Latest Posts
One moment pls. Loading 10 latest posts...

29 August 2004

Vive La Famille [MediaCorp]

Written by Funn Lim




"A very well acted ensemble cast in any series I have seen though the plot is all too familiar. Watch this series to see the differences in acting approaches in HK, Taiwan and Singapore."





SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS!









Title deciphered

Why such a pretentious title? The Chinese title, Hau Er Hau Nu was better. I mean why not "Good Sons, Good Daughters"?



Cast-Character

Chen Shucheng - Sun Yongshun

Edmund Tay - Sun Yuguo

San Yow - Sun Yutai

Huang Biren - Sun Yumin

Gary Yap - Sun Yuan

Richard Low - Sun Yongfa

Li Yinzhu - Zeng Shixuan

Lin Meijiao - Stella Sim

Chen Hanwei - Thomas Pang

Patricia Mok - Pat Lok

Chen Huihui - Huang Huifen

Joey Ng - Liang Xiaoqi

Unknown - Sun Jieming

Unknown - Tony





About ...

100% family drama set in modern Singapore, produced by MediaCorp and released in 2001 but only shown in Malaysia in 2004.



No. Of Episodes

20



Released In

I have a feeling it could be 2001 or 2002. Quite old series.



Episode Summary & Character Analysis

The great thing about MediaCorp is they have one specific site for each of their series, so all info can be found HERE. Be forewarned though, their episode summaries are highly undependable, often giving wrong info. For one, they wrote Thomas Pang is a chaunivistic man, frankly I find him the most agreeable man there is. The only chauvinist in here comes in the form of a very prejudiced Sun Yu-min. Everything else, the plot and all are quite accurate. You can even find character analysis, some interviews, not many pictures.



The Plot

This series revolves around the lives, loves, joys and pains of patriarch, Sun Yongshun's family. Widowed decades ago (wife was a lawyer from a very rich family who gave up her career to marry a penniless teacher despite the objections of her mother, the matriarch who in later years accepted her daughter's choice of husband and later wife died of illness at a very young age), he worked as a teacher/headmaster to bring up his 4 children into decent human being. He also tried hard to fulfill his duties and responsibilities as a father, therefore often making many sacrifices his children took lightly.



His eldest son, Yuguo is a businessman married to a very materialistic and spendthrift wife and they have a son, Jieming whom old man Sun dotes upon. But since marriage they moved out and it upsets him that he rarely sees his son, wife and grandson who are always busy socialising. One day all 3 moved back into the old house on the pretense of taking care of old man Sun, but actually they secretly planned to migrate to Canada and even bought a house there. So they were just home to save a bit of cash since old man Sun pays for everything. Although Stella, the wife of Yuguo is often at loggerheads with old man Sun about the education of Jieming (she often pressures Jieming to get into EM1 so as not to lose face to Jonathan's mother whom we never see and Jieming often felt so much pressure he cried and old man Sun felt absolutely helpless), life was quite alright until Yuguo lost a whole lot of money when playing with shares. His wife refuses to sell any of their houses and facing bankruptcy, he begged his father for help and in the process mortgaged the family house to the bank. And then old man Sun found out they actually secretly planned to migrate to Canada and in anger, had a stroke and fell into a deep coma. Naturally everybody blamed Yuguo and wife, I too blamed him.



His second son, Yutai is a very quiet man who steers clear of any controversy, much to the disappointment of his wife, Huifen. Although Huifen felt shortchanged in terms of old man Sun's love for her husband, she often helped out with the family chores. When Stella returned, all hell broke loose, first with the maid, then with the washing machine, then with the mortgaging of the house. Because of lack of money, Huifen decided to study to better herself and therefore any plans to start a family was delayed. Then uncle Yongfa took Yutai to a local karaoke bar and Huifen though Yutai was having an affair out there and left the family home but only to come back when Yu-tai went to see her after many days. Once home she became pregnant but felt so angry that her father in law is doing so much for Yuguo and so little got Yutai, she had to be hospitalised. In the end, all well's will always end well. Yeah, they had a baby.



Third child is the only daughter, Yumin who is the most successful of them all. A career woman in her early 30s, her father often worries about her love life and often wishes that she puts aside her career and find a decent man. But Yumin has a high standard for her man and even her job, so no man met her requirements. One day she met Thomas Pang, a successful ad executive who was working with her on several projects. She hated him because she thought he was rude, inconsiderate and a cad due to several wrong impressions. Thomas did his best to steer clear from her and her icy cold stares until they both shared a common friend; Tony a real estate agent dating Yumin's best friend, Pat. When Pat pressured Yu-min to move out to share an apartment with her, her father disallowed that but later relented. However not long after Pat married Tony and moved out. In the end Thomas was her new house mate. From wrong impressions to the right ones, they fell in love and spent one night of passion. Thomas who lost his parents when he was a teenager appreciated the attention given by Yu-min's family and Yumin who never really fell in love liked Thomas' gentleness towards her. And then one day Thomas asked Yu-min to leave her job, marry him and move to New York with him. She flatly refused, Thomas felt she didn't give serious thought to what he said so he suggested they go there for a holiday first. Not that she didn't try to get leave from her boss but it was all during a very busy time so she couldn't. Thomas mistook that as her refusal to be with him and left for New York alone. Yumin missed Thomas but since both are as career-minded and she will never leave her job as this would be surrendering her independence, what will happen to this couple?



The youngest is Yuan, old man Sun's favourite son. Nothing much happens to him except he was supposed to be studying business admin but changed to filmmaking and back home he fell in love with a sweet simple girl whose only problem is having a senile mother.



The entire series basically is about how a father has to learn to let go of his children and let them live their own lives, and how he can find love again. Yes, even at the age of 62, he can still find love which is a very positive thing. But anyway that never materialise. Feel a bit cheated.



Comments

Basically there is nothing spectacular about the plot of this series. It is a family drama, not much drama happens, just some bickering and some love issues. Even for 20 episodes, sometimes this series just drags along without really having a real destination. The characters in this series aren't exactly colourful to make a very dramatic and engaging plot. For one, all 4 siblings generally have very good relationship with one another and with their father, uncle, aunt and maternal grandmother. So you won't find any heartfelt bickering between siblings or with their parent. In fact I find all of them very loving and respectful towards one another. So the only characters that could give this series a bit of spice are Hui Fen and Stella, the two sisters in law. Even that I find their bickering tiresome. How much more can one fight about a washing machine? Apparently quite a lot, at least for 3 to 4 episodes. But it's real. I fight with my sister in law over my shoes. Little things make real plot but not necessarily an engaging one.



One possible dramatic point is the relationship between the eldest son, Yuguo and his father. It is evident the father loves this son a lot and yet this son is quite an absentee. I am not saying he is useless, he is a bad son, but he just doesn't really show concern much, which is typical even in real life. He pampers his wife (because he loves her) making her rather obnoxious and rude (though she still gives face to her father in law because her husband gives face to his own father-see the pattern?) and he loves his son, but he was rarely there. He indulges his father and yet doesn't really feel guilt when he makes mistakes. And when he does make real mistakes and his father suffers because of that, he actually has a conscience and genuinely wants to make it up to his father. Is he a bad son? Difficult to say. I don't think he is but he married a bad woman so to speak. She dictates him, as very obvious in this series and their plans to migrate to Canada. One of the best and most emotional charged scene was when his father found out about their plans and his father for the first time screamed and shouted and the shut could say nothing. It was a very well acted scene. Another one was when Yu-guo pleaded with his father to perhaps sell the family house to save his skin (you know his wife could have sold one of their houses-this was when Yu-guo became despicable and an utterly useless son) and his father tearfully reprimanded him and Yuguo (and Edmund Tay's best acting moment) couldn't help but cried, really really big drop of tears. Amazing scene.



And the other point of drama is Stella's relationship with her son, Jieming. This is probably one of the few points in this series that is heart wrenching. As Stella tries hard to save face for herself, it is a surprise her son didn't just jump off the building everytime she mentions "Don't make me lose face to Jonathan's mother, get 100% marks, get into EM1, study, study, study". Often she beats her sons for the flimsiest reasons and her son is made to bear a very heavy burden, thinking he did wrong when he did his best. The best contrast of a caring person is Yuguo's secretary and the way she treated Jieming (with such tenderness and care) and his own mother (who blamed Jieming for failing an exam paper simply because he suffered an acute stomach ache and had to be hospitalised!).



But perhaps the more interesting dramatic point is old man Sun's concern for Jieming and Stella insistence that what she is doing is best for her own son. Often their quarrels over Jieming are the most interesting scenes, providing a very realistic scenes which is at times infuriating, but too few, too few.



Then there are stories about friendship (Yumin and her ultra modern best friend in terms of looks, Pat) which is cartoonish and boring and love (courtesy mainly by Yu-min and Thomas) which is rather lovely.



Of all these relationships outside of the family, I find Yumin and Thomas' relationship the most engaging. From the simple prejudices, misunderstandings and Yu-min's arrogance and Thomas' I-Don't-Care attitude to a very believable love affair and then marriage, I like the progression of this relationship. Basically Yumin, who is one of my most favourite modern heroine is a really nice girl. She's a loving sister, a very dependable sister in law, a good aunt, a nice niece and a very filial daughter. But when it comes to her career, she is the iron lady, unable to compromise in anything. Thomas became her object of hate and disgust when she thought he was rude to a lady, fighting for a parking space, and what nots. All small problems and when they're forced to live together in close proximity, it wasn't easy but they managed and all that blossomed into love. It's a bit cliche but frankly I think this relationship and its progression very entertaining.



Other than that, the rest of the love stories are basically and utterly boring.



Now as I have mentioned above, the main selling point in this series is not really the plot or even the characters though I like some of them and hate most of them (Yutai for one, I believe if he's not such a nice guy he will be termed as a useless guy who never stood up for himself or for his wife). The main selling point for me is because I just finished watching Holland V and then I saw the trailer for this series which was taking over Holland V's time slot. I recognised 4 actors from Holland V who are now playing characters that are total opposites of their characters in Holland V and that in itself is shocking to me, shocking enough for me to tune in to watch this series. Then I saw two other actors that I have often heard about in discussion forums but never seen them act, one actor from my favourite Singaporean movie and one actress from another series I have seen some time ago. Then there are 2 Malaysians (I am sure the guy is a Malaysian, can't be sure about the girl) and feeling a bit patriotic, I had to watch this series like I watched Auguste Kwan in his first dismal acting job in Battle Against Evil. There was also one actress that I was very happy to see, even only for a second or so. Are you wondering who I am talking about? Wonder no more!



Holland V's Actors

Edmund Tay

The biggest shock was Edmund Tay (Zheng Geping) who plays Yuguo in here. He was like 100% u-turn from his very patient, gentle and loving character in Holland V that is Dr Fang Nuowen, my most favourite male character in that series and the best man there is (apart from my current obsession, Shaun Chen). In this series he is not a bad guy, just not that decent a guy. Ordinary, plain, unable to control his wife and sometimes using his own father, he's not really that bad but I won't say he's a decent enough guy. He gave perhaps the best performance in this series with his laid back attitude, his flirtation with his wife Stella and the one scene that made me tune in into this series; when his father tearfully asked him why had to get himself into the mess with those shares and Yu-guo was crying, really really crying. That was a very emotional scene. I am still shocked actually. What a wonderful performance!



San Yow

The second most shocking one is San Yow who plays Yutai in here. In Holland V, he was my most hated character where he played Ah Ming, that sex starved, limping, balding, abusive, rude chicken rice seller. In this series I still do not like him but he's not that bad, just sex starved and timid. Yes, sex starved again. Is it because of how he looks? I am just so surprised, what a shave, office clothes, a pair of glasses and a very timid demeanour can do to an actor. I would say the 100% u-turn was very interesting to watch, but again I dislike Yutai. At times I pity Hui Fen having married a man with zero opinion.But he did gave his opinion at the most important moment, when his sis in law insisted that Yuguo go for a medical check up when their dad laid dying from a stroke. He gave his big brother quite a lecture. Other than that this man is infuriatingly too docile and nice.



Chen Sucheng

The third most shocking one is old man Sun himself played by Chen Sucheng. In Holland V, he had little scenes but lucky guy, he spent most scenes hugging, kissing and sleeping next to gorgeous Jamie Yeo who played his young lover. Yes he was the rich banker, supposedly in his 70s or 80s called Steven. In here he is supposed to be 62 years old. I suspect this actor is younger but always had to play older, much much older man. I find his performance beyond satisfactory, in fact I think he was one of the best in here. I especially liked his interaction with that young actor who played Jieming.



Patricia Mok

The least shocking one is Patricia Mok. Least shocking because in real life I believe she is exactly like Pat Lok, except less blonde. In Holland V she was the timid but kind hearted Mo Lingling, a 100% u-turn from her usual characters that lack style, elegance and finesse. Her performance in here is cartoonish, I'd rather see her as subdued Lingling actually.



Two actors I have heard about but never seen

Chen Hanwei

For one Chen Hanwei, whom I believe is like a heartthrob in Singapore? When I first saw him, my impression was who is this Bae Yongjun wannabe? His hair, his glasses all kind looks like you-know-who from Winter Sonata. Then his lips, so red, so glossy. Too red, too glossy. He had more lipstick on than Huang Biren! But I like his performance, as the rather cool, calm, nice, understanding Thomas who had to give in to the demands and restrictions placed by Yu-min than Yu-min giving in to him. Mediacorp website listed his character as a chauvinist. If Thomas is a chauvinist, then no man in this world can be considered a considerate man. His Thomas is hungry for a family life, as he lacked that when he was younger, he may be ambitious but he was ready to give it all up simply because family to him is more important. Yu-min is dead stubborn but not necessarily a bad woman. But sometimes I do wonder, is Yu-min worth it all? Thomas is indeed one of the nicest guy you can see on TV and Chen Hanwei's portrayal gave him a genuine niceness, no arrogance, no airs, just a simple guy who so happens to be very successful in what he does who has simple needs and simple wants. But is Chen Hanwei really a heartthrob? He lacks that dashing aura that one would associate with heartthrobs, in my humble opinion. But he does have that ordinary guy appeal, someone you just like, though I suspect it may be because of his hairstyle which suits him, though however Bae Yong-jun lookalike.



Huang Biren

Huang Biren has a name I really like to pronounce, again Huang Biren. Such a powerful sounding name you know. This actress I believe is not young but she looks young. My first impression of her was, she talked too fast, way too fast and she looked weird. But by the 3rd episode, I was so used to her way of talking, it didn't matter anymore and I began to see beyond her one annoying trait (that is talking too fast) and just concentrate on her acting. First of all, may I say I have seen quite a lot of beautiful actresses on the screen but only very few manages to look more beautiful as the series went by. Fann Wong for one is the camera's favourite girl and then there's Huang Biren. Her hair suits her perfectly and she looks gorgeous. Her dress sense in here is sexy and yet conservative, elegant and yet wild in a very conservative way. I love her clothes in here. Her make up is only just, not too much and I definitely love her lip gloss. And she is tall, very tall. Figure wise, she is a bit like Patricia Mok, no figure, just thin but well models look best when they're fully dressed so I think she is gorgeous. Acting wise, she is wonderful. Her icy stares, her cold disposition when with Chen's Thomas and her gentleness when with her father. There is a contrast between the career woman and the family woman. Very good performance.



One actor from my favourite Singaporean movie

Richard Low

That is Richard Low from I Not Stupid fame, perhaps his best role todate. I can still remember his "Lin Beh" lines from the movie. If there's one Singaporean movie you have got to watch, I Not Stupid would be it and then you'll understand why Stella and Jieming acted the way they did. Anyway, his performance in here as the nosy uncle is perhaps the worst acting in this series. Totally unconvincing, very juvenile and totally annoying character, it's amazing he was my favourite adult actor in I Not Stupid. It didn't help that his character in here has little to do.



One actress from another series I have seen some time ago

Lin Meijiao

That is Lin Meijiao who plays Stella Sim. I first saw her in Brotherhood, a very good series and she played the god mother who favoured Christopher Lee and mistreated Jordan Chan. I remember saying her performance in there was very good. In here she's playing again a very irritating and unreasonable character but less spiteful. I dislike her Stella, the way she places more importance in saving her face than actually caring for her son's needs, the way she uses the family for her own personal gain and the way she pushes her husband to do something her husband shouldn't be doing. Of course the husband should say no but this woman, like Yu-min is very pushy. The thing is Yu-min is pushy only when working but this Stella is always pushy. However, her performance, though noisy is top notch and her best scenes are always when she is scolding her son and she cries whilst doing so. It's rather conflicting, that she mistreats her son in a certain way but I am sure she thinks whatever she is doing is for her son's own good.



Then there are 2 Malaysians...

Gary Yap

I reserve my comments on Joey Ng as being a Malaysian but Gary Yap who plays Yuan is definitely a Malaysian who won the Star Search I think the year this series was released. Don't take my word for it but I read this somewhere. Cute boy, a very eager actor, competent actor but lacking that star like charisma. I think time and an image consultant may be able to change all that. It's just that some actors just walk out and you'll know, they have got the IT factor. This actor, I am still trying to see that factor. It's less about the characters they play but more about that charisma, that aura, those that will guarantee you the idol like status. So he may lack that but I think he is a competent actor, only if he stops adding "ah" at the end of his every sentence. Sounds like some Taiwanese Qiong Yau series ... "Ba, ni sui pah, ah!" ("Father, sleep, ah!"). Of course his character's predicament is very silly. He got a job with MediaCorp, and with little experience he quit his job to try and raise like quarter of a million of Singaporean dollars to make his first artistic movie. Even Steven Spielberg had to start with something more commercial and perhaps smaller budget.



Joey Ng

Now the girl, Joey Ng playing Liang Xiaoqi. She is pretty and has a very likeable face. Acting wise she is ok, only that she looks nervous and morose in the entire series. I was thinking what's her problem? Why she looks so nervous? Is it because this is her first acting job and she has substantial scenes or because her character is perpetually nervous? She reminds me of Shirley Yeung, except she can act better. Again lacking that star quality that time and an image consultant may be able to change. What I find funny is Yumin was looking for a fresh new look to represent her cosmetic company and then she saw this girl and thought she was perfect. I for one thought Yumin looked more like the model with that special look than this girl.



There was also one actress that I was very happy to see...

Li Da Mu

That is Holland V's Ba Gu (Li Da Mu). Here she was just a ke-le-fe, enjoying a meal with her bratty grandchildren at KFC and San Yow was cleaning the mess and she kept apologising. San Yow was her son in Holland V! I think this series was released first before Holland V.



Last but not least ...

The Boy Who Was Jieming

The boy who plays Jieming. What a wonderful young actor. He was shaky at first but with a domineering mother and a timid personality, I find his performance phenomenal, especially when his mother started crying and everything and this boy tearfully cried and say "It's all my fault". He genuinely blames himself for everything bad that happens and his mom just let him be! I really feel for Jie Ming and the pressure he was in.A pity that MediaCorp site did not list his name.



Chen Huihui

And Chen Huihui who plays Huifen. Apparently a very established character actress who had little success in MediaCorp and jumped ship to rival MediaWorks for I guess better prospects. I was very annoyed with her performance simply because she was whispering her lines. After a while I realise that is not whispering, that is restraining herself and spoke very softly. I hated that because I thought she could have shouted her lines when being confronted by such a useless husband and unfair treatment. But overall it is a believable performance. I guess people shouldn't shout too much, which is expected in any TVB series but not in Singapore. I am just very surprised at how restrained they could be and yet in such restrained performance, I see such realness, that is very rare. Maybe I am too used to dramatic kind of acting. By the way I am very shocked to see this same actress in a very unglamarous role playing a mentally challenged woman in The Wing Of Desire. It was a very good performance, very believable but that doesn't mean I like the actress. I still find her annoying and I suspect it's the actress, not the characters.



Verdict

A very well acted ensemble cast in any series I have seen though the plot is all too familiar. Watch this series to see the differences in acting approaches in HK, Taiwan and Singapore. Malaysia is not even there yet. I don't understand; we have wonderful newcomers from Malaysia acting in Singapore who all did so well and yet those who stayed back are all such boring actors? Could it be the script? Anyway this series is nothing spectacular but I urge you to give it a try because sometimes you might be sick watching explosions, family killing family, betrayals and what nots and you just want something smaller, more personal and more intimate in terms of family drama. This is the one for you. And the joy of watching other country's series is most of the time you feel TVB could have done so much better but got too complacent. The lesson I learn from watching the few Singaporean series (which I swear the last 2 I watched were wonderful indication that perhaps MediaCorp is doing much better than its previous predecessors, whatever the name may be, and I saw a few episodes of MediaWorks' Power Of Love which I thought was decent enough) is the difference in acting approaches. In Singapore, because of the lack of actors, the same actor may play 2 totally different roles and often they can pull it off. Edmund Tay is a fine example. TVB seems more keen to typecast their actors than to show what they're capable of.



Rating

A very good .



Ending Revealed

Jieming went looking for his grandpa and was almost kidnapped by a drug addict when Xiao Qi saw Jieming and followed him and bravely rescued Jieming from the clutches of evil people of Singapore! And then they all went to the hospital, Yuguo reconciles with Stella and father was feeling quite alright. Thomas returns and marries Yumin, foregoing his career in New York since she is not willing to forego hers. Yutai and Hui min has a son (I think).Sometime like 1 year from the first episode of this series, again they're cooking to commemorate the death day of old man Sun's wife. Nope, Shixuan never ended up with old man Sun though there were indications they might end up together. Everybody, including Stella helped in the preparations whilst old man Sun sat in his room listening to his old favourite records holding his family picture. When it was time to eat, Jie ming ran in to call his grandpa but old man Sun wasn't moving anymore, looking peaceful, picture fell, shattered glasses and Jieming screamed; "YEHHHHH YEHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!".



THE END.



The end music was hauntingly poignant though, until I realised there is a sequel. Look at P/S for more info.



P/S

There is a sequel to this series called Vive La Famille 2 and I saw the father in the picture which means he didn't die! What is the point of part 1's surprise ending then? Why not he just be dead and part 2 concentrates on his children and their problems? Basically the father has no problems!



And to my utter shock, Chen Hanwei is from Malaysia! How many more from Malaysia? Let's count them all. Gorgeous guys, Chen Hanwei, Christopher Lee Mingshun, Shaun Chen Hongyu ... there's one more in this series itself, who else? Why are they there when we should open our own MediaCorp and make our own stars? What's wrong with our local entertainment industry that we must make series like Homecoming which looks, feels and even is HK's Kindred Spirit which boasts some very bad acting and really bad script? Why must we always put HK 3rd rate actors as leads and push our very own stars way back? Why can't we create our own idols, heartthrobs and casanovas? It's not that we don't have them. We have! Why must they all be in Singapore? Come back! But to what? Sometimes it is unfair to ask them to come back when as an actor I would have chosen MediaCorp, if not TVB or even Hollywood! So frustrating!



By the way I read here that Chen Hanwei was from a very poor family, very very poor. It's just shows what talent, intelligence, good looks, dedication, good mandarin and luck can do for you. Apparently he has been in the business for 14 years (perhaps at the time of posting it could be more) and he is still going strong.



I believe some actors take time to grow as an actor. Once you're a star and a celebrity you might lose sight of who you are. Some actresses are just too concern with fame, earn more money, endorsing slimming products and giving this slim sexy image, sometimes they just forgot what they're supposed to do. Actors generally rarely lose sight as to who they really are, some actresses just got the right stuff that does not stray them away. I have seen far too many untalented people or people with just enough talent (but not much to justify all the leading roles they got) acting in big series, in big roles, in lead roles, getting all the credit not because of how well they perform but because of how good they look. I agree sometimes screen presence justify it all but not all has the IT factor. It's true to say when a series bomb, these actors and actresses will get the public wrath but is that true anymore? There are fans so blinded by their devotion for these group of stars that they will say anything to say that their favourite actors or actresses are the best of the best. I am guilty of the same conduct too sometimes, probably because I genuinely believe this particular person has enough of star quality and talent to make it big and be a better actor though many may differ. I see potential and I hope this prediction is not guided by my blinded devotion. The point is there are many good actors out there languishing in secondary roles (but very memorable secondary roles) whilst not very good actors (especially actresses) hogging the limelight with acting that frankly I think I can do better. I genuinely do think I can really do better, if not a bit different. Some actors found the perfect role and thus gave the performance of their life. Some actors got great roles but screw it all up by not trying. Some try and succeed, some try but failed not because of lack of trying but because not enough research, not enough time, not enough calibre whilst some fail even before trying simply because they have no talent. No talent as in acting, though they may be the best dancer, the best singer, the best pianist, the best mannequin. I can name a few actresses in this category, also some actors as well but I refrain from naming names. Those who reads my reviews will know my sentiments about particular people.



My point is there is a whole new world of great actors and actresses out there. I realise now not to place too much emphasis on plot, just ignore the plot and zoom in on the performances and I find myself discovering many wonderful performances. Singapore certainly impressed me a lot though their series aren't exactly worthy of praise sometimes. Perhaps experience and the chance to act in many types of roles help or maybe, just maybe most of these people got discovered by talent scouts looking for star quality or won talent contests instead of beauty pageants. It's time, I propose that TVB holds a Star Search to discover the next real star who looks not only gorgeous but can act as well. I am sick to death of beauty pageants as a stepping stone to a film career, no matter how good you could be (case in point, Mariane Chen). Which is why however much I may dislike Tavia Yang's earlier performances, I have a grudging respect for this woman. She took the difficult route and now she's enjoying the accolades that she deserves.








Share:

Vive La Famille [MediaCorp]

Written by Funn Lim




"A very well acted ensemble cast in any series I have seen though the plot is all too familiar. Watch this series to see the differences in acting approaches in HK, Taiwan and Singapore."





SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS!









Title deciphered

Why such a pretentious title? The Chinese title, Hau Er Hau Nu was better. I mean why not "Good Sons, Good Daughters"?



Cast-Character

Chen Shucheng - Sun Yongshun

Edmund Tay - Sun Yuguo

San Yow - Sun Yutai

Huang Biren - Sun Yumin

Gary Yap - Sun Yuan

Richard Low - Sun Yongfa

Li Yinzhu - Zeng Shixuan

Lin Meijiao - Stella Sim

Chen Hanwei - Thomas Pang

Patricia Mok - Pat Lok

Chen Huihui - Huang Huifen

Joey Ng - Liang Xiaoqi

Unknown - Sun Jieming

Unknown - Tony





About ...

100% family drama set in modern Singapore, produced by MediaCorp and released in 2001 but only shown in Malaysia in 2004.



No. Of Episodes

20



Released In

I have a feeling it could be 2001 or 2002. Quite old series.



Episode Summary & Character Analysis

The great thing about MediaCorp is they have one specific site for each of their series, so all info can be found HERE. Be forewarned though, their episode summaries are highly undependable, often giving wrong info. For one, they wrote Thomas Pang is a chaunivistic man, frankly I find him the most agreeable man there is. The only chauvinist in here comes in the form of a very prejudiced Sun Yu-min. Everything else, the plot and all are quite accurate. You can even find character analysis, some interviews, not many pictures.



The Plot

This series revolves around the lives, loves, joys and pains of patriarch, Sun Yongshun's family. Widowed decades ago (wife was a lawyer from a very rich family who gave up her career to marry a penniless teacher despite the objections of her mother, the matriarch who in later years accepted her daughter's choice of husband and later wife died of illness at a very young age), he worked as a teacher/headmaster to bring up his 4 children into decent human being. He also tried hard to fulfill his duties and responsibilities as a father, therefore often making many sacrifices his children took lightly.



His eldest son, Yuguo is a businessman married to a very materialistic and spendthrift wife and they have a son, Jieming whom old man Sun dotes upon. But since marriage they moved out and it upsets him that he rarely sees his son, wife and grandson who are always busy socialising. One day all 3 moved back into the old house on the pretense of taking care of old man Sun, but actually they secretly planned to migrate to Canada and even bought a house there. So they were just home to save a bit of cash since old man Sun pays for everything. Although Stella, the wife of Yuguo is often at loggerheads with old man Sun about the education of Jieming (she often pressures Jieming to get into EM1 so as not to lose face to Jonathan's mother whom we never see and Jieming often felt so much pressure he cried and old man Sun felt absolutely helpless), life was quite alright until Yuguo lost a whole lot of money when playing with shares. His wife refuses to sell any of their houses and facing bankruptcy, he begged his father for help and in the process mortgaged the family house to the bank. And then old man Sun found out they actually secretly planned to migrate to Canada and in anger, had a stroke and fell into a deep coma. Naturally everybody blamed Yuguo and wife, I too blamed him.



His second son, Yutai is a very quiet man who steers clear of any controversy, much to the disappointment of his wife, Huifen. Although Huifen felt shortchanged in terms of old man Sun's love for her husband, she often helped out with the family chores. When Stella returned, all hell broke loose, first with the maid, then with the washing machine, then with the mortgaging of the house. Because of lack of money, Huifen decided to study to better herself and therefore any plans to start a family was delayed. Then uncle Yongfa took Yutai to a local karaoke bar and Huifen though Yutai was having an affair out there and left the family home but only to come back when Yu-tai went to see her after many days. Once home she became pregnant but felt so angry that her father in law is doing so much for Yuguo and so little got Yutai, she had to be hospitalised. In the end, all well's will always end well. Yeah, they had a baby.



Third child is the only daughter, Yumin who is the most successful of them all. A career woman in her early 30s, her father often worries about her love life and often wishes that she puts aside her career and find a decent man. But Yumin has a high standard for her man and even her job, so no man met her requirements. One day she met Thomas Pang, a successful ad executive who was working with her on several projects. She hated him because she thought he was rude, inconsiderate and a cad due to several wrong impressions. Thomas did his best to steer clear from her and her icy cold stares until they both shared a common friend; Tony a real estate agent dating Yumin's best friend, Pat. When Pat pressured Yu-min to move out to share an apartment with her, her father disallowed that but later relented. However not long after Pat married Tony and moved out. In the end Thomas was her new house mate. From wrong impressions to the right ones, they fell in love and spent one night of passion. Thomas who lost his parents when he was a teenager appreciated the attention given by Yu-min's family and Yumin who never really fell in love liked Thomas' gentleness towards her. And then one day Thomas asked Yu-min to leave her job, marry him and move to New York with him. She flatly refused, Thomas felt she didn't give serious thought to what he said so he suggested they go there for a holiday first. Not that she didn't try to get leave from her boss but it was all during a very busy time so she couldn't. Thomas mistook that as her refusal to be with him and left for New York alone. Yumin missed Thomas but since both are as career-minded and she will never leave her job as this would be surrendering her independence, what will happen to this couple?



The youngest is Yuan, old man Sun's favourite son. Nothing much happens to him except he was supposed to be studying business admin but changed to filmmaking and back home he fell in love with a sweet simple girl whose only problem is having a senile mother.



The entire series basically is about how a father has to learn to let go of his children and let them live their own lives, and how he can find love again. Yes, even at the age of 62, he can still find love which is a very positive thing. But anyway that never materialise. Feel a bit cheated.



Comments

Basically there is nothing spectacular about the plot of this series. It is a family drama, not much drama happens, just some bickering and some love issues. Even for 20 episodes, sometimes this series just drags along without really having a real destination. The characters in this series aren't exactly colourful to make a very dramatic and engaging plot. For one, all 4 siblings generally have very good relationship with one another and with their father, uncle, aunt and maternal grandmother. So you won't find any heartfelt bickering between siblings or with their parent. In fact I find all of them very loving and respectful towards one another. So the only characters that could give this series a bit of spice are Hui Fen and Stella, the two sisters in law. Even that I find their bickering tiresome. How much more can one fight about a washing machine? Apparently quite a lot, at least for 3 to 4 episodes. But it's real. I fight with my sister in law over my shoes. Little things make real plot but not necessarily an engaging one.



One possible dramatic point is the relationship between the eldest son, Yuguo and his father. It is evident the father loves this son a lot and yet this son is quite an absentee. I am not saying he is useless, he is a bad son, but he just doesn't really show concern much, which is typical even in real life. He pampers his wife (because he loves her) making her rather obnoxious and rude (though she still gives face to her father in law because her husband gives face to his own father-see the pattern?) and he loves his son, but he was rarely there. He indulges his father and yet doesn't really feel guilt when he makes mistakes. And when he does make real mistakes and his father suffers because of that, he actually has a conscience and genuinely wants to make it up to his father. Is he a bad son? Difficult to say. I don't think he is but he married a bad woman so to speak. She dictates him, as very obvious in this series and their plans to migrate to Canada. One of the best and most emotional charged scene was when his father found out about their plans and his father for the first time screamed and shouted and the shut could say nothing. It was a very well acted scene. Another one was when Yu-guo pleaded with his father to perhaps sell the family house to save his skin (you know his wife could have sold one of their houses-this was when Yu-guo became despicable and an utterly useless son) and his father tearfully reprimanded him and Yuguo (and Edmund Tay's best acting moment) couldn't help but cried, really really big drop of tears. Amazing scene.



And the other point of drama is Stella's relationship with her son, Jieming. This is probably one of the few points in this series that is heart wrenching. As Stella tries hard to save face for herself, it is a surprise her son didn't just jump off the building everytime she mentions "Don't make me lose face to Jonathan's mother, get 100% marks, get into EM1, study, study, study". Often she beats her sons for the flimsiest reasons and her son is made to bear a very heavy burden, thinking he did wrong when he did his best. The best contrast of a caring person is Yuguo's secretary and the way she treated Jieming (with such tenderness and care) and his own mother (who blamed Jieming for failing an exam paper simply because he suffered an acute stomach ache and had to be hospitalised!).



But perhaps the more interesting dramatic point is old man Sun's concern for Jieming and Stella insistence that what she is doing is best for her own son. Often their quarrels over Jieming are the most interesting scenes, providing a very realistic scenes which is at times infuriating, but too few, too few.



Then there are stories about friendship (Yumin and her ultra modern best friend in terms of looks, Pat) which is cartoonish and boring and love (courtesy mainly by Yu-min and Thomas) which is rather lovely.



Of all these relationships outside of the family, I find Yumin and Thomas' relationship the most engaging. From the simple prejudices, misunderstandings and Yu-min's arrogance and Thomas' I-Don't-Care attitude to a very believable love affair and then marriage, I like the progression of this relationship. Basically Yumin, who is one of my most favourite modern heroine is a really nice girl. She's a loving sister, a very dependable sister in law, a good aunt, a nice niece and a very filial daughter. But when it comes to her career, she is the iron lady, unable to compromise in anything. Thomas became her object of hate and disgust when she thought he was rude to a lady, fighting for a parking space, and what nots. All small problems and when they're forced to live together in close proximity, it wasn't easy but they managed and all that blossomed into love. It's a bit cliche but frankly I think this relationship and its progression very entertaining.



Other than that, the rest of the love stories are basically and utterly boring.



Now as I have mentioned above, the main selling point in this series is not really the plot or even the characters though I like some of them and hate most of them (Yutai for one, I believe if he's not such a nice guy he will be termed as a useless guy who never stood up for himself or for his wife). The main selling point for me is because I just finished watching Holland V and then I saw the trailer for this series which was taking over Holland V's time slot. I recognised 4 actors from Holland V who are now playing characters that are total opposites of their characters in Holland V and that in itself is shocking to me, shocking enough for me to tune in to watch this series. Then I saw two other actors that I have often heard about in discussion forums but never seen them act, one actor from my favourite Singaporean movie and one actress from another series I have seen some time ago. Then there are 2 Malaysians (I am sure the guy is a Malaysian, can't be sure about the girl) and feeling a bit patriotic, I had to watch this series like I watched Auguste Kwan in his first dismal acting job in Battle Against Evil. There was also one actress that I was very happy to see, even only for a second or so. Are you wondering who I am talking about? Wonder no more!



Holland V's Actors

Edmund Tay

The biggest shock was Edmund Tay (Zheng Geping) who plays Yuguo in here. He was like 100% u-turn from his very patient, gentle and loving character in Holland V that is Dr Fang Nuowen, my most favourite male character in that series and the best man there is (apart from my current obsession, Shaun Chen). In this series he is not a bad guy, just not that decent a guy. Ordinary, plain, unable to control his wife and sometimes using his own father, he's not really that bad but I won't say he's a decent enough guy. He gave perhaps the best performance in this series with his laid back attitude, his flirtation with his wife Stella and the one scene that made me tune in into this series; when his father tearfully asked him why had to get himself into the mess with those shares and Yu-guo was crying, really really crying. That was a very emotional scene. I am still shocked actually. What a wonderful performance!



San Yow

The second most shocking one is San Yow who plays Yutai in here. In Holland V, he was my most hated character where he played Ah Ming, that sex starved, limping, balding, abusive, rude chicken rice seller. In this series I still do not like him but he's not that bad, just sex starved and timid. Yes, sex starved again. Is it because of how he looks? I am just so surprised, what a shave, office clothes, a pair of glasses and a very timid demeanour can do to an actor. I would say the 100% u-turn was very interesting to watch, but again I dislike Yutai. At times I pity Hui Fen having married a man with zero opinion.But he did gave his opinion at the most important moment, when his sis in law insisted that Yuguo go for a medical check up when their dad laid dying from a stroke. He gave his big brother quite a lecture. Other than that this man is infuriatingly too docile and nice.



Chen Sucheng

The third most shocking one is old man Sun himself played by Chen Sucheng. In Holland V, he had little scenes but lucky guy, he spent most scenes hugging, kissing and sleeping next to gorgeous Jamie Yeo who played his young lover. Yes he was the rich banker, supposedly in his 70s or 80s called Steven. In here he is supposed to be 62 years old. I suspect this actor is younger but always had to play older, much much older man. I find his performance beyond satisfactory, in fact I think he was one of the best in here. I especially liked his interaction with that young actor who played Jieming.



Patricia Mok

The least shocking one is Patricia Mok. Least shocking because in real life I believe she is exactly like Pat Lok, except less blonde. In Holland V she was the timid but kind hearted Mo Lingling, a 100% u-turn from her usual characters that lack style, elegance and finesse. Her performance in here is cartoonish, I'd rather see her as subdued Lingling actually.



Two actors I have heard about but never seen

Chen Hanwei

For one Chen Hanwei, whom I believe is like a heartthrob in Singapore? When I first saw him, my impression was who is this Bae Yongjun wannabe? His hair, his glasses all kind looks like you-know-who from Winter Sonata. Then his lips, so red, so glossy. Too red, too glossy. He had more lipstick on than Huang Biren! But I like his performance, as the rather cool, calm, nice, understanding Thomas who had to give in to the demands and restrictions placed by Yu-min than Yu-min giving in to him. Mediacorp website listed his character as a chauvinist. If Thomas is a chauvinist, then no man in this world can be considered a considerate man. His Thomas is hungry for a family life, as he lacked that when he was younger, he may be ambitious but he was ready to give it all up simply because family to him is more important. Yu-min is dead stubborn but not necessarily a bad woman. But sometimes I do wonder, is Yu-min worth it all? Thomas is indeed one of the nicest guy you can see on TV and Chen Hanwei's portrayal gave him a genuine niceness, no arrogance, no airs, just a simple guy who so happens to be very successful in what he does who has simple needs and simple wants. But is Chen Hanwei really a heartthrob? He lacks that dashing aura that one would associate with heartthrobs, in my humble opinion. But he does have that ordinary guy appeal, someone you just like, though I suspect it may be because of his hairstyle which suits him, though however Bae Yong-jun lookalike.



Huang Biren

Huang Biren has a name I really like to pronounce, again Huang Biren. Such a powerful sounding name you know. This actress I believe is not young but she looks young. My first impression of her was, she talked too fast, way too fast and she looked weird. But by the 3rd episode, I was so used to her way of talking, it didn't matter anymore and I began to see beyond her one annoying trait (that is talking too fast) and just concentrate on her acting. First of all, may I say I have seen quite a lot of beautiful actresses on the screen but only very few manages to look more beautiful as the series went by. Fann Wong for one is the camera's favourite girl and then there's Huang Biren. Her hair suits her perfectly and she looks gorgeous. Her dress sense in here is sexy and yet conservative, elegant and yet wild in a very conservative way. I love her clothes in here. Her make up is only just, not too much and I definitely love her lip gloss. And she is tall, very tall. Figure wise, she is a bit like Patricia Mok, no figure, just thin but well models look best when they're fully dressed so I think she is gorgeous. Acting wise, she is wonderful. Her icy stares, her cold disposition when with Chen's Thomas and her gentleness when with her father. There is a contrast between the career woman and the family woman. Very good performance.



One actor from my favourite Singaporean movie

Richard Low

That is Richard Low from I Not Stupid fame, perhaps his best role todate. I can still remember his "Lin Beh" lines from the movie. If there's one Singaporean movie you have got to watch, I Not Stupid would be it and then you'll understand why Stella and Jieming acted the way they did. Anyway, his performance in here as the nosy uncle is perhaps the worst acting in this series. Totally unconvincing, very juvenile and totally annoying character, it's amazing he was my favourite adult actor in I Not Stupid. It didn't help that his character in here has little to do.



One actress from another series I have seen some time ago

Lin Meijiao

That is Lin Meijiao who plays Stella Sim. I first saw her in Brotherhood, a very good series and she played the god mother who favoured Christopher Lee and mistreated Jordan Chan. I remember saying her performance in there was very good. In here she's playing again a very irritating and unreasonable character but less spiteful. I dislike her Stella, the way she places more importance in saving her face than actually caring for her son's needs, the way she uses the family for her own personal gain and the way she pushes her husband to do something her husband shouldn't be doing. Of course the husband should say no but this woman, like Yu-min is very pushy. The thing is Yu-min is pushy only when working but this Stella is always pushy. However, her performance, though noisy is top notch and her best scenes are always when she is scolding her son and she cries whilst doing so. It's rather conflicting, that she mistreats her son in a certain way but I am sure she thinks whatever she is doing is for her son's own good.



Then there are 2 Malaysians...

Gary Yap

I reserve my comments on Joey Ng as being a Malaysian but Gary Yap who plays Yuan is definitely a Malaysian who won the Star Search I think the year this series was released. Don't take my word for it but I read this somewhere. Cute boy, a very eager actor, competent actor but lacking that star like charisma. I think time and an image consultant may be able to change all that. It's just that some actors just walk out and you'll know, they have got the IT factor. This actor, I am still trying to see that factor. It's less about the characters they play but more about that charisma, that aura, those that will guarantee you the idol like status. So he may lack that but I think he is a competent actor, only if he stops adding "ah" at the end of his every sentence. Sounds like some Taiwanese Qiong Yau series ... "Ba, ni sui pah, ah!" ("Father, sleep, ah!"). Of course his character's predicament is very silly. He got a job with MediaCorp, and with little experience he quit his job to try and raise like quarter of a million of Singaporean dollars to make his first artistic movie. Even Steven Spielberg had to start with something more commercial and perhaps smaller budget.



Joey Ng

Now the girl, Joey Ng playing Liang Xiaoqi. She is pretty and has a very likeable face. Acting wise she is ok, only that she looks nervous and morose in the entire series. I was thinking what's her problem? Why she looks so nervous? Is it because this is her first acting job and she has substantial scenes or because her character is perpetually nervous? She reminds me of Shirley Yeung, except she can act better. Again lacking that star quality that time and an image consultant may be able to change. What I find funny is Yumin was looking for a fresh new look to represent her cosmetic company and then she saw this girl and thought she was perfect. I for one thought Yumin looked more like the model with that special look than this girl.



There was also one actress that I was very happy to see...

Li Da Mu

That is Holland V's Ba Gu (Li Da Mu). Here she was just a ke-le-fe, enjoying a meal with her bratty grandchildren at KFC and San Yow was cleaning the mess and she kept apologising. San Yow was her son in Holland V! I think this series was released first before Holland V.



Last but not least ...

The Boy Who Was Jieming

The boy who plays Jieming. What a wonderful young actor. He was shaky at first but with a domineering mother and a timid personality, I find his performance phenomenal, especially when his mother started crying and everything and this boy tearfully cried and say "It's all my fault". He genuinely blames himself for everything bad that happens and his mom just let him be! I really feel for Jie Ming and the pressure he was in.A pity that MediaCorp site did not list his name.



Chen Huihui

And Chen Huihui who plays Huifen. Apparently a very established character actress who had little success in MediaCorp and jumped ship to rival MediaWorks for I guess better prospects. I was very annoyed with her performance simply because she was whispering her lines. After a while I realise that is not whispering, that is restraining herself and spoke very softly. I hated that because I thought she could have shouted her lines when being confronted by such a useless husband and unfair treatment. But overall it is a believable performance. I guess people shouldn't shout too much, which is expected in any TVB series but not in Singapore. I am just very surprised at how restrained they could be and yet in such restrained performance, I see such realness, that is very rare. Maybe I am too used to dramatic kind of acting. By the way I am very shocked to see this same actress in a very unglamarous role playing a mentally challenged woman in The Wing Of Desire. It was a very good performance, very believable but that doesn't mean I like the actress. I still find her annoying and I suspect it's the actress, not the characters.



Verdict

A very well acted ensemble cast in any series I have seen though the plot is all too familiar. Watch this series to see the differences in acting approaches in HK, Taiwan and Singapore. Malaysia is not even there yet. I don't understand; we have wonderful newcomers from Malaysia acting in Singapore who all did so well and yet those who stayed back are all such boring actors? Could it be the script? Anyway this series is nothing spectacular but I urge you to give it a try because sometimes you might be sick watching explosions, family killing family, betrayals and what nots and you just want something smaller, more personal and more intimate in terms of family drama. This is the one for you. And the joy of watching other country's series is most of the time you feel TVB could have done so much better but got too complacent. The lesson I learn from watching the few Singaporean series (which I swear the last 2 I watched were wonderful indication that perhaps MediaCorp is doing much better than its previous predecessors, whatever the name may be, and I saw a few episodes of MediaWorks' Power Of Love which I thought was decent enough) is the difference in acting approaches. In Singapore, because of the lack of actors, the same actor may play 2 totally different roles and often they can pull it off. Edmund Tay is a fine example. TVB seems more keen to typecast their actors than to show what they're capable of.



Rating

A very good .



Ending Revealed

Jieming went looking for his grandpa and was almost kidnapped by a drug addict when Xiao Qi saw Jieming and followed him and bravely rescued Jieming from the clutches of evil people of Singapore! And then they all went to the hospital, Yuguo reconciles with Stella and father was feeling quite alright. Thomas returns and marries Yumin, foregoing his career in New York since she is not willing to forego hers. Yutai and Hui min has a son (I think).Sometime like 1 year from the first episode of this series, again they're cooking to commemorate the death day of old man Sun's wife. Nope, Shixuan never ended up with old man Sun though there were indications they might end up together. Everybody, including Stella helped in the preparations whilst old man Sun sat in his room listening to his old favourite records holding his family picture. When it was time to eat, Jie ming ran in to call his grandpa but old man Sun wasn't moving anymore, looking peaceful, picture fell, shattered glasses and Jieming screamed; "YEHHHHH YEHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!".



THE END.



The end music was hauntingly poignant though, until I realised there is a sequel. Look at P/S for more info.



P/S

There is a sequel to this series called Vive La Famille 2 and I saw the father in the picture which means he didn't die! What is the point of part 1's surprise ending then? Why not he just be dead and part 2 concentrates on his children and their problems? Basically the father has no problems!



And to my utter shock, Chen Hanwei is from Malaysia! How many more from Malaysia? Let's count them all. Gorgeous guys, Chen Hanwei, Christopher Lee Mingshun, Shaun Chen Hongyu ... there's one more in this series itself, who else? Why are they there when we should open our own MediaCorp and make our own stars? What's wrong with our local entertainment industry that we must make series like Homecoming which looks, feels and even is HK's Kindred Spirit which boasts some very bad acting and really bad script? Why must we always put HK 3rd rate actors as leads and push our very own stars way back? Why can't we create our own idols, heartthrobs and casanovas? It's not that we don't have them. We have! Why must they all be in Singapore? Come back! But to what? Sometimes it is unfair to ask them to come back when as an actor I would have chosen MediaCorp, if not TVB or even Hollywood! So frustrating!



By the way I read here that Chen Hanwei was from a very poor family, very very poor. It's just shows what talent, intelligence, good looks, dedication, good mandarin and luck can do for you. Apparently he has been in the business for 14 years (perhaps at the time of posting it could be more) and he is still going strong.



I believe some actors take time to grow as an actor. Once you're a star and a celebrity you might lose sight of who you are. Some actresses are just too concern with fame, earn more money, endorsing slimming products and giving this slim sexy image, sometimes they just forgot what they're supposed to do. Actors generally rarely lose sight as to who they really are, some actresses just got the right stuff that does not stray them away. I have seen far too many untalented people or people with just enough talent (but not much to justify all the leading roles they got) acting in big series, in big roles, in lead roles, getting all the credit not because of how well they perform but because of how good they look. I agree sometimes screen presence justify it all but not all has the IT factor. It's true to say when a series bomb, these actors and actresses will get the public wrath but is that true anymore? There are fans so blinded by their devotion for these group of stars that they will say anything to say that their favourite actors or actresses are the best of the best. I am guilty of the same conduct too sometimes, probably because I genuinely believe this particular person has enough of star quality and talent to make it big and be a better actor though many may differ. I see potential and I hope this prediction is not guided by my blinded devotion. The point is there are many good actors out there languishing in secondary roles (but very memorable secondary roles) whilst not very good actors (especially actresses) hogging the limelight with acting that frankly I think I can do better. I genuinely do think I can really do better, if not a bit different. Some actors found the perfect role and thus gave the performance of their life. Some actors got great roles but screw it all up by not trying. Some try and succeed, some try but failed not because of lack of trying but because not enough research, not enough time, not enough calibre whilst some fail even before trying simply because they have no talent. No talent as in acting, though they may be the best dancer, the best singer, the best pianist, the best mannequin. I can name a few actresses in this category, also some actors as well but I refrain from naming names. Those who reads my reviews will know my sentiments about particular people.



My point is there is a whole new world of great actors and actresses out there. I realise now not to place too much emphasis on plot, just ignore the plot and zoom in on the performances and I find myself discovering many wonderful performances. Singapore certainly impressed me a lot though their series aren't exactly worthy of praise sometimes. Perhaps experience and the chance to act in many types of roles help or maybe, just maybe most of these people got discovered by talent scouts looking for star quality or won talent contests instead of beauty pageants. It's time, I propose that TVB holds a Star Search to discover the next real star who looks not only gorgeous but can act as well. I am sick to death of beauty pageants as a stepping stone to a film career, no matter how good you could be (case in point, Mariane Chen). Which is why however much I may dislike Tavia Yang's earlier performances, I have a grudging respect for this woman. She took the difficult route and now she's enjoying the accolades that she deserves.








Share:

21 August 2004

A Taste Of Love [TVB]

Written by Funn Lim


"If you like Lawrence Ng, watch this series and you'll love him. One of the best and well acted as a cast of a series that I have seen this year and highly entertaining as well."



SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS!



Cantonese Title
Mei Mei Ching Yuen (direct translation and please don't laugh..."A Delicious Love Affair"..yummy)

No. Of Episodes
25 episodes

Character-Cast
Ha Tau (Kong Seong Yau) - Raymond Lam Fung
Joyce Kiew Fa Chi - Flora Chan Wai San
Ma Yau - Lawrence Ng
So Mei (Sue) - Joyce Tang
Gordon Lung Chi San - Joe Ma Tak Chung
Kuk - Suet Lei
Candy - Miriam Yeung
Esther - Winnie Yeung
Fan Si - Tang Siu Juen
Misc - Wong Wai, Ma Tai Lou, Liu Kai Chi, Hillary Tsui Ho Ying, Jojo Zhou, etc

Basic Description
Relationships, cooking, food, jealousy and unrequited love.

Plot Summarized
You can read Seagull's review for a more in-depth plot analysis. I will provide for a brief summary. Be warned...spoilers galore...spoilers galore...spoilers galore...

Ok. The plot. Let's begin with the Hundred Miles Seafood Restaurant in Lamma Island.

There was once this famous chef who owned a famous restaurant named Hundred Miles Seafood Restaurant famous for it's 3 dishes. This owner named Kong Yew Chu was happily married to a happy go lucky descendant of the Chinese medicinal family named Kuk and they both had a son named Ha Tau. Unknown to the wife and son, this man once had an affair with a woman many many years before the birth of the son (maybe not so many years but since Flora is the lead, I logically deduced her character must be at least 10 years older though if we look at her mannerism, I might say just 2 years or so) and they had a daughter named Kiew Fa Chi, or Joyce. She didn't follow her father's family name. Years later this man died and left his beloved restaurant which is no longer as famous as it was years before to his irresponsible but talented son, Ha Tau. Later the workers of the restaurant as well Kuk and Ha Tau found out 50% of the shares was bequeathed to a girl named Joyce Kiew, who refused to reveal that she was actually Kong Yew Chu's daughter, she called herself a creditor who now owns the restaurant by 50%. Ha Tau was determined to sell the restaurant so that he could run off onto his beloved boat and explore the world. But Joyce was determined to save the restaurant, and enlisted the help of a very talented but temperamental chef, Ma Yau who felt indebted to Mr Kong's kindness, agreed to help her after much persuasion. The business began to pick up and Ha Tau who had feelings for Joyce began to learn the tools of the trade. But when he found out she was his sister, he went back to who he was before and acted rather childishly. But Joyce never gave up on her brother, Ma Yau, the lazy workers and the business. After much hardship, they all stood united and the restaurant became famous again. But then the worst began to happen.

One day, a waitress who worked for Jade Corporation began a relationship with a the Executive Chef of Jade chain of restaurants, Gordon. Gordon was obviously smitten by her individuality but later the ugly truth began to surface. Sue was once Ma Yau girlfriend and they were so serious, they were almost married, but Sue's ex-boyfriend who was jealous of their relationship told Ma Yau a white lie and Sue never saw Ma Yau again. Never knowing what really happened, she began on a journey of self destruction but 2 years later her wound, though still deep but she was beginning to let go of her love for Ma Yau by loving Gordon. But she never really loved Gordon because one day she bumped into Ma Yau and she found out that their relationship ended because of one silly lie. She began to feel tortured and at last realised she loved Ma Yau more. She went back to Ma Yau and Ma Yau accepted her back because he found out she suffered too much when he left her without any explanation. That meant his relationship with Joyce which was in early stage of formation was halted and Joyce quietly went back to pretending nothing ever happened, though everybody knew Ma Yau and Joyce were in love. Ha Tau was the one who felt his sister was cheated and angrily left the restaurant and his sifu, Ma Yau and went to work for Jade Restaurant on the recommendation of a girl named Candy. In that environment, he realised Gordon had a personal vendetta against Ma Yau and did all he could to humiliate Ma Yau. When Sue finally realised Ma Yau loved Joyce and not her, she was the one who said they should separate but she met with an accident along the way. Gordon thought she attempted suicide and blamed Ma Yau. Ma Yau and Joyce both feeling guilty drifted further apart and Joyce fired Ma Yau and he left the restaurant. But Gordon declared war against Ma Yau and aimed to destroy the very one thing Ma Yau treasured; the Hundred Miles Seafood Restaurant. Ma Yau tried all her could to prevent the destruction of the restaurant because of his love for Joyce and Joyce did all she could because of her love for her family business but to no avail. The restaurant will be closed and Gordon's plan succeeded. Joyce left to travel the world, Ha Tau left to see the world and Ma Yau became a hawker.

And then Sue woke up from her coma.

What will Gordon do? Will Joyce and Ma Yau be reunited and will the Hundred Miles Seafood Restaurant ever open to business again?

Well, I will reveal the ending, but not now.

Q & A
My reviews are never short so I won't break with my tradition of being long winded. Anything about the plot not revealed above will be revealed below.

Where is Miriam Yeung, and Hilary Tsui, and Winnie Yeung, and Suet Lei???
Miriam is Candy, a young rich girl who aspires to be a singer but rich daddy wants her to learn business. By the way her daddy is the CEO of Jade Corporation. She sees Gordon as her big brother and mentor and Gordon sees her as his little sister, always looking out for her best interest. But when daddy said no to her singing career, she ran away to Lamma Island. After a few misunderstanding with Ha Tau, Ma Yau took her under his wing and treated her like his own sister, and we see the softer side of Ma Yau every time he talks to Candy. She works in the restaurant to earn money to release an album and in there, she met her friends and fell in love with Ha Tau. Later her father had a stroke (not because she induced it but because of natural causes) and she decided to let go of her singing career and take care of the family business.

Hilary Tsui plays a girl whose name I can's remember. She is Ha Tau's best friend and is secretly in love with Ha Tau though he only sees her as a "brother". She owns a rival seafood restaurant in Lamma Island though there isn't mush rivalry in business between Ha Tau and her because well, they're both best buddies. Later when she found out Ha Tau loved Candy, she was heart broken but decided friendship is stronger than jealousy or love and so she returned to her old happy go lucky self.

Suet Lei plays Kuk, Ha Tau's mom. She hates mistresses and men who have mistresses. To her Yew Chu was the perfect husband, but when she found out Joyce was Yew Chu's daughter, she became angry and showed her jealousy in front of Joyce. However, she realised Joyce is a nice girl, and is there to help the restaurant with a sincere determination. She accepts Joyce as her daughter.

Winnie Yeung plays Esther, a PR with Jade Corporation who has the hots for Gordon but obviously, he feels nothing for her. She is the happy go lucky type who knows a lot but doesn't reveal much. Nothing much with this character actually, except that she lives with Sue and is bet of friends with Sue and Joyce. By the way, Joyce and Sue are friends as well, even before the Ma Yau incident.

How on earth Ha Tau found out about Joyce being his sister?
Actually Ma Yau knows about the truth first when he overheard a conversation between Esther and Joyce and she realised why Joyce never gave up on Ha Tau. At this time, Ha Tau was having this crush on Joyce who has always treated him with utmost respect. During one night both were drunk after a happy celebration at the restaurant and the workers who knew Ha Tau liked Joyce put them together into one room. Ma Yau found out about this and quickly rushed home to stop any incestuous act. Luckily Joyce who was quite drunk then heard Ha Tau mumbling about liking Joyce and she quickly left the room and sat on the sofa and began to think what she should do. Ma Yau came and they both talked. That was when Ha Tau overheard the truth and so did everybody else who was standing near the door to the dormitory. By the next morning, Ha Tau felt so embarrassed that he ran away and said hurtful things to Joyce, not wanting to believe that his father had a mistress. At the end of the day he realised Joyce was truly wonderful as a sister and felt so guilty for the hurtful things he said begged for her to stay when Joyce told everybody he was leaving. The truth was she was leaving for HK and will be back tomorrow morning, since she stayed in HK and worked in Lamma Island. Everything was ok, and only Kuk didn't know.

How on earth Kuk Found out?
She was at Joyce's apartment in HK and there was fire. They ran out and Joyce took her beloved possessions, some of which were her school's exam reports. They flipped through it and Kuk saw the one picture Joyce didn't want her to see; her father with her mum and Joyce as a young girl. Kuk who knew Joyce was the product of an affair between a married man and a mistress (she didn't know who though) became very angry and immediately left. Of course she later accepted Joyce as her daughter/

Why Joyce was so determined to save the restaurant?
She realised her father gave her the restaurant so that she could make it better and so that she could safeguard it until Ha Tau was ready and mature enough to take over the business. She fearlessly protects her brother and encourages him to learn from Ma Yau because she knew Ha Tau was very talented but not very motivated. All her life her father spent very little time with her since he didn't see much of her. His life was centred around his only son. To her, perhaps taking care of the business and her brother was something her father had wanted her to do and she felt a bit of familial love when she was in the restaurant. And so why she was so determined to save the restaurant? Because of her father and his legacy.

Why Ma Yau agreed to work for Hundred Miles Seafood Restaurant?
First of all, Ma Yau agreed to work for Joyce, not the restaurant. Not that he was touched by her sincerity. This Ma Yau was an egoistical, obnoxious and arrogant man who knew a lot about food and cooking but very little on communication between human beings. He wasn't particularly warm and friendly, in fact he was downright rude and cold to everybody else, except Candy, Joyce and Sue. But this was a man who knows what gratitude meant.

When he was a little boy, he was starving and he was soaking wet in the heavy rain. A chef took pity on him and cooked for him the best fried rice he ever tasted and because of this one friend rice and that man's kindness, he had the will to go on and he later learned from the King of Chefs, together with Gordon (who was Ma Yau's "brother" of the same sifu). That man who showed him such kindness was Kong Yew Chu. By the way, Kong Yew Chu was never his sifu. It was another chef.

How come Joyce fell for Ma Yau and vice versa?
Probably because Ma Yau was the only one old enough, decent looking enough and the only one eligible bachelor? Nahhhhh....she admired him. Period.

Why Ma Yau loved her is even simpler. She was really nice to him, really sweet and always very polite and encouraging. She never once belittled him or ever distrusted him. In her, Ma Yau perhaps became even softer, relaxed a bit more and even kicked his smoking habit.

So how come there was a So Mei?
Ahhh...that pest. You see, they were once very close and then ex-bf showed Ma Yau some intimate photos (here I must say this...they were just photos of a guy and a girl, nothing sordid or illegal) between him and So Mei and Ma Yau thought she was two timing her. Heart broken he left without demanding for an explanation. So Mei never looked for him to ask the all important question; "Oi! Idiot! What happened?? Where were you??"

Never.

Then how come So Mei came back?
So Mei was seeing Gordon and Gordon wanted to challenge Ma Yau and become the best chef. You see, sifu once told Gordon that his technique as a chef is meticulous and perfect but he lacked what Ma Yau has; real talent. So he wanted to defeat Ma Yau. So Mei then knew Ma Yau and Gordon were "brothers" of the same sifu. Gordon happily went to the competition but So Mei didn't want to go. On the day of the competition, she told him she loved Ma Yau. Ma Yau by that time has seen So Mei again and knew that she has a tendency to over eat until the brink of death, which was what she went through 2 years before when Ma Yau left without any word. So he can't possibly reject her without hurting her. Moreover, So Mei was so convinced Ma Yau still loved her. Which was why Ma Yau decided to cook a So Mei dish which he invented 2 years before in the name of So Mei instead of the dish he had invented together with Joyce. That pisses Ha Tau and more so when they lost. Gordon was the King of Chefs but he wasn't happy. Ha Tau wasn't happy, Joyce wasn't happy, Sue was very happy, thinking by cooking that So Mei dish Ma Yau was telling her that they could give their relationship another try but the truth was, Ma Yau was miserable.

So how come So Mei fell into a coma?
Gordon was destroying the restaurant by proposing that the Jade Corporation's latest billion dollar project named Seafood village be built at Lamma Island, and so all restaurants, shops and business along a specific road must be bought over. Interestingly, Hundred Miles was situated right smack on that road and even more interesting, decades of business and they never really owned that piece of land that the restaurant was situated on. The owner decided to sell his land to Jade Corp and so the business must be closed. So Mei at that time was spending every waking hours with Ma Yau but one night, she saw Ma Yau hugging Joyce and telling her he couldn't let go of her and he would stay to fight on in keeping the restaurant with Joyce. Ma Yau was willing to let go of a golden opportunity to work in France when Joyce was begging him to leave. So Mei was upset, understandably so and cried in front of Gordon. Later she went to the airport pretending nothing had ever happened to wait for Ma Yau and Ma Yau arrived. Before he could say anything, she realised she can't force love. And so she proposed that they separate. Ma Yau went home to Joyce and told her what Sue told him and then Joyce received a phone call. Sue met with an accident and was in a coma. Gordon sincerely thought she wanted to kill herself and so did everybody else. Because of this Gordon was determined to destroy Ma Yau and the best way to hurt him is to hurt Joyce which means he must destroy the restaurant. Candy at the end lost her respect for Gordon and ignored him. Gordon began to feel guilty and when Sue woke up to tell everybody the truth, Gordon realised he was wrong but he couldn't say those three hardest words to say for a man with pride; I am sorry. This went on for 2 years and by that time Joyce had already left to travel the world and Ha Tau has already left with Ma Yau's sifu to see the world.

So happy ending?
Yes, very happy ending. For one I am very glad Gordon didn't end up with Sue (again).

2 years later, Ma Yau was a hawker. He and Gordon patched things up again and became like brothers they once were thanks to their sifu who insisted that they cook something together and their sifu yelled at them that why can't they be like they were? Why can't they just talk? Why fight over money, fame and women when they could just cook a dish and eat until the anger is over? Gordon realised at the end of the day he wanted to be a chef, not fame not money but the joy of cooking. And so he quit his high paying job and works in a small restaurant, finding himself again as a chef. So Mei opened a flower shop and was her happy self again, and became good friends with Gordon and Ma Yau. Ma Yau was told by Gordon that the plan to create Seafood Village was scrapped off and so Gordon gave the restaurant back to Ma Yau who immediately went looking for the former employees and reopened the business. Ha Tau came back and basically, well...he came back and he will propose to Candy who has been waiting for him for 2 years. As for Joyce, she became a famous food critic named Chi Mei and reunited with Ma Yau again.

THE END.

My Comments
Many months before, there was a request that I write a review for this series but I didn't because I never watched this series. The reason was simple. Lawrence Ng, Flora Chan and an unknown named Raymond Lam didn't sound altogether appealing to me. Then I watched this on ASTRO and well.....it was free but I would have happily paid for the video rental fee if I had known it was such an entertaining series.

First of all, I must compliment the script writer for giving us such strong characterisation of characters. Each is an individual in his/her own right and each is given ample time to develop as a character in terms of personality and individualism. In terms of the relationships, characters and emotions, I must say this series is top notch and definitely a cut above A Step Into The Past, more so in the relationship between a master and his student. You could clearly see a teacher-student relationship in here, full of witty and sarcastic exchanges between Ma Yau and Ha Tau. You can see plenty of personalities and plenty of strong characters, from the ke-le-fe to the leads. All clearly mapped out. For an example, the character of Ma Yau. Truly despicable and yet not quite so and this series will back up the reason for each character's actions with some really good reasons. We might see Sue was someone strong and always laughing but actually deep down she is a very tortured woman, because of love and at the end we see what a mess she has become all because of her love for Ma Yau. Really excellent depiction of human emotions for all of the characters, and everybody has a chance to tell a bit of their story, though the leads may have more time to develop on their characters, I do think all the characters in here have distinct personalities that one could clearly see.

Secondly, the food. I am convinced, so very convinced every time Ma Yau talked about why certain food is so and so because all were very logical.

Finally, the simplicity of the storyline. You have someone you could hate, one you could pity, one you could cheer, one you could cry for....this is actually a drama about relationships but very little on the action sequence. For one, we won't get car chase scenes or some over the top emotional scene like someone dying unexpectedly but you could feel that anger in you every time that So Mei comes into the picture.

I wouldn't say the story was perfect. Same old formula with a really uninteresting ending which was rather rushed though the story closes itself nicely. We have some illogical stuff which I will reveal later. But some scenes stood out as the best;

Best Scenes
The relationship between Ha Tau and Ma Yau, Ma Yau and Joyce, Joyce and fellow employees and Kuk and also the relationship between Ha Tau and Candy. Individually they are not very interesting to watch but put them all into one scene or as pairs, you will see some amazing stories. I especially like the relationship between Ha Tau and Ma Yau, a relationship between a sifu and his student. Ma Yau calls Ha Tau "immature" whilst Ha Tau calls Ma Yau "heartless and wimpy". They don't like each other but they recognised each other's talent. I find their relationship so very real and so very humorous at times.

When Sue was coming over to the restaurant, look at how Ha Tau treated her. Rude but I would have done the same as he did but I don't have his guts.

Best Dialogues
The scene where Ha Tau wanted to fire Ma Yau and Joyce couldn't do it because she promised that Ma Yau will be in charge of the kitchen and the administration of the restaurant and so Joyce can't fire Ma Yau if he did nothing wrong. So Joyce told Ha Tau the best advice;

"You can learn from him, learn everything and then you can kick him out of the restaurant."

Very true don't you think? Ha Tau of course said yes, but half heartedly.

Any exchanges between Ha Tau and Ma Yau, with Ma Yau's infamous "Get out of my kitchen" and Ha Tau's "Ok, if you say so" and then Joyce would be the one to run after Ha Tau to beg him to come back.

And many more of course.

Worst Aspect
Every time the themesong is played. Like many many many times in this series until I am so sick of it. It wasn't even a good song and was badly sung by Miriam Yeung but hearing them again and again and again made me numb in my brain.

The ending was a bit rushed. I wouldn't mind an episode more to nicely close the chapter to the relationship between Joyce and Ma Yau.

Favourite Character
I quite like Joyce who is soft spoken and often bullied by her employees, Ma Yau included. But I don't like the way she handled the situation with Sue's coma. When she fired Ma Yau, I thought she shouldn't have done that. That isn't very nice, but Ma Yau was gentleman enough to simply walk away without a scream or fight. Of course Joyce felt guilty for what happened to Sue but frankly, that doesn't mean poor Ma Yau should be thrown aside, considering what he had done for the restaurant, he deserved a better farewell notice.

I quite like Gordon at first but when he became jealous of Ma Yau, I thought well understandable but when he plotted for the downfall of Hundred Miles Restaurant, that was when I agreed with what Candy said of him;

"What happened to you? What's wrong with you? You used to teach me good things and now...you used to be a gentleman...."

Ha Tau is not my favourite character though he is one character who is honest in the way he expresses himself and probably the only one who could think clearly amidst all the mess that Sue created, although he may be immature and sometimes irritating when things doesn't go his way. he is after all just a young man.

So my vote would be Ma Yau. I hated him at first but I thought this guy has got character. But when he mellowed down a bit and seeing the way he treated Candy, I thought this guy is actually a nice guy, but was an angry man because of the supposed betrayal by So Mei (Sue) 2 years before. Ha Tau called him wimpy, perhaps it's true since he obviously loved Joyce and yet he went with So Mei, for very good reasons of course. Definitely Ma Yau who takes his time to reveal to us his true nice self by slowly peeling away one layer at a time, the masks he was wearing to hide his true self and his pain. And ever notice this; he was so talented and yet he never fully realised his full talent, since he worked for small restaurants and even became a hawker. He certainly has an attitude problem which makes him a hot tempered and temperamental employee. But I still like him.

Most Hated Character
I so hate this character. So Mei or Sue. I can't understand why on earth Gordon loved her as much as he did. She seemed so pretentious when she was with Gordon and so desperate when she was with Ma Yau, especially the way she clung to him when Joyce was around. And even when she was in a coma, she could create havoc in people's life. She had the wonderful Gordon and yet she couldn't treasure that relationship because she felt that she was cheated of Ma Yau. That they both parted ways for trivial reasons. The reason why they could easily part perhaps as Ma Yau said; "Our foundation wasn't very strong". Even when Ma Yau repeatedly told her to forget the past and move on, this woman will cry, scream, cajole and practically crawl her way back to Ma Yau and in the process hurting Gordon, hurting Joyce and making Ma Yau a miserable man. Notwithstanding the fact that Gordon was ready to leave his high paying job and a great big promotion so that he could leave HK with her (she wanted to run away from Ma Yau at first, actually her way of dealing with things is either pretending nothing ever happened or to run and avoid the problem) and that Ma Yau was reluctant to accept the job offer in France (where she herself told everybody at Hundred Miles that Ma Yau has accepted the job offer), this woman still could not be satisfied or clear headed enough to see the real truth.

Perhaps I should rephrase that.

She knew Ma Yau loved Joyce but she pretended nothing ever happened. This is called lying to one self and in the end, she hurts only herself. I really really hate this woman.

Most Boring Character
Esther. Somebody please tell her to just shut up. She talks on and on and on and on....boring woman, no wonder Gordon looked at Sue rather than her.

Most Unbelievable Scenarios
Sue is a waitress. I assume Esther leads a comfortable life. But their apartment is way too big.

And Sue wanted to emigrate to another country. She is just a WAITRESS. Let's look at this practically. Even Stephen Chow with his millions and millions of dollars couldn't migrate to Canada, more so a waitress?! Come on, let's be logical. TVB always makes migrating to a country so easy. Hey! I may not even get a visa to visit USA more so migrate anywhere!

The way Joyce became a food critic. Ma Yau certainly taught her a lot but somehow, TVB makes changing jobs so easy. She so easily leave her kindergarten teaching job to run a restaurant and traveled 2 years and she became a famous food critic. So simple but not quite so in real life. You can of course run after your dreams but reality is, it's not that easy as depicted by TVB.

They were in a competition. Joyce was helping Ma Yau. See something wrong in this picture? What is Joyce doing in a cooking competition when she can't even cook right? Why not ask Fan Si, the assistant to assist? Why Joyce? Ahhhh.. to create the obligatory tension between the two of them. Lousy reason though.

Funniest Scene
One woman ate Ma Yau's food and she said his food was very delicious but lacked something.

"Lacks what?", asked Ma Yau.

And the lady answered in the most serious tone; "Compassion".

I was laughing so hard. Hmmm...how do you cook compassion? Clean a beggar and cook at the same time? Cry and cook at the same time? Hmmmmmmm....

Well she explained herself of course. She likes going to Hundred Miles every year not because the food is magnificent but because she likes the people in the restaurant whom she sees has known for years and they're all very close. So the food lacks closeness between individuals... Hmmm....still can't see how Ma Yau could cook a food like that!!

Classic response.

The Performances Evaluated
Not one excellent performance in here though I am very surprised by how some did so well.

Raymond Lam
First series I think and definitely over acted in some scenes, like really emotional. But his character, Ha Tau is very young and so very reckless and emotional. I thought he was such a joy to watch and he did a great job in conveying Ha Tau's stubbornness and immaturity.

Miriam Yeung
Never thought I could like her but I like her Candy. Her performance has certainly improved but I would have wished she had taken some speech lessons. Half the time she was mumbling her lines or talking with a mouth full of saliva, really lazy type of speech. But she was quite effective as the determined Candy and she looks good with Raymond Lam. They also have my vote for the Best Couple award because they were so very cute together.

Winnie Yeung
Some said she improved a lot, as Esther. I thought her performance as Esther was so pretentious and mediocre. I would have wanted to shut her up because as Esther, she talks too much. I don't like her performance which seems to cartoonish, too false and too happy go lucky-ish. Not one shred of jealousy when she realised Gordon loved Sue. Not even one hint. Such a nice person. I would have liked it if she feels something, like a bit of jealousy. So this character is not human at all and I feel Winnie Yeung made her even more unbelievable. And too preachy as well.

Suet Lei
Never liked her as an actress and in here, luckily she had little screen time and so I can stand her as Kuk, a happy go lucky woman who likes her son, shies away from responsibilities most of the time.

Joyce Tang
I hated her character but I thought she did well in conveying the insecurities of Sue, whom I loved to smack. I do think her character is a bit too fake but then since Sue never loved Gordon, I could believe those fake qualities, the pretentiousness of Sue as logical and believable. But frankly, she has little chemistry with Lawrence Ng. Looks forced but she certainly looks good with Joe Ma. They would have my vote as the Best Looking Couple.

Joe Ma
A very good performance. Nothing much to say except, he was very good. I never saw him as a villain, and his Gordon is a nice guy who misunderstood the whole situation at the end of the day. I don't hate his Gordon, in fact I pitied Gordon. He certainly deserved someone much better than that emotional wreck named Sue.

Flora Chan
Frankly, I thought she was a miscast. First of all, her Cantonese is a bit off. Second of all, she is playing someone whom I suspect is very young, naive, soft spoken and innocent and yet Flora has the face of a career woman, a strong woman and please forgive my language, a b***h, like the one in Healing Hands and Mr Diana (Feminine Masculinity). I can never buy her as someone who is young and soft spoken. The truth is she did her best in here, and gave one of her finest performance in her career, and she certainly looks pretty and sometimes young. But I wouldn't say she gave the best of all the performances by a female in this series because she was really horrible in the scene where she was crying and begging Ma Yau to accept the job offer in France. She over acted in that scene and it reminded me of her over the top crying scene from ATE which was such an embarrassing scene to watch. She certainly improved but I can't quite see her character as someone really young, and so when she acts really young and looks so mature, my only conclusion or my impression of Joyce Kiew Fa Chi as a person is that she is a bit of a featherweight in the brains department. At the end of the day, I like her Joyce, but I feel a younger looking actress or at least a more innocent looking actress would have made Kiew Fa Chi as more believable character to watch. With Flora Chan in this character, you would have to ignore many obvious facts and just stretch the limit of your imagination.

Hilary Tsui Ho Ying
Bland performance and nothing great with her performance. In fact, the worst performance. If I go on any further commenting about her performance, I am afraid I might offend her fans. Just let me put it this way; she was a eyesore not just in looks department but in her interpretation of the character she was playing. The 3 Bs would apply to her; Boring, Bland & Blahhhhhhh.

Lawrence Ng
I have been asked, quite often whether I am a fan of a certain actor or actress and if yes, how I could criticise them in certain series and yet praise them in the next. This is why. I do not believe in blind devotion. Some actors have their ups and downs, I'll criticise when I think they didn't do good enough and I'll praise if I think they did well. I don't care if they're my favourite whatever. To me, I rather look at the performance rather than the person, which is why I am often accused of biasness when I praise those I like and yet accused of being disloyal when I criticised the very same person I have praised many many times. It's quite hard to make a reader understand my point of view, but do take Lawrence Ng as an example.

Everybody knows that I am not a Lawrence Ng's fan. I have never been his fan even when he was mega famous in Healing Hands or even in later series for example, HSDS 2000, where his performances left much to be desired. You have got to give this guy some credit; he is not afraid of the possibility of making a fool out of himself by acting in a role that many deemed him as unsuitable and he is certainly not afraid to take on roles that has a streak of meanness, as long as at the end of the day the role he had is a good guy, deep down in his heart, guts and lungs.

And so I will have to admit; this guy is a revelation in this series. I do think there must be some truth in this observation; that when an actor plays someone close to the real him, he often does it well. As Ma Yau, Lawrence Ng in my opinion gave his finest performance. I like his Ma Yau who is my favourite character and Lawrence Ng gave such an excellent interpretation of this obnoxious man, I do think in real life Lawrence Ng must be someone arrogant, obnoxious, egoistical but you must take time to really peel away his masks to know the real him. When he snaps back at Ha Tau or the way he looks at Candy with this softness in his eyes, or the guilt he has when looking at Sue or when he looks at Joyce with admiration, respect and love, I do think of him as attractive and he possesses this handsomeness I have never seen in him. I wouldn't say he was flawless in this series as he overacted in some emotional scenes. Certainly he has got his voice acting right and he does have a mesmerizing voice sometimes but take note of his hand movements and body language. He certainly seems unsure as to where to put his hands, where to point, when to move. Ignore all that and just listen to him explain how to cook a certain dish, and he can be so very convincing as a chef. The chemistry he shares with Flora seems lacking at first but look for those stolen glances, those longing stares and of course, those angst looks that he will give Flora as Joyce and vice versa. Put them together into one scene and you could almost see fireworks, well ALMOST. Look for scenes of the way he talks to Miriam as Candy, and you will certainly like his Ma Yau. I could see a difference between his Ma Yau when he was with Joyce Tang's So Mei, his Ma Yau before the appearance of Flora's Joyce and of course, the great big transformation when he realised he loved Flora's Joyce. The sudden changes in his tone, his voice, and the way he looked at everybody. The best performance in this series. And I just realised he didn't wear his glasses in this series, which makes him less educated looking and certainly quite angry and sarcastic looking.

Everybody Else
Even that old man whom I had said can't act did very well in this series because he had little scenes. Everybody has their share of the story in this series and I thought everybody did well, especially Liu ka Chi as the perpetual gambler and Tang Siu Juen as Fan Si. I have always liked Tang Siu Juen as an actor, he may not have the looks but he certainly could act if given an opportunity.

Verdict
A must rent. If you like Lawrence Ng, watch this series and you'll love him. One of the best and well acted as a cast of a series that I have seen this year and highly entertaining as well.

Rating
N/A


Most Interesting Names
All the names have something to do with food.

So Mei - fish
Ma Yau -fish ( I had Ma Yau for lunch earlier!!)
Ha Tau - Shrimp Head
Kong Yew Chu - scallop (could also be dried scallop, definitely not shark fins)
Lung Chi San - I guess some superior part of an animal or something
Tim - Candy
Fan Si - noodles (you know, "Eat Fan Si like it is shark fins?")

Share:

Labels, Archive and the usual sidebar contents are at the bottom of this page.