated the ending. So did Yat Yuen die? When he disappeared before her eyes, I thought she was imagining things and I was like "Oh dear, Ruco dying, YET AGAIN". And then I heard he actually DID disappear before her eyes. So the poison nearly killed him, right? Whilst he got rid of the poison his exertion shortened his already short lifespan because he tried to help the jinx called Kai Kei.  So that should mean he should be dying soon. And yet had the energy to disappear, much like how Kobe did to hilarious effect in Line Walker. It was not figuratively; we are talking literally. And in the end Kai Kei climbs a hill in Yunnan and from afar she sees a guy and she smiled widely. Of course that's Yat Yuen although we are not shown Yat Yuen, probably because Ruco wasn't available for filming. It was just a silly end. Eithe he dies (and all pronogsis was telling us the viewers that) or show Kai Kei actually CURING him as promised. Nope. What we got was like perhaps 5 years later, pharmacy reopened, became a success, Kai Kei a successful doctor, likes picking herbs herself and climbs up mountain and sees Yat Yuen. Or maybe she was falling from some cliff and was imagining things and that was her personal heaven where the dead Yat Yuen was waiting for her. I find the latter a better ending than the crap I saw on TV. It does not justify at all that Kai Kei is a great doctor. DaeJanggeum, THIS IS NOT!


The underwater kiss. TVB, there are kisses and there are CPR. Which is which? And it is so funny Kai Kei is saved by the kiss of life and next thing it was Yat Yuen who was sinking to the bottom of the lake and so she had to drag him up for another session of... you guessed it! Kissing.. CPR I mean.


I absolutely hated the inconsistency in the Chong family's hate towards Kai Kei. Sometimes they do, and with such venom that they declare Kai Kei as a jinx (well, me too) and sometimes they don't, and could even emphatise with them. It disrupts the flow of the story for me.

I absolutely hate the following items;

1. Yat Yuen's hat! Get rid of the hat!

2. Kwan Yeuk outer mini top, she is forever in one.

3. Those silly pants of those GROs in Pin Pin's bar. Ugliest pants ever.

4. The short period of time from no remorse to deep remorse by To Sum.

5. But the most important one that I hated the most was Kai Kei's neck scarf, perpetually on her neck save for 3 or 4 occasions. It is like winter is always there, she is perpetually cold. Or maybe she is hiding the stranglings marks of fellow viewers who hated her. I wanted to rip off that scarf from her neck. I wanted to shred it to pieces. I don't get why her costume is so uninspired and worse, is is THAT cold all the time?

Of all my hates, the scarf is my number 1 hate. 


THE STUFF I ABSOLUTELY LOVED
The deaths. Fantastic. 

Kai Cho was poisoned to death, accelerated by negligence by To Sum. His death scene was so sad, so poignant, t sets the tone for the grief to follow. Everything was perfectly set up. 

General Hui was shot point blank on his temple by Ngai Chun. You know Ngai Chun will kill him but how? Using the general's favourite golden gun and without any time to prepare. Blood splurting, perfect set up and perfect execution, pun intended.

To Yung's death was well deserved and was glad he suffered. He was shot in the back by Ngai Chun anyway, so he was probably dying but in his dying moments he punch a hole or something onto the cylinder with the biochem warfare in it and some splurted on his face and it basically acted like acid. Not a good looking death. But I was glad he died.

Ngai Chun's death was as sudden as General Hui, except this time it was Kwan Yeuk who shot him on the temple with her father's golden gun. Great death!

Pin Pin's death was the saddest. Knocked from her bicycle and even slapped by Ngai Chun, she basically succumb to her injuries but she died a very very happy woman.


I absolutely loved Pin Pin for her generosity and Kwan Yeuk for her classiness. These 2 girls defined this series for me.

But I absolutely loved that one scene where Ngai Chun was arrested for act of terrorism so to speak. First he taunted Yat Yuen about Pin Pin's death and so Yat Yuen basically beat the crap out of him. Then he made Kai Chung very angry who ended up punching and beating him. In the space of a few minutes, he taunted the Minister Wong who was always the cool headed one but he got so angry this time he kung fu kicked the table which hit Ngai Chun so hard he flew back. Oh what a satisfying scene!!


THE PERFORMANCES
The Good
Ruco Chan is good in a role that is like sleepwalking for him because he has done the cheeky nice fella so many many many times. Whilst his role is not well defined, his performance is good enough for me. Won't win him the TV King but sure to garner a few female fans and will please many hard core Ruco fans who love his brand of acting where his eyes speak volume. He does make a convincing sick dying man. Since when he was filming this series he was reportedly sick, I guess it wasn't much of a method acting for him. I just feel that since I have seen this performance before, I wasn't thrilled by it as much as I should be.

Pierre Ngo is in the obligatory jerk role and frankly, seen him in such roles before except this time his To Yung doesn't repent. I like his performance and he was effective even if pointless in the grander scheme of things.

Raymond Wong successfully pulls off 2 characters with distinct personality but seperated by just 1 eyeglass. I know which is Kai Cho and which is Kai Chung. I liked him more as Kai Cho. As Kai Chung, you have seen that performance elsewhere, where he is mostly very expressive with his eyes.

Samantha Ko has improved a lot in her acting. She is convincing as the unselfish giving Pin Pin and her death scene is as epic as it is sad.

Poon Chi Man is someone I haven't seen for a long time. He was good as the pressured cowardly mayor who we know is a decent man but isn't always standing to what's right.

Du Yange is not that believable as the much feared To Sum but at the end when he is humbled, I think that's where he is at his best.

Susan Tse was sublime as the intelligent Mrs Chong.


The Great
Jazz Lam is the perfect sidekick in a role only he can give justice to.

Wai Ka Hung is the perfect sidekick in a role he perfectly blends between witty lines, serious moments and sad times.

Bak Yan was amazing as the vile small minded grandma who became a better person in the end.

Elliot Ngok was wonderful as General Hui. I couldn't get his performance at first but as the series got on, I began to appreciate his interpretation of the scary brash General Hui. Love his chemistry with Natalie.


The Bearable
Shirley Yeung is not the best actress but surprisingly she is watchable in here as the naive simplistic "brain not all there" Mrs To. Stil can't stand the way she talks.

The Best
Natalie Tong has my vote as the best female performance in this series. Whilst I may dislike her clothing or her helmet hair, or the fact that she hardly smiles at all, I find her less dramatic than she was sayyyyy in A Fistful Of Stances. She was graceful, elegant, sophisticated, intelligent, not that nice but isn't a bad person and she is absolutely believeable as Kwan Yeuk. I love her earlier scenes where she was pining for Kai Cho, later on I love her tender moments with General Hui. She shares great chemistry with Elliot Ngok and balances well with his brashness and her gracefulness. Natalie has finally come of age as an actress. 

Sammy Shum has my vote as the best male performance in this series, and it is of no disrespect to Ruco. Ruco was wonderful but the character was hardly a stretch for him. Sammy is in a role that I have never seen him in before. He has big expressive eyes and he used it to great effect in her. He was whiny and clingy and overall inadequate acting in Line Walker which will win him TVB's Most Improved but frankly if he does win for Line Walker, I will interprete it to include his fine performance in this series. His Ngai Chun is a complex character and he carried the role and around veterans with panache, gung ho and a certain sense of style. As handsome he is to look at, his character was ugly to behold and yet infused with the right amount of romanticism when he is with his goddess and sadism when he is cruel and in the end manic insanity that had almost every male character punching him. He was a revelation and even if he looked young to be the corrupt chief of police, his success was he was believable. Line Walker may gain him his legions of fans but it is in this series where his growth of an actor is reaching a point where I can say, he is almost there as the lead actor kind. I have always said he is one actor where he has the charisma and the looks and the ability to mold his face to any role but the talent is catching up, slowly. Now, it is catching up much faster. He still needs some more "baking" time in the oven called the actor rite of passage but I do believe we are seeing a potentially good actor with star quality in the making. If he has Vincent Wong's acting abilities with Vincent's body and his own looks, that would be deadly and the metamorphosis complete. Right now, not quite yet but on the correct trajectory.

The Worst
Linda Chung. She is by no means a bad actress. She is often better at roles that are opposite of her public image. This role however is sorta like her public image; nice sweet helpful girl. The problem is as highlighted above. The shorter version is she never seem comfortable in this role. The way she delivered her lines is too fact, like she is hurrying to finish the lines so she doesn't need to speak those lines, like she is afraid of them. She is a naturally gentle feminine girl (however much she may like to stress she is a tomboy, etc, don't be fooled) and she didn't need to put on those gentle movements but here it felt timed, calculated and nothing natural. She speaks with a naturaly higher pitch tone, almost lazy and very feminine girl voice but her, she somehow ramped up the girlish tone and coupled with deliberate heavy sighs,it felt like she is always burdened with something. It doesn't help that her character doesn't change much, not in personality, not in clothes. Linda herself did nothing to show that aspect of change. For someone who is well liked in the industry, I somehow hated her Kai Kei. I just felt something is way off with her performance and in the end my conclusion is she is having a bad day in the office. She never felt comfortable in this role; she looked like she'd rather be elsewhere. Not even her favourite costar Ruco can make her feel otherwise. Of course this is just my personal opinion but I thought her best costar was always Steven Ma who is every girl's best costar these days! I lament the fact that Linda is now becoming Myolie; everything she does is poison. Myolie never got out of that, and that is because somehow I feel she lost her enthusiasm for acting. For Linda, maybe it is nerves but she has been in more difficult roles in the past. So maybe Linda has lost her temporary touch. The writing isn't top notch either so that contributes to her failure in this role but at the end of the day, I just feel Linda was the main reason.

VERDICT
Good for an afternoon watch if you have no great expectations. You will be surprised how much you will like the supporting cast and some aspects of this character. Watch it for Ruco but seriously, watch it for Sammy Shum and Natalie Tong who are the stars in this series. I won't say this is a must watch but to those who enjoys such genre, this is a good choice but just don't expect great stuff.


Share:

Labels, Archive and the usual sidebar contents are at the bottom of this page.