Latest Posts
One moment pls. Loading 10 latest posts...

31 December 2002

Hotelier [Korea]

Written by Funn Lim


"My favourite character is actually Han Tai Jun!"



SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS!





Chinese Title
Ching Ding Da Fan Dian

Cast : Character
Bae Yong Joon: Shin Dong-hyuk/Frank (Shen Dong Xian)
Kim Seung Woo: Head Mgr. Han Tae-jun (Han Tai Jun)
Song Yun Ah: Mgr. Suh Jin-young (Xu Zhen Yin)
Song Hae Gyo: Kim Yun-hee (Jin Yun Xi)
Park Jung Chul: Cui Rong Qi
Choi Yong Min: Leo Park
Choi Hwa Jung: Manager Lee Soon Jung (Manager Li)
Hu Joon Ho: Manager Oh Hyung Man (Manager Wu)
Ha Jin Hee: President Kim Bock Man (Jin Fu Wan)
Kim Nah Rae: Jenny
Joo Hyun: The "deceased' President Choi (President Cui)
Yoon Yu Jung: Madam Choi-Yoon Dong Sook (Madam Cui Dong Suk)
Kang Young Suk: Xuan Jie (the bellboy that always followed Han Tae Joon)
Myung Gye Nam: Head chef Loo
Lee Gae Yin: Manager Yoo

No. of VCDS
20

Year of Production
2001

Language
Korean - dubbed/subtitles in Mandarin

Recommended
MTV/VCD/Soundtrack.
There is a 3-song VCD-MTV out there for the 3 songs sung in this series. Frankly the songs are quite ok, I couldn't say memorable since I do not what the singer was singing about. If you're interested, you may download the MTVs here. Forgive me for the lack of titles as I do not

Summary
Love, hate, penitence and survival in the competitive world of hotel management with a difference; heart. Plenty of it. Service with a smile and a heart. Remember that; HEART. PLENTY OF IT.

Story
It's Seoul, it's modern times and there is a big hotel which has seen glorious days under attack by an unseen but very well known power. The boss of the hotel, a man who believes in service with a smile and heart died all of a sudden, leaving the management of the huge hotel now in financial difficulties to his aged wife and a son who doesn't even quite cut it as a bell boy. And so the wife, Mrs Chairman as she is known wanted to invite a Mr Han Tai Jun to return to the hotel and work some of his ordinary man magic and save the hotel in process. The problem is nobody knows where he is, except for his ex-girlfriend who is still pining for him, a Manager at the hotel and a bubbly women, Shu Zhen Ying. She traveled alone, all the way to Las Vegas tracing his steps only to find him in a downtrodden place, without a decent job and living in with a 20 year old female delinquent. After some emotional misunderstandings, she realised the girl, Jenny was actually Tai Jun's dead professor's adopted child who was all alone and he was actually taking care of her and his lack of achievements is actually his very own choice. Zhen Ying had to work her magic, to bring him back but he refused, remembering the bitter past where a politician's wife accused him of sexually attacking her in the hotel bedroom she was staying in, though in actual fact she was the one who tried very hard to seduce him (and failed miserably as Tai Jun is an honest and honourable man). Driven out of Korea by scandals and by his mentor the boss who died not long ago himself, Tai Jun went to Las Vegas a disappointed and broken man. But Zhen Ying wanted nothing of that sort; she literally scolded him when she had the opportunity. Only after Jenny tangled in some nasty business with some local bad guys and Tai Jun got beaten up as a result, Jenny wanted to start a new leaf and to return to her roots. Tai Jun could only agree and went back to Korea with Zhen Ying and Jenny in tow.

Once back, things were not as rosy as Tai Jun had anticipated. Back stabbing by jealous fellow staff, and one stiff competition by a competitor who wanted the hotel simply because the woman he loved married the owner of the hotel, he had to deal with also bad tempered guests at the hotel, a love struck young girl who so happened to be the daughter of the competitor who wanted the hotel and worst of all, he could not reveal his love for Zhen Ying though Zhen Ying has been waiting for his return for 3 long years. When he could almost do it, a highly competitive, successful and desirable mysterious man by the name of Frank Shen Dong Xian appeared in Zhen Ying's life. He was actually the one entrusted by the evil Mr Jin to acquire the shares to the hotel at all costs and together with his trusty lawyer-sidekick, he stayed at the hotel even though everybody eventually knew of 2 glaring facts;

1. He is the one commissioned to take over the hotel and so he is hotel enemy no.1; and

2. more importantly, he is Tai Jun's competitor even in love as he was pursuing Zhen Ying herself whilst Zhen Ying became highly confused about her feelings for 2 men.

When Zhen Ying rejected his advances, Frank took it badly and decided to concentrate fully on his job at hand, even when Zhen Ying branded him a liar for lying to her and for using her in getting around the hotel though that was really unnecessary. Zhen Ying who is highly protective of Tai Jun snubbed Frank though she found it increasingly hard to not acknowledge his presence whilst Frank and Tai Jun entered into a manly competition in business; each knows why each is so eager to save/destroy the hotel and things became personal with Zhen Ying involved.

Through thick and thin, troubles and glories, rumours and facts, Tai Jun with gritted teeth went through it all for the love of the hotel, a promise to his dead boss and dying Mrs Chairman and to the staff at the hotel; he'll save the hotel no matter what.

Frank Shen who took a high risk gamble when he realisd work isn't as important as he thought it was learned that life is more than mergers and acquisitions and together with Tai Jun, a confused Zhen Ying and his new found compassion, he learned to give instead of take.

So, will all these lead to an extremely magnificent happy ending for all?

Questions Asked And Answered
What does Frank do for a living?
M&A which is not like selling insurance but Mergers & Acquisitions. I guess he is the guy who acquires companies. Whilst this series had been compared with Pretty Woman since Richard Gere's character has the same job as Frank, I find that's where the similarities end. For one, there is no prostitute in here.

How did Frank knew Zhen Ying?
In Las Vegas, Frank was eating in a restaurant when he heard a very angry customer complaining about the bad service, the customer being Zhen Ying. He was I guess captivated by her honesty, beauty and personality. Along the way he met her several times in Las Vegas and began to like this fiesty woman who would not take no for an answer.

How long did Tai Jun left Korea?
3 years.

What was his position in the hotel before he left?
I would guess senior manager, and he would have taken over the management of the hotel if not for that scandal. He was after all Mr Chairman's favourite "son". A prodigal "son" whose father worked in the same hotel years before.

Why Mr Jin so eager to buy the hotel?
Anger, jilted lover. Mrs Chairman was kinda with him when she kinda left him for his good friend, the Mr Chairman. In fact Mr Jin had no interest in developing the hotel; he wanted to get rid of it. Even the prospect of going to jail for dealing in illegal trading methods in buying the shares of the hotel didn't scare him at all. He just wanted to destroy the hotel.

So how did Tai Jun managed it all?
Classic. Through heart, plenty of it. Of course a few helped along the way. Remember that lady who tried to seduce him 3 years before? Well, she holds some major number of shares and instead of selling them to Frank for a big amount of money, she gave it to Tai Jun. GAVE IT TO TAI JUN because she felt guilty for all the problems she caused him. Quite a decent woman. And of course Frank had a change of heart.

What change of heart?
Zhen Ying's condition for loving him is for him to not take over the hotel for Mr Jin. Without such condition, sooner of later he would have let go of everything for Zhen Ying anyway and of course, his long lost baby sister, Jenny. Jenny couldn't believe her brother was the hated enemy of the hotel where she was working as a junior chef in training and she couldn't bring herself to look at him with love as Frank had hoped. She felt a certain loyalty for Tai Jun, and she resents the fact that Frank almost had Zhen Ying's heart. And so she was rather cold towards him but with some intervention by the reasonable Tai Jun and Zhen Ying, she decided to accept Frank as her brother. And so Frank decided to take the biggest gamble of his life to win back the love of Zhen Ying, the trust of his sister and the friendship of Tai Jun.

Friendship of Tai Jun? But they're enemies!
Not quite. Each admires each other for various reasons but to Frank, Tai Jun would make a very good and loyal friend. In fact it was Tai Jun who avoided such a prospect because well, there's still the problem of Zhen Ying.

Is Zhen Ying the only woman in this series?
Nope. There's a younger, prettier, richer and of course sulkier Yun Xi, the unhappy daughter of mega rich Mr Jin who was a chauvinistic pig in his treatment towards his only child. But Yun Xi with gritted teeth worked in secret at enemy's hotel as a waitress and expressed an interest in mainly 2 things;

1. hotel management. She wants to take over papa's business but papa said go get married. Took quite some time for her to convince him of course that she was all business and not 100% play;

2. Han Tai Jun. After she was rescued by him when she was almost raped by some drunken young men, she became enamoured with Tai Jun despite the huge differences in their age (she's 20, he is presumably mid or late 30s). She went all the way out, confessed her love many many times but Tai Jun had only one woman in his heart, though he can't deny his attraction for this young beautiful child-woman. In the end, nothing happened. Sadly.

So does Tai Jun love Yun Xi?
I would say yes but he doesn't quite realise it. One scene he looked at her and said he realises he likes her but due to their age differences and society's taboo, he can't take the relationship any further. If you don't like a girl, you won't say that.

So the ending?
Frank had to leave Korea as a condition for his freedom after nabbing Mr Jin in a highly dangerous cat and mouse game (I mean Frank himself is guilty of illegal trading but he was acting on orders), Zhen Ying didn't leave with him because of Tai Jun and when she finally realised Frank was the one she loved, too late, plane already flown. Yun Xi went abroad to study hotel management and well, hopefully something transpired off camera but on camera, Tai Jun and her remained cordial, polite, no hot romance or anything. Mrs Chairman succumbed to her illness and left the entire business to Tai Jun. Of course her son became a better person though still a lazy bum with really spiky hair. As for Frank and Zhen Ying, they got back together at last.

HAPPY ENDING. In a way. With HEART. Plenty of it.

Comments
I have heard a lot about Korean series, with the bombarding of Winter Sonata into the deeper recesses of my mind every day and Bae Yong Jun, Bae Yong Jun and more Bae Yong Jun. I wanted to watch a good Korean series, but having read some reviews of some really over the top love stories with one being blind, crippled or dead (in a happy way), I was skeptical; will Korean dramas turn up to be like Qiong Yau series? So my friends recommended me Hotelier. No one dies, at least not young people in their prime and whilst we get a fair share of diseases and tensions, nobody dies of some unfortunate freak accident or sisters falling in love with brothers, so to speak. The series is reasonably normal in length, 20 VCDs which is like watching a normal length TVB series. The story is frankly nothing remarkable. Luckily I didn't have to torture myself watching the original version, I watched the mandarin-dubbed version. I didn't know who is who, even when Bae Yong Jun appeared I was still clueless as to who the heck is this hottest Korean actor since...since I do not know who.

There is a certain joy in watching a series with people you do not know or has yet to be familiar with. Only then of course you open yourself to a whole new universe and suddenly you realise, there's more than TVB, ATV, TCS, Chinastar and Japanese series in this world. Right now Korean series is the in thing. One major reason why people love Korean series is because they focus on one subject and one couple. Unlike TVB series which tends to overblow the entire contents with explosions, threats and ten thousand women for one man, in Korean series we have one man (or max 2) loving one woman (or max 2) till death. We see a more monogamous kinda relationship. There's no hanky panky, even the kissing scenes are devoid of any romantic notions. No stripping off clothes, it's all love based on personality and knowing each other well.

So is this a good series?

In a way, and looking at it as a whole, a definite yes. It has some great moments, many funny moments and certainly loads of tender and sentimental moments. In fact this is a series with moments, connected to the story and yet you can appreciate it without associating it with the next scene. Everything happens for a reason and in that aspect, this series is very consistent in its flow of story and definitely, in the characterisation of certain key players, but of course not quite.

Everybody has their fair share of screen time, certainly one couple tends to have more, that is Frank Shen and Zhen Ying. The thing is whilst the whole world was fascinated by their love story, I wasn't. I find their love story interesting at first, but when Han Tai Jun posed no threat at all to their blossoming love and the entire series built on mergers and takeovers, frankly their love story becomes rather stale and bland. But as I do not know who the heck Bae Yong Jun is, I was left to wonder who will get the girl. Of course I made the mistake of reading some reviews and then the suspense was gone for me and when I realised how famous Bae Yong Jun is the whole suspense kinda disappear for me. Actually I should have known the ending would be as such; after all the VCD cover has two faces, one Bae Yong Jun smiling that famous smile of his and the actress, smiling sweetly.

So what about the story you may ask?

As I said, it's consistent but not entirely logical.

I do believe in the business of servicing people such as the hotel industry, a worker must be polite and helpful, all the time, like Zhen Ying and Tai Jun. But I do not believe any hotel would buy underwear or kneel before a guest to make these guest feel happy for staying at the hotel. I certainly don't see that in Malaysian or Singaporean hotels. Maybe only in Korea. In that sense it is illogical but not unreasonable as they are to show how dedicated these people are even when faced with such insults.

Whilst everybody hoped, prayed and cheered when Frank came back to Zhen Ying, I was a tad disappointed. I do believe in real life if Tai Jun were to say "Come back to me" a person like Zhen Ying would run to him. In TVB world, this would be the case and of course very boring in the end. But I was hoping Tai Jun ends up with somebody, even if the person is Yun Xi but that's not the case. I do believe Zhen Ying loves Tai Jun, I do believe she feels something for Frank. And I also believe if Zhen Ying were to be with Frank, when Tai Jun has a problem she would run to him. This is because they have this unbreakable bond. In a way the ending was apt but still, I was hoping for the boring ending for once.

As for the idea of a villain, you won't find one here except for one stubborn old man you could hate for the way he treated his daughter and the reason why he wanted the hotel, which is pretty lame and very unwise for a man who has made a fortune by making wise business decisions. Of course in the business of the heart, you can't always guarantee logical actions.

Last but not least, I was very disappointed at some characters which were more cartoonish than real. Like for example Tai Jun's rival Manager who did quite a lot of back stabbing, even opposed the appointment of Tai Jun and yet the Mrs Chairman never considered dismissing him. Certainly in the world of management, when one dissents for no apparent reason, some vote of no confidence must be given against such opposition? But not in here. Everybody tolerates him and I do not know why. Then they went on with how he fell for another supervisor, all of a sudden. That was illogical and very out of place. No reason, just love all of a sudden. Strange.

And of course the story of Mrs Chairman's son, with the spiky hair and all. Lazy bum but for love, he was willing to buck up. The thing is I was hoping he would create some problem for Tai Jun but in the end, he is just a love sick puppy. Whilst in TVB world he would have turned real bad, in here he is nothing more than a mild puppy. I find that disappointing because at the end of the day the problems posed to Tai Jun is really nothing personal, just business. If it had been an inside job, and inside spy, that would make this series even more interesting. The main focus of this series though is love or the inability to accept or confess love. Very narrow focus and not my cup of tea.

But that doesn't mean I hated it. Quite the contrary I quite liked it. Some of my favourites are ...

Most Favourite Couple
Strangely, I like Yun Xi and Tai Jun's segments because it's just so funny. Whilst Frank had the bubbly one, guess who had the young beautiful physically perfect being? Ahhhhhh...justice, sweet justice. Of course both girls had personalities to die for, NOT. Yun Xi is such a boring girl.

Most Favourite Scene(s)
Plenty. Not all Frank Shen's. I like the scene where Frank met his father. I love the scene where he looked at his sister, Jenny, the pain in his eyes when Jenny told him she disliked him and was ashamed that he was her brother by blood. I like the scene where Frank tried to make friendly conversations with Tai Jun and basically, Tai Jun was very rude. Gave one line answers only. I like the scenes where Zhen Ying scolded Tai Jun for everything. I like the scene where Yun Xi questioned Tai Jun on everything and then dropped the bomb; that she liked him. All except scenes between Zhen Ying and Frank and that Mr Jin scenes.

Most Favourite Character
I do like Zhen Ying who has personality like no other female heroines before. I can understand why two men would vie for her even with her messy appearance and temper.

A lot of my friends who watched this series fell in love with the cold, calculative, but loving and stylish Frank Shen. Quite a contradiction. He was that kinda man that most women would try hard to vie for since he is rich, successful and best of all hard to get. Imagine when he smiles at you and says he loves you, wouldn't you melt like Zhen Ying and thousands of women did when his smile is rarer than lightning striking you?

I didn't.

My favourite character is actually Han Tai Jun. He is honest, hard working, decent, loyal and yes yes yes, very indecisive when it comes to women. Why don't he just confess his love for Zhen Ying? Surely Zhen Ying would have run to him in a second. But he must have had his reasons; maybe with so much responsibilities at hand, a relationship is the last he would expect. I find him rather good looking in a very ordinary man sort of way. He is a man you could trust. But the funny thing is and the best thing about this series is things are not what they seem to be.

Funniest Scene
Yun Xi joined with his drunken friends in a hotel room. Somebody played a joke at and his clothes were a bit dirty. So he said he wanted to change his clothes. FINE. Then whilst changing, Yun Xi was sexually assaulted by his drunken friends, she was crying help and this guy, was from changing his clothes to... get this....drum roll please...WASHING HIS HAIR AND HAVING A FULL SHOWER! I mean that was so funny! And the of course Tai Jun came in and rescued the damsel in distress with Yun Xi, feeling refreshed from the shower stupefied as to what happened.

Worst Aspect
Frank is supposed to be Korean born but educated in America. Whilst Bae Yong Jun's voice is certainly very deep and quite pleasing to the ears, his poor grasp of English had me laughing in stitches. So much attention given to the details of management and yet very little on just a few lines of English.

And did I mention that every time they had dinner in the hotel, it's in this big hall that looks more like a ball room than a restaurant?

Best Aspect : A Study Of The Characters Of Two Men
Frank Shen started out as cold, calculative, arrogant. But in his pursuit of Zhen Ying, we know he believes in romance, he believes in revealing his feelings when he had to. He is a man who has no problems flirting with Zhen Ying, with teary eyes looking at his sister, silently begging for Jenny to accept him as his brother, very vocal in his love for Zhen Ying. This is a man who may look secretive, or even sometimes behave as one in business (more so when Zhen Ying rejected him, he went emotional overload and wanted the hotel to squash Han Tai Jun, after all he is just a jealous man) but in actual fact, you can read everything from his face. He has nothing to hide emotionally and his feelings is an open book.

Now we move on to Han Tai Jun.

He started out as exceedingly friendly, hard working, everybody tells him their problems and being less competitive than Frank, you would expect him to be more open with his feelings. And yet he is one secretive man. He doesn't get emotional, he looks downwards but his eyes fixed on you with his head tilted down when he is embarrassed and when he has nothing much to say. In fact Tai Jun has nothing much to say at all as opposed to Frank Shen. And yet when it comes to Frank Shen, he does get emotional but not in a big way. He just ignores you. That can be very annoying but Tai Jun made it very clear, what can be discussed and what can't be without even saying a word. His lack of emotional output frustrated Zhen Ying (and me) though many a times he would suddenly blurt out old memories and quietly told off Zhen Ying for revealing to people he likes chocolates when he likes chocolates because Zhen Ying used to give him chocolates during Valentine's day. He takes problems onto his shoulder, he doesn't reveal them nor share them, a quiet man and so a potentially loyal friend because he may not say much, he would compensate his lack of words with plenty of action.

Which is why I liked the fact that Frank wanted him as a friend. Frank's successful and all but had no friends except for one. Tai Jun could easily make friends because no one feels threatened when they're with him. In a way, Frank envied Tai Jun's ability to communicate with people in a level without revealing too much and Tai Jun's ability to make friends, and very loyal friends along the way. Tai Jun is humble whilst Frank learned to be humble. Tai Jun is a good man whilst Frank whilst a good man had to learn to give more than take. Tai Jun had his sister's loyalty without much question or hesitation on Jenny's part whilst Frank practically had to earn his way to Jenny's heart.

What Frank at last realised is you don't have to give to get back what you lost in equal portions. When at last he walked down the corridors of the hotel, he realised people were actually greeting him even when they all knew he was hotel enemy no. 1. He realised people are innately friendly. Why people turn the other way is because of his output. Tai Jun always treated others with respect, acknowledging everybody in his presence no matter how lowly ranking they may be whilst Frank didn't even stop to look. When he did, he realised he lost a lot of things and he suddenly understood why Zhen Ying and Tai Jun wanted to save the hotel, not for profit but because of the vision of the dead chairman and because of hundreds of jobs which could be lost by one angry man's whim and fancy. He could no longer serve such an unreasonable master and for once he understood the idea of giving in a small way is much better than taking in a major way. What's the use of money when at the end he losses his humanity and everybody else? By sacrificing a little, he gained not only the heart of a woman he loves, he gained back his sister and plenty of grateful friends.

Certainly the best aspect of this series.

Best Performances
Surprisingly everybody gave good performances with the exception of Bae Yong Jun (Frank Shen), Kim Seong Yu (Han Tai Jun) and Song Yun Erh (Shu Zhen Ying) who gave excellent performances. There's no over the top acting but more of restraint acting. One though stood out as a poor actress, that is Song Hye Kyo (Jin Yun Xi) who is pretty to look at and really nothing much in other aspects. That doesn't mean she isn't good, but she could have been better. Her character is angry, cold and frustrated, but frankly she sulked too much.

As for Song Yun Erh , for once we have a heroine who doesn't comb her hair or wear make up. She is so believably messy, so unremarkably unattractive in looks and yet 2 men vies for her heart for a very simple reason; her character is bursting with personality. Instead of expensive restaurants, her unofficial first date with Frank is a fast food restaurant. She is not flawless, she is not perfect, she is not afraid to show her flaws and like those 2 guys, you'll end up liking her and think of her as kinda cute too.

My favourite actor happens to be the guy who plays my favourite character, Kim Seong Yu where he gave a very controlled performance of a man who could blend into the background but not quite. He is charismatic, he is a very good actor and in a way he brings integrity and honour into Han Tai Jun, which is why I like his Han Tai Jun; you don't see this kinda man anymore. Of course you could hate him for being so indecisive when it comes to love, but who would go and woo a woman when faced with such huge responsibilities? I feel the actor handled all the emotional scenes well and in a way I feel Zhen Ying is much more relaxed when with him and less pretentious than when she was with Bae Yong Jun's Frank Shen.

Bae Yong Jun was not my favourite at first. I thought he tried so hard to be cool he seems rather pretentious. Girls swoon over the fact that when he smiles, he lights up the whole screen. The same compliment I gave Daniel Radcliffe of Harry Potter fame; when they smile all your worries disappear and all you're left with is this amazingly sincere and happy smile. Frankly I didn't feel that way with Bae Yong Jun. Maybe too fair for my taste, maybe acts too cool, maybe it's the way he walks where he swings left to right and right to left in a very unmanly and young-ish kinda way, in fact like Keanu Reeves. But later on I appreciated his acting, when he had to do emotional scenes like with his dad or his sister. But with Song Yun Erh's Zhen Ying, I feel nothing for their love. Maybe I am immune to romanticism, but then I am absolutely in love with Hugh Jackman's Leopold in Kate and Leopold. Maybe I just don't like him. Anyway, a competent performance deserving of all the swooning female fans.

Verdict
The intro scenes are not theme song based but music based and the artwork is refreshingly different. The story was well paced at first, with interesting moments but after the 10th VCD, things get a bit draggy when things finally settles. And it picks up again towards the end but still is overly too long. It's not very well paced with moments where I just didn't feel like watching it anymore. In fact I stopped watching for quite some time, due to my busy schedule and mostly because I don't feel motivated to watch what I would term as seen that-done that series. However I must compliment the voice overs who did such excellent jobs. When the lips moves, the dialogue begins and when the lips stop, so will the dialogue. I do wonder how they all sound in real life but then the Korean language is such a difficult language to listen to; all sound the same to me.

Anyway, look at the length of my review. It could have been longer if I were to deal with the nitty gritty stuff. But let me get straight to the point;

I wouldn't mind watching more Korean series thanks to my introduction to Korean series by this what I would term as a very good series, short of brilliant series. Guys are rather ok looking, girls are exceptionally beautiful (all looks the same to me, long black hair, flawless skin which is why I appreciated the actress Song Yun Erh who looks messy enough to look different but when she wore the hotel uniform, I couldn't recognise her), beautiful sceneries and of course, nice soundtrack.

I don't think this series need my recommendation or my introduction. Just look at the girls swooning at Bae Yong Jun's face filmed at 45 degrees to the left with the sun shining on his face with a slightly crooked lips forming into what would be a beautiful smile and you'll realise how famous this series is. Put that aside, do give this series a try and I hope you'll like Han Tai Jun like those few odd people in this world like yours truly. After all if everybody loves Bae Yong Jun's Frank Shen, things would be a bit crowded don't you think?

Rating
A good

Interesting observation
Bae Yong Jun, Kim Yoon Hee, Jang Dong Gun ... Malaysians have names like Lim Chee Yung, Wong Mei Ling, Tan Yong Jin...see anything similar?

Share:

Hotelier [Korea]

Written by Funn Lim


"My favourite character is actually Han Tai Jun!"




SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS!





Chinese Title
Ching Ding Da Fan Dian

Cast : Character
Bae Yong Joon: Shin Dong-hyuk/Frank (Shen Dong Xian)
Kim Seung Woo: Head Mgr. Han Tae-jun (Han Tai Jun)
Song Yun Ah: Mgr. Suh Jin-young (Xu Zhen Yin)
Song Hae Gyo: Kim Yun-hee (Jin Yun Xi)
Park Jung Chul: Cui Rong Qi
Choi Yong Min: Leo Park
Choi Hwa Jung: Manager Lee Soon Jung (Manager Li)
Hu Joon Ho: Manager Oh Hyung Man (Manager Wu)
Ha Jin Hee: President Kim Bock Man (Jin Fu Wan)
Kim Nah Rae: Jenny
Joo Hyun: The "deceased' President Choi (President Cui)
Yoon Yu Jung: Madam Choi-Yoon Dong Sook (Madam Cui Dong Suk)
Kang Young Suk: Xuan Jie (the bellboy that always followed Han Tae Joon)
Myung Gye Nam: Head chef Loo
Lee Gae Yin: Manager Yoo

No. of VCDS
20

Year of Production
2001

Language
Korean - dubbed/subtitles in Mandarin

Recommended
MTV/VCD/Soundtrack.
There is a 3-song VCD-MTV out there for the 3 songs sung in this series. Frankly the songs are quite ok, I couldn't say memorable since I do not what the singer was singing about. If you're interested, you may download the MTVs here. Forgive me for the lack of titles as I do not

Summary
Love, hate, penitence and survival in the competitive world of hotel management with a difference; heart. Plenty of it. Service with a smile and a heart. Remember that; HEART. PLENTY OF IT.

Story
It's Seoul, it's modern times and there is a big hotel which has seen glorious days under attack by an unseen but very well known power. The boss of the hotel, a man who believes in service with a smile and heart died all of a sudden, leaving the management of the huge hotel now in financial difficulties to his aged wife and a son who doesn't even quite cut it as a bell boy. And so the wife, Mrs Chairman as she is known wanted to invite a Mr Han Tai Jun to return to the hotel and work some of his ordinary man magic and save the hotel in process. The problem is nobody knows where he is, except for his ex-girlfriend who is still pining for him, a Manager at the hotel and a bubbly women, Shu Zhen Ying. She traveled alone, all the way to Las Vegas tracing his steps only to find him in a downtrodden place, without a decent job and living in with a 20 year old female delinquent. After some emotional misunderstandings, she realised the girl, Jenny was actually Tai Jun's dead professor's adopted child who was all alone and he was actually taking care of her and his lack of achievements is actually his very own choice. Zhen Ying had to work her magic, to bring him back but he refused, remembering the bitter past where a politician's wife accused him of sexually attacking her in the hotel bedroom she was staying in, though in actual fact she was the one who tried very hard to seduce him (and failed miserably as Tai Jun is an honest and honourable man). Driven out of Korea by scandals and by his mentor the boss who died not long ago himself, Tai Jun went to Las Vegas a disappointed and broken man. But Zhen Ying wanted nothing of that sort; she literally scolded him when she had the opportunity. Only after Jenny tangled in some nasty business with some local bad guys and Tai Jun got beaten up as a result, Jenny wanted to start a new leaf and to return to her roots. Tai Jun could only agree and went back to Korea with Zhen Ying and Jenny in tow.

Once back, things were not as rosy as Tai Jun had anticipated. Back stabbing by jealous fellow staff, and one stiff competition by a competitor who wanted the hotel simply because the woman he loved married the owner of the hotel, he had to deal with also bad tempered guests at the hotel, a love struck young girl who so happened to be the daughter of the competitor who wanted the hotel and worst of all, he could not reveal his love for Zhen Ying though Zhen Ying has been waiting for his return for 3 long years. When he could almost do it, a highly competitive, successful and desirable mysterious man by the name of Frank Shen Dong Xian appeared in Zhen Ying's life. He was actually the one entrusted by the evil Mr Jin to acquire the shares to the hotel at all costs and together with his trusty lawyer-sidekick, he stayed at the hotel even though everybody eventually knew of 2 glaring facts;

1. He is the one commissioned to take over the hotel and so he is hotel enemy no.1; and

2. more importantly, he is Tai Jun's competitor even in love as he was pursuing Zhen Ying herself whilst Zhen Ying became highly confused about her feelings for 2 men.

When Zhen Ying rejected his advances, Frank took it badly and decided to concentrate fully on his job at hand, even when Zhen Ying branded him a liar for lying to her and for using her in getting around the hotel though that was really unnecessary. Zhen Ying who is highly protective of Tai Jun snubbed Frank though she found it increasingly hard to not acknowledge his presence whilst Frank and Tai Jun entered into a manly competition in business; each knows why each is so eager to save/destroy the hotel and things became personal with Zhen Ying involved.

Through thick and thin, troubles and glories, rumours and facts, Tai Jun with gritted teeth went through it all for the love of the hotel, a promise to his dead boss and dying Mrs Chairman and to the staff at the hotel; he'll save the hotel no matter what.

Frank Shen who took a high risk gamble when he realisd work isn't as important as he thought it was learned that life is more than mergers and acquisitions and together with Tai Jun, a confused Zhen Ying and his new found compassion, he learned to give instead of take.

So, will all these lead to an extremely magnificent happy ending for all?

Questions Asked And Answered
What does Frank do for a living?
M&A which is not like selling insurance but Mergers & Acquisitions. I guess he is the guy who acquires companies. Whilst this series had been compared with Pretty Woman since Richard Gere's character has the same job as Frank, I find that's where the similarities end. For one, there is no prostitute in here.

How did Frank knew Zhen Ying?
In Las Vegas, Frank was eating in a restaurant when he heard a very angry customer complaining about the bad service, the customer being Zhen Ying. He was I guess captivated by her honesty, beauty and personality. Along the way he met her several times in Las Vegas and began to like this fiesty woman who would not take no for an answer.

How long did Tai Jun left Korea?
3 years.

What was his position in the hotel before he left?
I would guess senior manager, and he would have taken over the management of the hotel if not for that scandal. He was after all Mr Chairman's favourite "son". A prodigal "son" whose father worked in the same hotel years before.

Why Mr Jin so eager to buy the hotel?
Anger, jilted lover. Mrs Chairman was kinda with him when she kinda left him for his good friend, the Mr Chairman. In fact Mr Jin had no interest in developing the hotel; he wanted to get rid of it. Even the prospect of going to jail for dealing in illegal trading methods in buying the shares of the hotel didn't scare him at all. He just wanted to destroy the hotel.

So how did Tai Jun managed it all?
Classic. Through heart, plenty of it. Of course a few helped along the way. Remember that lady who tried to seduce him 3 years before? Well, she holds some major number of shares and instead of selling them to Frank for a big amount of money, she gave it to Tai Jun. GAVE IT TO TAI JUN because she felt guilty for all the problems she caused him. Quite a decent woman. And of course Frank had a change of heart.

What change of heart?
Zhen Ying's condition for loving him is for him to not take over the hotel for Mr Jin. Without such condition, sooner of later he would have let go of everything for Zhen Ying anyway and of course, his long lost baby sister, Jenny. Jenny couldn't believe her brother was the hated enemy of the hotel where she was working as a junior chef in training and she couldn't bring herself to look at him with love as Frank had hoped. She felt a certain loyalty for Tai Jun, and she resents the fact that Frank almost had Zhen Ying's heart. And so she was rather cold towards him but with some intervention by the reasonable Tai Jun and Zhen Ying, she decided to accept Frank as her brother. And so Frank decided to take the biggest gamble of his life to win back the love of Zhen Ying, the trust of his sister and the friendship of Tai Jun.

Friendship of Tai Jun? But they're enemies!
Not quite. Each admires each other for various reasons but to Frank, Tai Jun would make a very good and loyal friend. In fact it was Tai Jun who avoided such a prospect because well, there's still the problem of Zhen Ying.

Is Zhen Ying the only woman in this series?
Nope. There's a younger, prettier, richer and of course sulkier Yun Xi, the unhappy daughter of mega rich Mr Jin who was a chauvinistic pig in his treatment towards his only child. But Yun Xi with gritted teeth worked in secret at enemy's hotel as a waitress and expressed an interest in mainly 2 things;

1. hotel management. She wants to take over papa's business but papa said go get married. Took quite some time for her to convince him of course that she was all business and not 100% play;

2. Han Tai Jun. After she was rescued by him when she was almost raped by some drunken young men, she became enamoured with Tai Jun despite the huge differences in their age (she's 20, he is presumably mid or late 30s). She went all the way out, confessed her love many many times but Tai Jun had only one woman in his heart, though he can't deny his attraction for this young beautiful child-woman. In the end, nothing happened. Sadly.

So does Tai Jun love Yun Xi?
I would say yes but he doesn't quite realise it. One scene he looked at her and said he realises he likes her but due to their age differences and society's taboo, he can't take the relationship any further. If you don't like a girl, you won't say that.

So the ending?
Frank had to leave Korea as a condition for his freedom after nabbing Mr Jin in a highly dangerous cat and mouse game (I mean Frank himself is guilty of illegal trading but he was acting on orders), Zhen Ying didn't leave with him because of Tai Jun and when she finally realised Frank was the one she loved, too late, plane already flown. Yun Xi went abroad to study hotel management and well, hopefully something transpired off camera but on camera, Tai Jun and her remained cordial, polite, no hot romance or anything. Mrs Chairman succumbed to her illness and left the entire business to Tai Jun. Of course her son became a better person though still a lazy bum with really spiky hair. As for Frank and Zhen Ying, they got back together at last.

HAPPY ENDING. In a way. With HEART. Plenty of it.

Comments
I have heard a lot about Korean series, with the bombarding of Winter Sonata into the deeper recesses of my mind every day and Bae Yong Jun, Bae Yong Jun and more Bae Yong Jun. I wanted to watch a good Korean series, but having read some reviews of some really over the top love stories with one being blind, crippled or dead (in a happy way), I was skeptical; will Korean dramas turn up to be like Qiong Yau series? So my friends recommended me Hotelier. No one dies, at least not young people in their prime and whilst we get a fair share of diseases and tensions, nobody dies of some unfortunate freak accident or sisters falling in love with brothers, so to speak. The series is reasonably normal in length, 20 VCDs which is like watching a normal length TVB series. The story is frankly nothing remarkable. Luckily I didn't have to torture myself watching the original version, I watched the mandarin-dubbed version. I didn't know who is who, even when Bae Yong Jun appeared I was still clueless as to who the heck is this hottest Korean actor since...since I do not know who.

There is a certain joy in watching a series with people you do not know or has yet to be familiar with. Only then of course you open yourself to a whole new universe and suddenly you realise, there's more than TVB, ATV, TCS, Chinastar and Japanese series in this world. Right now Korean series is the in thing. One major reason why people love Korean series is because they focus on one subject and one couple. Unlike TVB series which tends to overblow the entire contents with explosions, threats and ten thousand women for one man, in Korean series we have one man (or max 2) loving one woman (or max 2) till death. We see a more monogamous kinda relationship. There's no hanky panky, even the kissing scenes are devoid of any romantic notions. No stripping off clothes, it's all love based on personality and knowing each other well.

So is this a good series?

In a way, and looking at it as a whole, a definite yes. It has some great moments, many funny moments and certainly loads of tender and sentimental moments. In fact this is a series with moments, connected to the story and yet you can appreciate it without associating it with the next scene. Everything happens for a reason and in that aspect, this series is very consistent in its flow of story and definitely, in the characterisation of certain key players, but of course not quite.

Everybody has their fair share of screen time, certainly one couple tends to have more, that is Frank Shen and Zhen Ying. The thing is whilst the whole world was fascinated by their love story, I wasn't. I find their love story interesting at first, but when Han Tai Jun posed no threat at all to their blossoming love and the entire series built on mergers and takeovers, frankly their love story becomes rather stale and bland. But as I do not know who the heck Bae Yong Jun is, I was left to wonder who will get the girl. Of course I made the mistake of reading some reviews and then the suspense was gone for me and when I realised how famous Bae Yong Jun is the whole suspense kinda disappear for me. Actually I should have known the ending would be as such; after all the VCD cover has two faces, one Bae Yong Jun smiling that famous smile of his and the actress, smiling sweetly.

So what about the story you may ask?

As I said, it's consistent but not entirely logical.

I do believe in the business of servicing people such as the hotel industry, a worker must be polite and helpful, all the time, like Zhen Ying and Tai Jun. But I do not believe any hotel would buy underwear or kneel before a guest to make these guest feel happy for staying at the hotel. I certainly don't see that in Malaysian or Singaporean hotels. Maybe only in Korea. In that sense it is illogical but not unreasonable as they are to show how dedicated these people are even when faced with such insults.

Whilst everybody hoped, prayed and cheered when Frank came back to Zhen Ying, I was a tad disappointed. I do believe in real life if Tai Jun were to say "Come back to me" a person like Zhen Ying would run to him. In TVB world, this would be the case and of course very boring in the end. But I was hoping Tai Jun ends up with somebody, even if the person is Yun Xi but that's not the case. I do believe Zhen Ying loves Tai Jun, I do believe she feels something for Frank. And I also believe if Zhen Ying were to be with Frank, when Tai Jun has a problem she would run to him. This is because they have this unbreakable bond. In a way the ending was apt but still, I was hoping for the boring ending for once.

As for the idea of a villain, you won't find one here except for one stubborn old man you could hate for the way he treated his daughter and the reason why he wanted the hotel, which is pretty lame and very unwise for a man who has made a fortune by making wise business decisions. Of course in the business of the heart, you can't always guarantee logical actions.

Last but not least, I was very disappointed at some characters which were more cartoonish than real. Like for example Tai Jun's rival Manager who did quite a lot of back stabbing, even opposed the appointment of Tai Jun and yet the Mrs Chairman never considered dismissing him. Certainly in the world of management, when one dissents for no apparent reason, some vote of no confidence must be given against such opposition? But not in here. Everybody tolerates him and I do not know why. Then they went on with how he fell for another supervisor, all of a sudden. That was illogical and very out of place. No reason, just love all of a sudden. Strange.

And of course the story of Mrs Chairman's son, with the spiky hair and all. Lazy bum but for love, he was willing to buck up. The thing is I was hoping he would create some problem for Tai Jun but in the end, he is just a love sick puppy. Whilst in TVB world he would have turned real bad, in here he is nothing more than a mild puppy. I find that disappointing because at the end of the day the problems posed to Tai Jun is really nothing personal, just business. If it had been an inside job, and inside spy, that would make this series even more interesting. The main focus of this series though is love or the inability to accept or confess love. Very narrow focus and not my cup of tea.

But that doesn't mean I hated it. Quite the contrary I quite liked it. Some of my favourites are ...

Most Favourite Couple
Strangely, I like Yun Xi and Tai Jun's segments because it's just so funny. Whilst Frank had the bubbly one, guess who had the young beautiful physically perfect being? Ahhhhhh...justice, sweet justice. Of course both girls had personalities to die for, NOT. Yun Xi is such a boring girl.

Most Favourite Scene(s)
Plenty. Not all Frank Shen's. I like the scene where Frank met his father. I love the scene where he looked at his sister, Jenny, the pain in his eyes when Jenny told him she disliked him and was ashamed that he was her brother by blood. I like the scene where Frank tried to make friendly conversations with Tai Jun and basically, Tai Jun was very rude. Gave one line answers only. I like the scenes where Zhen Ying scolded Tai Jun for everything. I like the scene where Yun Xi questioned Tai Jun on everything and then dropped the bomb; that she liked him. All except scenes between Zhen Ying and Frank and that Mr Jin scenes.

Most Favourite Character
I do like Zhen Ying who has personality like no other female heroines before. I can understand why two men would vie for her even with her messy appearance and temper.

A lot of my friends who watched this series fell in love with the cold, calculative, but loving and stylish Frank Shen. Quite a contradiction. He was that kinda man that most women would try hard to vie for since he is rich, successful and best of all hard to get. Imagine when he smiles at you and says he loves you, wouldn't you melt like Zhen Ying and thousands of women did when his smile is rarer than lightning striking you?

I didn't.

My favourite character is actually Han Tai Jun. He is honest, hard working, decent, loyal and yes yes yes, very indecisive when it comes to women. Why don't he just confess his love for Zhen Ying? Surely Zhen Ying would have run to him in a second. But he must have had his reasons; maybe with so much responsibilities at hand, a relationship is the last he would expect. I find him rather good looking in a very ordinary man sort of way. He is a man you could trust. But the funny thing is and the best thing about this series is things are not what they seem to be.

Funniest Scene
Yun Xi joined with his drunken friends in a hotel room. Somebody played a joke at and his clothes were a bit dirty. So he said he wanted to change his clothes. FINE. Then whilst changing, Yun Xi was sexually assaulted by his drunken friends, she was crying help and this guy, was from changing his clothes to... get this....drum roll please...WASHING HIS HAIR AND HAVING A FULL SHOWER! I mean that was so funny! And the of course Tai Jun came in and rescued the damsel in distress with Yun Xi, feeling refreshed from the shower stupefied as to what happened.

Worst Aspect
Frank is supposed to be Korean born but educated in America. Whilst Bae Yong Jun's voice is certainly very deep and quite pleasing to the ears, his poor grasp of English had me laughing in stitches. So much attention given to the details of management and yet very little on just a few lines of English.

And did I mention that every time they had dinner in the hotel, it's in this big hall that looks more like a ball room than a restaurant?

Best Aspect : A Study Of The Characters Of Two Men
Frank Shen started out as cold, calculative, arrogant. But in his pursuit of Zhen Ying, we know he believes in romance, he believes in revealing his feelings when he had to. He is a man who has no problems flirting with Zhen Ying, with teary eyes looking at his sister, silently begging for Jenny to accept him as his brother, very vocal in his love for Zhen Ying. This is a man who may look secretive, or even sometimes behave as one in business (more so when Zhen Ying rejected him, he went emotional overload and wanted the hotel to squash Han Tai Jun, after all he is just a jealous man) but in actual fact, you can read everything from his face. He has nothing to hide emotionally and his feelings is an open book.

Now we move on to Han Tai Jun.

He started out as exceedingly friendly, hard working, everybody tells him their problems and being less competitive than Frank, you would expect him to be more open with his feelings. And yet he is one secretive man. He doesn't get emotional, he looks downwards but his eyes fixed on you with his head tilted down when he is embarrassed and when he has nothing much to say. In fact Tai Jun has nothing much to say at all as opposed to Frank Shen. And yet when it comes to Frank Shen, he does get emotional but not in a big way. He just ignores you. That can be very annoying but Tai Jun made it very clear, what can be discussed and what can't be without even saying a word. His lack of emotional output frustrated Zhen Ying (and me) though many a times he would suddenly blurt out old memories and quietly told off Zhen Ying for revealing to people he likes chocolates when he likes chocolates because Zhen Ying used to give him chocolates during Valentine's day. He takes problems onto his shoulder, he doesn't reveal them nor share them, a quiet man and so a potentially loyal friend because he may not say much, he would compensate his lack of words with plenty of action.

Which is why I liked the fact that Frank wanted him as a friend. Frank's successful and all but had no friends except for one. Tai Jun could easily make friends because no one feels threatened when they're with him. In a way, Frank envied Tai Jun's ability to communicate with people in a level without revealing too much and Tai Jun's ability to make friends, and very loyal friends along the way. Tai Jun is humble whilst Frank learned to be humble. Tai Jun is a good man whilst Frank whilst a good man had to learn to give more than take. Tai Jun had his sister's loyalty without much question or hesitation on Jenny's part whilst Frank practically had to earn his way to Jenny's heart.

What Frank at last realised is you don't have to give to get back what you lost in equal portions. When at last he walked down the corridors of the hotel, he realised people were actually greeting him even when they all knew he was hotel enemy no. 1. He realised people are innately friendly. Why people turn the other way is because of his output. Tai Jun always treated others with respect, acknowledging everybody in his presence no matter how lowly ranking they may be whilst Frank didn't even stop to look. When he did, he realised he lost a lot of things and he suddenly understood why Zhen Ying and Tai Jun wanted to save the hotel, not for profit but because of the vision of the dead chairman and because of hundreds of jobs which could be lost by one angry man's whim and fancy. He could no longer serve such an unreasonable master and for once he understood the idea of giving in a small way is much better than taking in a major way. What's the use of money when at the end he losses his humanity and everybody else? By sacrificing a little, he gained not only the heart of a woman he loves, he gained back his sister and plenty of grateful friends.

Certainly the best aspect of this series.

Best Performances
Surprisingly everybody gave good performances with the exception of Bae Yong Jun (Frank Shen), Kim Seong Yu (Han Tai Jun) and Song Yun Erh (Shu Zhen Ying) who gave excellent performances. There's no over the top acting but more of restraint acting. One though stood out as a poor actress, that is Song Hye Kyo (Jin Yun Xi) who is pretty to look at and really nothing much in other aspects. That doesn't mean she isn't good, but she could have been better. Her character is angry, cold and frustrated, but frankly she sulked too much.

As for Song Yun Erh , for once we have a heroine who doesn't comb her hair or wear make up. She is so believably messy, so unremarkably unattractive in looks and yet 2 men vies for her heart for a very simple reason; her character is bursting with personality. Instead of expensive restaurants, her unofficial first date with Frank is a fast food restaurant. She is not flawless, she is not perfect, she is not afraid to show her flaws and like those 2 guys, you'll end up liking her and think of her as kinda cute too.

My favourite actor happens to be the guy who plays my favourite character, Kim Seong Yu where he gave a very controlled performance of a man who could blend into the background but not quite. He is charismatic, he is a very good actor and in a way he brings integrity and honour into Han Tai Jun, which is why I like his Han Tai Jun; you don't see this kinda man anymore. Of course you could hate him for being so indecisive when it comes to love, but who would go and woo a woman when faced with such huge responsibilities? I feel the actor handled all the emotional scenes well and in a way I feel Zhen Ying is much more relaxed when with him and less pretentious than when she was with Bae Yong Jun's Frank Shen.

Bae Yong Jun was not my favourite at first. I thought he tried so hard to be cool he seems rather pretentious. Girls swoon over the fact that when he smiles, he lights up the whole screen. The same compliment I gave Daniel Radcliffe of Harry Potter fame; when they smile all your worries disappear and all you're left with is this amazingly sincere and happy smile. Frankly I didn't feel that way with Bae Yong Jun. Maybe too fair for my taste, maybe acts too cool, maybe it's the way he walks where he swings left to right and right to left in a very unmanly and young-ish kinda way, in fact like Keanu Reeves. But later on I appreciated his acting, when he had to do emotional scenes like with his dad or his sister. But with Song Yun Erh's Zhen Ying, I feel nothing for their love. Maybe I am immune to romanticism, but then I am absolutely in love with Hugh Jackman's Leopold in Kate and Leopold. Maybe I just don't like him. Anyway, a competent performance deserving of all the swooning female fans.

Verdict
The intro scenes are not theme song based but music based and the artwork is refreshingly different. The story was well paced at first, with interesting moments but after the 10th VCD, things get a bit draggy when things finally settles. And it picks up again towards the end but still is overly too long. It's not very well paced with moments where I just didn't feel like watching it anymore. In fact I stopped watching for quite some time, due to my busy schedule and mostly because I don't feel motivated to watch what I would term as seen that-done that series. However I must compliment the voice overs who did such excellent jobs. When the lips moves, the dialogue begins and when the lips stop, so will the dialogue. I do wonder how they all sound in real life but then the Korean language is such a difficult language to listen to; all sound the same to me.

Anyway, look at the length of my review. It could have been longer if I were to deal with the nitty gritty stuff. But let me get straight to the point;

I wouldn't mind watching more Korean series thanks to my introduction to Korean series by this what I would term as a very good series, short of brilliant series. Guys are rather ok looking, girls are exceptionally beautiful (all looks the same to me, long black hair, flawless skin which is why I appreciated the actress Song Yun Erh who looks messy enough to look different but when she wore the hotel uniform, I couldn't recognise her), beautiful sceneries and of course, nice soundtrack.

I don't think this series need my recommendation or my introduction. Just look at the girls swooning at Bae Yong Jun's face filmed at 45 degrees to the left with the sun shining on his face with a slightly crooked lips forming into what would be a beautiful smile and you'll realise how famous this series is. Put that aside, do give this series a try and I hope you'll like Han Tai Jun like those few odd people in this world like yours truly. After all if everybody loves Bae Yong Jun's Frank Shen, things would be a bit crowded don't you think?

Rating
A good

Interesting observation
Bae Yong Jun, Kim Yoon Hee, Jang Dong Gun ... Malaysians have names like Lim Chee Yung, Wong Mei Ling, Tan Yong Jin...see anything similar?


Share:

25 November 2002

The White Flame [TVB]

Written by Jeanne


"On a scale of 1 to 10, I have to give this series a 3. I have to say that this is possibly one of the worst TV series I have ever seen..."



SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS!





Chinese Title
Hoong Yee Seou Gei (which had nothing to do with the English title, although they never do)

Episodes
20

Produced In
2002

Cast-Character
Charmaine Sheh-Charlie Yuk Choi Ling
Samuel Chan-Yung Duc Gei
Hong Chi Nei-Go Hiu Lam (Crystal)
Chan Hoi Yi-Lo Bo Bo
Claire Yiu-Ah Leng
Ling Zi Heen-Chan Ga Lok
Gregory Lee-Mun Geen Fai
Yuen Keng Dan-Goo Mei Lan (Goo Goo)
Chu Mei Mei-Rosemary
Chan Ga Yi-Crystal’s Mom

Language
Cantonese (original)

Plot
This series is basically about a group of twenty year olds who are in nursing school. These student nurses share their experiences and become good friends. Blah…blah…blah…

If you don’t want to read spoilers…stop right now!!! {although I think you’ll expect them}

At the nursing school there are the teacher, Crystal, Ah Gei, Bobo, Ah Leng, and Chan Ga Lok. Later we meet Dai Lo Fai. They all have reasons for being in nursing school. Crystal would like to learn some things before reapplying for med school. Crystal’s main goal is not to become a nurse but a doctor like her father and brothers. Ah Gei remembers when his father was dying and the nurse who took care him and his father. He feels very grateful to the nurse and would like to become a nurse. Bobo does not know what she wants to do but she needs a job. She is afraid of everything. Ah Leng would like to meet a handsome doctor hoping to marry him. She is very superficial. Dai Lo Fai is doing this for the money and had a crush on Charlie. Chan Ga Lok wants to get away from his mother and get a job while he’s at it. He’s the funny guy in the group.

Charlie
The audience first meets Charlie in her parents’ restaurant, “Yuk Gei.” Charlie is in her twenties and still does not have a career. She is not in college but she signed up for nursing school because she loves babies and has hopes of working in the maternity ward. In the beginning there is a misunderstanding between Ah Gei and Charlie on the bus to the nursing school. Charlie thought he was a pervert because she thought he touched her foot but it was actually an old man’s umbrella that touched her foot when ah gei was picking the napkins he dropped. *sigh* did you get all the info from my run-on sentence? Anyways, when they got off the bus, Ah Gei saw Crystal and she helped him get rid of Charlie.

In nursing school the nurse teacher says there are four “hearts,” ngoi sum(love), tong ching sum(sympathy), jat yum sum(responsibility), and shuun sum(confidence). I hope I got the sounds right. Over the three years Charlie and her friends, alternate between work, school, and play. “Play” is usually eating, mostly da been lo at yuk gei or elsewhere. (What’s with that? Charmaine always have these themes with food, makes me all hungry at night.) Ah Gei and Charlie forget about the incident on the bus and become friends. (I see clichés here.) At school they have the boring lectures and tests. Charlie is the worst student in the class. She has not much brain but a lot of sympathy. At work Charlie has been paired with Crystal for the same ward (it was bad enough they had to share a room, they didn’t become friends until they had separate rooms and Charlie helped Crystal get better when she had the flu). They are supervised by a nurse everyone calls Goo Goo. Later on in their rotation, Charlie gets to work in the maternity ward. One of the mothers tried very hard to have a child. She did have one but the baby died from complications. Charlie was very depressed when that happened and decided to quit nursing. She did not to quit because Ah Gei asked her to stay because he liked her. Ah Gei asked her to stay after he got some advice from Dai Lo Fai. (Dai Lo Fai liked Charlie but she didn’t like him that way.) Oh man… that scene where Ah Gei “confessed his love” was so cheesy and yuk maah with that song in the background.

Charlie was having some family problems around this time. She got in a fight with her mother about how she never lets her father do anything. Charlie’s mother had reasons for not letting him drink or overwork. Charlie’s father, Yuk Gei, is sick with liver cancer. He had liver problems when Charlie was younger but kept it from her. He fainted and was sent to the hospital. He found out that he has liver cancer and needs surgery. He does have surgery with complications but was fine afterwards. He and Charlie’s mother go to Hawaii together as like a second honeymoon.

Charlie also has relationship problems with Ah Gei because she thought he was cheating on her with Crystal. Charlie and Ah Gei get back together in the end.

Ah Gei
Ah Gei knew Crystal when they were little and has a crush on her. Ah Gei thinks this is “yuen fen” or fate that they meet again in nursing school. At home he lies to his mother because she does not want him to be a nurse. He says that he works at the airport. He buys imported food for his mother to cover up but he’s not very smart about it because his receipt is there with his mother. When his mom does find out, Charlie tries to help Ah Gei convince her. That does not work. The nurse instructor decided to speak to Ah Gei’s mother because he was falling a little behind in class. That probably did the trick.

An episode or two later ah gei’s mom is sick with gallstones or some kind of stone. She needed a small operation to remove it. In the hospital his mom starts to like Charlie and the idea of her being her daughter in law. She is not very fond of Crystal though. When Crystal was sick he made her rice porridge. When he found out that Crystal never ate any of it but Charlie did he was so angry with her. (How irrational) Around this same time, one of his patients died. He was very depressed as a result. He was taking his anger out on everyone, including his mother and his other patients. Everything was better though when he asked her to stay. Ah gei does lie to Charlie. He didn’t want Charlie to misunderstand his relationship with Crystal which is just friendship. He was trying to help Crystal get through her sickness. Charlie was having a hard time too because her father was sick. Charlie was very angry with him but after he confronted her a few times they get back together.

Crystal
Crystal is a pretty depressed and moody person because she feels very left out of her family. Her father and brothers are doctors. I don’t really know what her mother does but she is really busy. Everyone is busy with their big operations except Crystal. When Crystal was younger, her mother was never home. Crystal resented that. She stormed out of the house when she got angry with her family for not asking her to go to the family trip. When Crystal was sick with the flu, Charlie helped her get better. She made Crystal some food because Crystal didn’t want ah gei’s rice porridge. Crystal finally made friends with Charlie. Crystal’s family knew and understood how she felt. Her mother made her a birthday dinner (well, only the cake). The whole family waited for her but Crystal was at the surprise party that Charlie and the gang threw for her. The next day Crystal went home and her mom was on a plane to Taiwan. (There is always the telephone.)

When Crystal’s mom was there she was very worried because there was an earthquake in Taiwan. (There has to be some obstacle in the relationship to make them realize how important they are to each other -_- duh…). Crystal was sick right after her mom came back. She was packing for a trip to Switzerland with her family. Crystal had kidney failure, I think. She tried to hide it from everyone. Ah Gei found out first when she fainted. She didn’t want anyone to know so she would go to the doctor by herself and dressed in long sleeved sweaters to cover the bruises she gets because of her disease. Of course people do find out about her disease. (Well, duh… she stayed at the same hospital as the nursing school.) Crystal had to have her stomach cleaned, I think. It is very painful and she couldn’t take it. Ah gei helps her by encouraging her to stay in the hospital. Her family comes back from Switzerland. Crystal’s mom decided to give up one of her kidneys for her. Crystal’s father and brothers operates on them. Of course she lives in the end. She also realizes that doctors need and rely on nurses. Without nurses the doctors wouldn’t seem that great.

Goo Goo
She is the one character you should pity in this series. She seems happy and all in the beginning. (She also makes me laugh a little because I will always remember her character as Ah King on Kindred Spirit.) She has a good husband who is a doctor. She doesn’t have kids and doesn’t want kids. Her husband makes her happy. They live in a nice apartment.

It’s like that old saying “It too good to be true.” Her husband really wants to have children. When she wants to have children, it’s too late. She became infertile. Her husband buys a puppy though, they named him jei jei. Later on, she finds out that her husband is cheating on her with his secretary(why do men always have affairs with secretaries). His secretary is pregnant with his child. Goo goo and her husband files for divorce.

Goo Goo sees her long lost father again in the hospital she works in. He is sick and dying. She is angry with him at first that she avoids talking to him. She has ambivalent feelings towards him. It is too late to even say goodbye to him. He dies in the hospital. The scene where she cries for her father makes me want to cry.

All of the characters graduate from nursing school. No one dies. Charlie is with Ah Gei. Crystal decides to stay being a nurse. Charlie’s parents come back from Hawaii. Bobo is dating Chan Ga Lok. Ah Leng gets her doctor…ahem…a veterinarian. Dai Lo Fai shows up at the graduation with his girlfriend.

Comments
On a scale of 1 to 10, I have to give this series a 3. I have to say that this is possibly one of the worst TV series I have ever seen. The acting was horrible. The plot was predictable because of the clichés. Boy meets girl, boy and girl dislike each other, boy and girl make up, boy and girl become friends and then good friends and then voila you have boy and girl becomes a couple. You know that no one dies because it is always given away by the clips in the beginning. I don’t even know why the producers like giving away the ending.

It’s pretty hard for me to like this series because I’ve gotten so used to American television. It has been almost three years since I watched any TVB series or Chinese series. I ended on Kindred Spirit, which I didn’t finish watching (it was so long but I liked it), now I begin again by watching this series. I definitely did not start on the right foot. Whenever they have operation scenes in the emergency room it’s not as intense or real. If anyone has ever watched ER on NBC they would know what I am talking about. Why do nurses have to wear such tacky uniforms? What I meant to say is that White Flame doesn’t really try hard to show a good portrayal of a real hospital.

I did not like any of the female characters as a person, except maybe Crystal. They were all very stupid and dumb. They remind of rich white girls that talk about stupid things while chewing bubble gum. How the hell did they get into nursing school? It’s kind of scary to have them working on patients. I would not want to be in that hospital. Crystal is probably the only that knows what she’s doing but she was really cold. Brr… I felt sorry for her towards the end of the series. I liked Goo Goo too. I felt that Goo goo, Crystal and Ah Gei were more important than the main character.

I really hate, no…hate is a strong word, I mean I really dislike Charmaine Sheh because I don’t think she could act at all. Some people also think that she’s drop dead gorgeous or something to that affect. Hearing that makes me laugh so hard that I could puke. There are so many more actresses that are way more gorgeous than she would ever be. I still have to give Charmaine a little credit because I think that she acted a little better in Country Spirit or Herbalist Affair.

The best actor and actresses in here would have to be Samuel Chan, Hong Chi Nei, and Yuen Kay Dan, even though it was mediocre, I guess its something I should expect from bad scripts.

I got these tapes for free and thought it was a total waste of time. Don’t borrow these tapes even if they paid you to watch it. I think it’s a waste of time, unless you actually like Charmaine and girls who act stupid.

Rating
N/A

Share:

The White Flame [TVB]

Written by Jeanne


"On a scale of 1 to 10, I have to give this series a 3. I have to say that this is possibly one of the worst TV series I have ever seen..."




SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS!





Chinese Title
Hoong Yee Seou Gei (which had nothing to do with the English title, although they never do)

Episodes
20

Produced In
2002

Cast-Character
Charmaine Sheh-Charlie Yuk Choi Ling
Samuel Chan-Yung Duc Gei
Hong Chi Nei-Go Hiu Lam (Crystal)
Chan Hoi Yi-Lo Bo Bo
Claire Yiu-Ah Leng
Ling Zi Heen-Chan Ga Lok
Gregory Lee-Mun Geen Fai
Yuen Keng Dan-Goo Mei Lan (Goo Goo)
Chu Mei Mei-Rosemary
Chan Ga Yi-Crystal’s Mom

Language
Cantonese (original)

Plot
This series is basically about a group of twenty year olds who are in nursing school. These student nurses share their experiences and become good friends. Blah…blah…blah…

If you don’t want to read spoilers…stop right now!!! {although I think you’ll expect them}

At the nursing school there are the teacher, Crystal, Ah Gei, Bobo, Ah Leng, and Chan Ga Lok. Later we meet Dai Lo Fai. They all have reasons for being in nursing school. Crystal would like to learn some things before reapplying for med school. Crystal’s main goal is not to become a nurse but a doctor like her father and brothers. Ah Gei remembers when his father was dying and the nurse who took care him and his father. He feels very grateful to the nurse and would like to become a nurse. Bobo does not know what she wants to do but she needs a job. She is afraid of everything. Ah Leng would like to meet a handsome doctor hoping to marry him. She is very superficial. Dai Lo Fai is doing this for the money and had a crush on Charlie. Chan Ga Lok wants to get away from his mother and get a job while he’s at it. He’s the funny guy in the group.

Charlie
The audience first meets Charlie in her parents’ restaurant, “Yuk Gei.” Charlie is in her twenties and still does not have a career. She is not in college but she signed up for nursing school because she loves babies and has hopes of working in the maternity ward. In the beginning there is a misunderstanding between Ah Gei and Charlie on the bus to the nursing school. Charlie thought he was a pervert because she thought he touched her foot but it was actually an old man’s umbrella that touched her foot when ah gei was picking the napkins he dropped. *sigh* did you get all the info from my run-on sentence? Anyways, when they got off the bus, Ah Gei saw Crystal and she helped him get rid of Charlie.

In nursing school the nurse teacher says there are four “hearts,” ngoi sum(love), tong ching sum(sympathy), jat yum sum(responsibility), and shuun sum(confidence). I hope I got the sounds right. Over the three years Charlie and her friends, alternate between work, school, and play. “Play” is usually eating, mostly da been lo at yuk gei or elsewhere. (What’s with that? Charmaine always have these themes with food, makes me all hungry at night.) Ah Gei and Charlie forget about the incident on the bus and become friends. (I see clichés here.) At school they have the boring lectures and tests. Charlie is the worst student in the class. She has not much brain but a lot of sympathy. At work Charlie has been paired with Crystal for the same ward (it was bad enough they had to share a room, they didn’t become friends until they had separate rooms and Charlie helped Crystal get better when she had the flu). They are supervised by a nurse everyone calls Goo Goo. Later on in their rotation, Charlie gets to work in the maternity ward. One of the mothers tried very hard to have a child. She did have one but the baby died from complications. Charlie was very depressed when that happened and decided to quit nursing. She did not to quit because Ah Gei asked her to stay because he liked her. Ah Gei asked her to stay after he got some advice from Dai Lo Fai. (Dai Lo Fai liked Charlie but she didn’t like him that way.) Oh man… that scene where Ah Gei “confessed his love” was so cheesy and yuk maah with that song in the background.

Charlie was having some family problems around this time. She got in a fight with her mother about how she never lets her father do anything. Charlie’s mother had reasons for not letting him drink or overwork. Charlie’s father, Yuk Gei, is sick with liver cancer. He had liver problems when Charlie was younger but kept it from her. He fainted and was sent to the hospital. He found out that he has liver cancer and needs surgery. He does have surgery with complications but was fine afterwards. He and Charlie’s mother go to Hawaii together as like a second honeymoon.

Charlie also has relationship problems with Ah Gei because she thought he was cheating on her with Crystal. Charlie and Ah Gei get back together in the end.

Ah Gei
Ah Gei knew Crystal when they were little and has a crush on her. Ah Gei thinks this is “yuen fen” or fate that they meet again in nursing school. At home he lies to his mother because she does not want him to be a nurse. He says that he works at the airport. He buys imported food for his mother to cover up but he’s not very smart about it because his receipt is there with his mother. When his mom does find out, Charlie tries to help Ah Gei convince her. That does not work. The nurse instructor decided to speak to Ah Gei’s mother because he was falling a little behind in class. That probably did the trick.

An episode or two later ah gei’s mom is sick with gallstones or some kind of stone. She needed a small operation to remove it. In the hospital his mom starts to like Charlie and the idea of her being her daughter in law. She is not very fond of Crystal though. When Crystal was sick he made her rice porridge. When he found out that Crystal never ate any of it but Charlie did he was so angry with her. (How irrational) Around this same time, one of his patients died. He was very depressed as a result. He was taking his anger out on everyone, including his mother and his other patients. Everything was better though when he asked her to stay. Ah gei does lie to Charlie. He didn’t want Charlie to misunderstand his relationship with Crystal which is just friendship. He was trying to help Crystal get through her sickness. Charlie was having a hard time too because her father was sick. Charlie was very angry with him but after he confronted her a few times they get back together.

Crystal
Crystal is a pretty depressed and moody person because she feels very left out of her family. Her father and brothers are doctors. I don’t really know what her mother does but she is really busy. Everyone is busy with their big operations except Crystal. When Crystal was younger, her mother was never home. Crystal resented that. She stormed out of the house when she got angry with her family for not asking her to go to the family trip. When Crystal was sick with the flu, Charlie helped her get better. She made Crystal some food because Crystal didn’t want ah gei’s rice porridge. Crystal finally made friends with Charlie. Crystal’s family knew and understood how she felt. Her mother made her a birthday dinner (well, only the cake). The whole family waited for her but Crystal was at the surprise party that Charlie and the gang threw for her. The next day Crystal went home and her mom was on a plane to Taiwan. (There is always the telephone.)

When Crystal’s mom was there she was very worried because there was an earthquake in Taiwan. (There has to be some obstacle in the relationship to make them realize how important they are to each other -_- duh…). Crystal was sick right after her mom came back. She was packing for a trip to Switzerland with her family. Crystal had kidney failure, I think. She tried to hide it from everyone. Ah Gei found out first when she fainted. She didn’t want anyone to know so she would go to the doctor by herself and dressed in long sleeved sweaters to cover the bruises she gets because of her disease. Of course people do find out about her disease. (Well, duh… she stayed at the same hospital as the nursing school.) Crystal had to have her stomach cleaned, I think. It is very painful and she couldn’t take it. Ah gei helps her by encouraging her to stay in the hospital. Her family comes back from Switzerland. Crystal’s mom decided to give up one of her kidneys for her. Crystal’s father and brothers operates on them. Of course she lives in the end. She also realizes that doctors need and rely on nurses. Without nurses the doctors wouldn’t seem that great.

Goo Goo
She is the one character you should pity in this series. She seems happy and all in the beginning. (She also makes me laugh a little because I will always remember her character as Ah King on Kindred Spirit.) She has a good husband who is a doctor. She doesn’t have kids and doesn’t want kids. Her husband makes her happy. They live in a nice apartment.

It’s like that old saying “It too good to be true.” Her husband really wants to have children. When she wants to have children, it’s too late. She became infertile. Her husband buys a puppy though, they named him jei jei. Later on, she finds out that her husband is cheating on her with his secretary(why do men always have affairs with secretaries). His secretary is pregnant with his child. Goo goo and her husband files for divorce.

Goo Goo sees her long lost father again in the hospital she works in. He is sick and dying. She is angry with him at first that she avoids talking to him. She has ambivalent feelings towards him. It is too late to even say goodbye to him. He dies in the hospital. The scene where she cries for her father makes me want to cry.

All of the characters graduate from nursing school. No one dies. Charlie is with Ah Gei. Crystal decides to stay being a nurse. Charlie’s parents come back from Hawaii. Bobo is dating Chan Ga Lok. Ah Leng gets her doctor…ahem…a veterinarian. Dai Lo Fai shows up at the graduation with his girlfriend.

Comments
On a scale of 1 to 10, I have to give this series a 3. I have to say that this is possibly one of the worst TV series I have ever seen. The acting was horrible. The plot was predictable because of the clichés. Boy meets girl, boy and girl dislike each other, boy and girl make up, boy and girl become friends and then good friends and then voila you have boy and girl becomes a couple. You know that no one dies because it is always given away by the clips in the beginning. I don’t even know why the producers like giving away the ending.

It’s pretty hard for me to like this series because I’ve gotten so used to American television. It has been almost three years since I watched any TVB series or Chinese series. I ended on Kindred Spirit, which I didn’t finish watching (it was so long but I liked it), now I begin again by watching this series. I definitely did not start on the right foot. Whenever they have operation scenes in the emergency room it’s not as intense or real. If anyone has ever watched ER on NBC they would know what I am talking about. Why do nurses have to wear such tacky uniforms? What I meant to say is that White Flame doesn’t really try hard to show a good portrayal of a real hospital.

I did not like any of the female characters as a person, except maybe Crystal. They were all very stupid and dumb. They remind of rich white girls that talk about stupid things while chewing bubble gum. How the hell did they get into nursing school? It’s kind of scary to have them working on patients. I would not want to be in that hospital. Crystal is probably the only that knows what she’s doing but she was really cold. Brr… I felt sorry for her towards the end of the series. I liked Goo Goo too. I felt that Goo goo, Crystal and Ah Gei were more important than the main character.

I really hate, no…hate is a strong word, I mean I really dislike Charmaine Sheh because I don’t think she could act at all. Some people also think that she’s drop dead gorgeous or something to that affect. Hearing that makes me laugh so hard that I could puke. There are so many more actresses that are way more gorgeous than she would ever be. I still have to give Charmaine a little credit because I think that she acted a little better in Country Spirit or Herbalist Affair.

The best actor and actresses in here would have to be Samuel Chan, Hong Chi Nei, and Yuen Kay Dan, even though it was mediocre, I guess its something I should expect from bad scripts.

I got these tapes for free and thought it was a total waste of time. Don’t borrow these tapes even if they paid you to watch it. I think it’s a waste of time, unless you actually like Charmaine and girls who act stupid.

Rating
N/A


Share:

12 August 2002

2009: Lost Memories [Kr]

Written by Funn Lim

"It takes a very brave writer to write such an original and imaginative script. The entire premise of the story may be offensive to some. Japanese may feel this movie insults them, whilst Koreans may feel this movie distorts the very fabric of the truth we all knew. But frankly, the entire premise of this movie is built on two words; What if"

SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS!




IMPORTANT NOTICE
The characters' names in this review was taken from various sources as this reviewer herself did not quite catch their names.

Released In
2002

Origin
South Korea

Directed by
Lee Si-myung

Written by
Lee Sang-hak & Lee Si-myung

Language
Mostly Japanese, some times Korean. The version I saw had English subtitles.

Cast-Character
Kil-Kang Ahn - Lee Myung-Hak
Jang Dong-Gun - Masayuki Sakamoto
Tôru Nakamura - Shojiro Saiko
Jin-ho Seo - Hye-Rin Oh
Goo Shin - Takahashi


Plot
I do not profess to know much about the history of the deep hatred that Koreans has for Japanese but according to this movie, the following events happened;

In 1909, Korean nationalist An Chung-Gun assassinated Japanese statesman Ito Hirobumi, which set in motion the Korean Nationalist cause, where Korea sought independence only to fall into civil war and Korea divided into South and North Korea whilst Japan went into WWII with disastrous results where many people (Chinese, Korean, etc) were murdered and A-boms dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, thus ending what I would call a war that the Japanese deserved to have those A-boms dropped on them As we all know now as the present and true history, that was what really happened. But what if that wasn't what happened? What if, in 1909 the assassin was killed before he could complete his mission and the statesman didn't die? What if Japan later on combined power with USA in WWII, became an ally, dropped the A-bom on Berlin (Nazi Germany) thus ending WWII, Korea never achieved independence, China, Manchuria, Korea all fall into Japan's rule even until the year 2009?

This is the very premise of this movie. What if Korea falls under the Japanese rule?

The movie started in year 2009 where a group of 10 Korean terrorists (or freedom fighters) in an organisation called Hureisenjin burst into an exhibition and all 10 died being killed by JBI (equivalent to FBI) which started a motion of investigations which led to an even bigger conspiracy, At the centre of this conspiracy lies two good friends, one a Japanese named Saiko and another, a Korean (now considered a Japanese) named Sakamoto (with a very Japanese name). These two had been friends for years, where Saiko's wife was Sakamoto's object of infatuation when they were younger. But Sakamoto always had this vision of a young girl whose face he could not clearly see wearing a crescent shaped pendant he could not recognise. After the death of the 10 terrorists, he began to wonder why 10 men were willing to sacrifice themselves for something the even the JBI did not know about? Dots after dots were connected and then Sakamoto realised they were after a Korean artifact used in rituals, such crescent shaped object was actually owned by a group called Inoue Foundation, a very powerful and influential group. When Sakamoto decided to dig deeper into the mystery, his past began to haunt him as his father who was involved in an investigation of an act of terrorism by Hureisenjim many years before was falsely accused of receiving bribe from such terrorist group and was subsequently killed. Sakamoto was himself ashamed of his past when he realised something was amiss. Sakamoto was then framed for the murder he did not commit and he realised, all the people he called his colleagues in the JBI was turning against him, and Saiko too was after Sakamoto, wanting to kill him under the orders of his superior and proclaiming that they were now enemies. Sakamoto narrowly escaped and found himself face to face with a very familiar face whom he could not name, someone he thought he knew once in his deep recesses of his memory and the girl helped him in return, as they were all Koreans. When Sakamoto saw with his own eyes the many deaths that ensued and he heard the truth why the JBI was so keen in killing him, he knew he must stop JBI and the Inoue Foundation. Saiko too knew of the truth and the conspiracy, where the chairman of the present Inoue Foundation used the crescent shaped artifact to travel back in time to change the real history to what was the history in the movie's premise. Sakamoto, having seen all his comrades and the girl he thought he knew died before his eyes went into the time portal to right the wrongs and Saiko with some hesitation jumped into the one way portal with no return to stop Sakamoto from destroying the history and the present he knew.

Will Sakamoto succeed before Saiko got to him first? Will history correct itself?

Comments
It takes a very brave writer to write such an original and imaginative script. The entire premise of the story may be offensive to some. Japanese may feel this movie insults them, whilst Koreans may feel this movie distorts the very fabric of the truth we all knew. But frankly, the entire premise of this movie is built on two words;

What if


I find these two words very intriguing and after having watched this movie, I too wonder, if I am faced with such a truth, will I do a Saiko (meaning preserve the history I knew) or a Sakamoto (correct the history to what it really was). The problem is the choice isn't very obvious.

The year 2009 we see in this movie had what was a false history, and Sakamoto and Saiko at last realised the truth of such lies. But for me, the lie in the end became the truth. Whilst I could write a thesis on whether the 2009 world is a real world or a false real world, I would not debate on such a deep issue. Let me get back to the movie itself. But i must note it will take a Korean to appreciate the impact of the changed future because this movie does not really dwelve into the anomisity of these two nations so those who doesn't know the history would not understand why it is so important to correct the past.

Anyway, excellent premise of a movie, the problem is actually the overzealous art director who seemed to work overtime on the cinematography, including the wind blowing on the bamboo, leaves everywhere, slow-mo in all shootout scenes. This movie is long, and the entire interesting premise was stretched to even a longer time that at times I felt the movie was tedious, and quite boring. The only two reasons I sat through all the endless shootouts and endless freedom fighters vs JBI officers is because of Jang Dong-Gun and I wanted to know the ending for Sakamoto and Saiko. Actually I would think these two factors is enough for any fan of Korean/Japanese movies to sit through the rather confusing plot (at first) to know the deeper meaning of this movie.

Like I have said above, the writer was very brave in speculating what could not have been and making it, weaving it into a believable past and present of this movie. The beginning scene was excellent, where the false history was presented and you will read every line confused, as that wasn't the history we knew. The explanation seems logical and possible, though don't expect an in depth explanation on the function of the crescent shaped artifact or any time travel notions. Just take it as it is, and enjoy the other posed questions of what ifs and believe me, you too will leave the cinema wondering, what if the present we knew is false, what if we live in a present which was built on a false past. would we change it or would we maintain it? To me, the false past has indeed become the real present but then that is a very academic question. When you're the oppressed Koreans you too would want to fight for your independence.

Frankly I am on neither side. I may be too young to say this but after WWII and what the Japanese did to the Chinese, I really don't care much for what their past, present will be in this movie however much I like Saiko and I may be childish to say thus, but after the obviously rigged World Cup games in Korea/ Japan year 2002, I really don't care if the Koreans is a slave to the Japanese in the present world. But for the sake of China that in this movie fell into the hands of Japanese, I guess I'll be Sakamoto.

And one point I do like about this movie about all others. Korean Sakamoto has a very Japanese name, he works for JBI, he eats Sushi, he lives, walks and talks like a Japanese but in the end, he became a Korean fugitive. Sad isn't it?

Anyway, interesting that this movie is made by a Korean when the dialogue and the actors, if I am not mistaken are mostly Japanese. It is quite amazing though the Japanese were not offended with this movie but I do wonder, did it do well in Japan?

Favourite Scenes
When Sakamoto befriended a tough little Korean boy (I thought the boy was a girl, why on Earth he looked like a girl?) who was shot by JBI before his eyes and he saw the pictures the little boy was trying to cling on to, the pictures of the little boy and her father. His father was one of the 10 men Sakamoto killed, and that was when that man screamed at Sakamoto, branding him a traitor to the cause of the Koreans freedom fighters who were trying to correct history. When Sakamoto realised that he killed the boy's father and the boy dying before his eyes, he snapped and he screamed. That was a very good scene, very emotionally charged.

The almost ending scene where Saiko and Sakamoto faced off in the past of 1909, with Sakamoto pointing his gun at the chairman of Inoue Foundation who was in turn pointing his gun at the assassin who was pointing his gun at the Japanese Statesman. On top of that, Saiko was pointing his gun at Sakamoto. It was a question who starts the firing first and it was indeed because either way Saiko or Sakamoto had to die making sure history remains as it is, whether from Sakamoto's point of view or Saiko's point of view.

The very end scene in the modern year of 2009 in Korea where a little girl saw the picture of Korean heroes in the past who helped achieved Korea's independence and well...just look out for that scene.

Most Favourite Scene
Every time Jang Dong-Gun's left or right side of his face facing the screen. As a woman, I can't help but melt at the sight of his handsome side profile.

Worst Scenes
Very high body counts, until I lost count. Honest! The shooting just went on and on and on and worst of all, all in slow-mo which tends to make this whole movie tedious. The reason why this movie was 130 minutes long was because 45 minutes or so was spent on slow-mo shoot outs where JBI officers and terrorists kept dying and dying, bullets kept flying everywhere. A bit unrealistic in this aspect.

Performances Evaluated
I only know two actors, the rest are gave credible performances.

Tôru Nakamura
Japanese actor playing what else but Japanese Saiko. He gave an impressive performance though compared to Jang Dong-Gun, he had very little screen time. At times his Saiko seemed confused, but in the end I could understand why he went all the way to stop Sakamoto. After all, the history you know may not be the real history, but for years you knew it as real, so being a true patriotic Japanese, however ill gotten the present history may have been, Japan being a super power and all, even as an honest Japanese, you can't let it all go down the drain. In that aspect, he played Saiko's dilemma and determination well. You can't blame his Saiko.

Jang Dong-Gun
I have heard a lot of this Korean heart throb, the star of All About Eve and many more. Seen his pictures only twice or so, heard about his Chinese features (plus a very Chinese name, Zhang Dong Jian) and his handsome face. Saw the movie poster and had to agree, both the stars looked good, stylish. And then I saw this movie. Let's just say I am determined to watch all his Korean TV series. Not only did he spoke good enough Japanese (he' a Korean by the way), he played his character Sakamoto with enough of confusion, hatred, pain, confusion, guilt and ultimately regret with so much human emotion, I thought "well well well, this is a bloody good dramatic actor without being overly dramatic". It helps of course he has such a beautiful profile, isn't skinny without any body shape and he has a very deep voice, though he didn't speak much in this movie. He could do the action sequences very well and very convincing to boot and best of all, best best best of all, did I mention he is eye candy to me? You know, sweet to look at? Whilst my review wouldn't have much credibility if I based my entire observation and comments on his good looks but I must admit, he is a very Chinese looking and a very good looking Korean actor, better looking in fact than Bae Young-Jun BUT both as good in the acting departments, thought I personally feel Jang Dong-Gun is a slightly better and more varied actor. I read that he took months to learn his lines in Japanese, and mind you whilst this movie may be tagged as a Korean movie, the dialogue is 80% Japanese, and he spoke 90% Japanese. I would say his effort was commendable and really, a fan of his will love this movie. After all, he is the hero in this movie.

Verdict
A definite must buy for any fans of Jang Dong Gun and action genre. If the guys do not interest you or the story does not excite you, at least the stylish direction will interest you a little so as to encourage you to watch this movie from start to the end. This movie could have been so much more but as it is now, it's really entertaining.

Rating


A Question To All
Will you be a Saiko or a Sakamoto?

Interesting Answer
If you're wondering the following, fret not Funn is here!

Who is that girl Sakamoto kept seeing in his dreams?
Definitely not the present girl in the false present. She is actually from the real past, perhaps some relatives of the present girl in the false present. The reason why Sakamoto had memories of her is because after all, time travel is like jet lag you know, there are some side effects. You may remember stuff which may have happened in the past but the past has yet to materialise. Confusing eh?

An update [11.09.2005 ]: Saw the movie again and I remember it was mentioned that the new future knew about the real future because a female reseacher was dragged into the time travel portal and lived until old age. Could it be that Sakamoto was a reseacher together with this woman he saw in his dreams, like some vague buried memory? Try not to over exert yourself on this point since the director did not even bother to clear this confusion.

Was Sakamoto's father really a cop who took bribes from the Korean terrorists?
No. His father actually tried to travel back in time to change the course of history into the original history but was killed instead. He was then defamed by the Japanese counterpart.

So Saiko and Sakamoto can't go back once they crossed the time portal?
Yes.

Is Korea doing better now in the real present than in the movie's false present?
Nobody wants to be subjected to the governance of some country other than your own, so I guess South Korea is doing better now. But please do not remind me of 2002 World Cup.

When the real past was changed into the false past, we see the present 2009. If Sakamoto changed it into a real past what would that mean?
It would mean some people may not exist, like Saiko may not have existed, etc etc etc. Like I said, time travel is tricky, the end may be the beginning and the beginning may be the end. I myself is confused.

Is there such a thing called time travel?
I do not know but I believe you can travel into the future but you can't travel to the past. What's done is done. You can't turn back time because time is constant and time moves only forward, never back works, even if I were to rewind the clock to 3 pm when it is actually 5 pm, what I am doing in effect is cheating myself that this is now 3 pm and not the real 5 pm. Why cheat yourself when you can just admit, it's 5 pm now and I so I must do something to make sure by the time it's 6pm I have not wasted 1 hour of my time thinking how to turn back to 4 pm. And quite frankly I don't think you can even time travel to the future come to think about it since the future has yet to happen and so how can one travel to an uncertain timeline?

So how did Saiko and Sakomoto and that chairman of the organisation travelled back in time?
Using the crescent shaped object. But don't expect this movie to explain how. Just appreciate the premise of the story and forget about logic.

So who was the man who assassinated the assassin who tried to assassinate the statesman in the beginning scene?
The chairman of Inoue Foundation, though we thought it was his great great grandfather or something. Actually it was the same man who traveled back in time to stop the important assassination which sparked the Korean revolution so to speak.

So were those dead Koreans terrorists or freedom fighters?
Depends on how you see them. Muslim world may view Al-Qaeda as freedom fighters, crusaders but we all see them as terrorists. The line there is more obvious but in this movie, it may not be so clear. Like someone once told me, a freedom fighter to a man may be a terrorist to another.

Is it possible for the little boy to live again in the real future?
It's a hopeful and optimistic ending. But let's not forget, there was a very bloody civil war after the events in this movie so in most probability this boy may not even exist as his grandpa may have been drafted and then killed in war. But again it is an optimistic ending though I have my own preferred ending, however impossible that may be.

Preferred Ending
The ending scene showed the little boy as a young student visiting the museum and saw Sakamoto in a picture of freedom fighters. Frankly, I would prefer that Saiko now a tourist in Korea with his wife and daughter Keiko looking over the pictures and saw Sakamoto and somehow he thought he knew this guy. I mean I like Saiko and I want him to have a good end you know.

Interesting Drool Factor
I just had to put this lovely side profile of a picture here. Notice the ultra stylish glasses, and their serious expressions. Notice they're actually at eye level but in the movie I kinda thought Jang Dong-Gun is about half a head shorter than the Japanese actor. Anyway, girls, together now...sighhhhhhhhhh

Free Image Hosting at www.ImageShack.us



Share:

Labels, Archive and the usual sidebar contents are at the bottom of this page.